Skip to content

Inconsistency between PGN data and the data on the site. #9

Closed
@salvador-dali

Description

@salvador-dali

Here is an example from lichess_db_standard_rated_2015-03.pgn.

One of the PGNs I am getting from this file looks in the following way:

[Event "Rated Classical game"]
[Site "https://lichess.org/cclZlRwO"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "gunsti"]
[Black "azuaga"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[UTCDate "2015.03.05"]
[UTCTime "23:09:12"]
[WhiteElo "1572"]
[BlackElo "1631"]
[WhiteRatingDiff "+2"]
[BlackRatingDiff "-2"]
[ECO "B30"]
[Opening "Sicilian Defense: Nyezhmetdinov-Rossolimo Attack"]
[TimeControl "360+10"]
[Termination "Normal"]

1. e4 { [%eval 0.17] } 1... c5 { [%eval 0.27] } 2. Nf3 { [%eval 0.27] } 2... Nc6 { [%eval 0.32] } 3. Bb5 { [%eval 0.45] } 3... e6 { [%eval 0.39] } 4. Nc3 { [%eval 0.26] } 4... a6 { [%eval 0.48] } 5. Bxc6 { [%eval 0.42] } 5... bxc6 { [%eval 0.41] } 6. e5 { [%eval 0.41] } 6... g6 $4 { [%eval #3] } 7. d4 $4 { [%eval 0.55] } 7... cxd4 { [%eval 0.74] } 8. Qxd4 { [%eval 0.7] } 8... Bg7 { [%eval 0.84] } 9. O-O { [%eval 0.63] } 9... Qc7 $2 { [%eval 2.18] } 10. Bf4 $2 { [%eval 0.62] } 10... Ne7 $6 { [%eval 1.38] } 11. Rad1 $6 { [%eval 0.48] } 11... Nd5 $6 { [%eval 1.32] } 12. Nxd5 $2 { [%eval 0.15] } 12... cxd5 { [%eval 0.26] } 13. c3 { [%eval 0.2] } 13... Rb8 { [%eval 0.24] } 14. b4 { [%eval 0.09] } 14... a5 { [%eval 0.32] } 15. a3 { [%eval 0.0] } 15... O-O { [%eval 0.33] } 16. Rfe1 { [%eval 0.0] } 16... Ba6 { [%eval 0.22] } 17. Qe3 { [%eval 0.0] } 17... Rbc8 { [%eval 0.13] } 18. Rc1 { [%eval 0.2] } 18... axb4 { [%eval 0.57] } 19. axb4 $6 { [%eval 0.03] } 19... Qc4 { [%eval 0.15] } 20. Bh6 { [%eval 0.08] } 20... Qd3 { [%eval 0.36] } 21. Qg5 $2 { [%eval -0.69] } 21... Qf5 $6 { [%eval 0.29] } 22. Qh4 { [%eval 0.36] } 22... Rc4 $6 { [%eval 1.15] } 23. Nd4 { [%eval 1.12] } 23... Qh5 { [%eval 1.08] } 24. Qxh5 { [%eval 1.18] } 24... gxh5 { [%eval 1.17] } 25. Bxg7 { [%eval 1.06] } 25... Kxg7 { [%eval 1.12] } 26. Re3 $6 { [%eval 0.17] } 26... Kh8 $2 { [%eval 1.73] } 27. Rh3 $6 { [%eval 0.93] } 27... Rfc8 { [%eval 0.74] } 28. Ne2 $2 { [%eval -2.1] } 28... Re4 { [%eval -1.77] } 29. Ng3 { [%eval -1.83] } 29... Rxe5 $2 { [%eval -0.25] } 30. Nxh5 { [%eval -0.26] } 30... Re4 $2 { [%eval 1.91] } 31. Nf6 { [%eval 1.91] } 31... Kg7 { [%eval 1.98] } 32. Nxe4 { [%eval 1.96] } 32... dxe4 { [%eval 1.86] } 33. Re3 $6 { [%eval 1.32] } 33... d5 { [%eval 1.43] } 34. Ra1 $2 { [%eval 0.0] } 34... Bc4 $2 { [%eval 1.34] } 35. h4 { [%eval 1.11] } 35... Bd3 { [%eval 1.18] } 36. Ra3 { [%eval 1.15] } 36... Kg6 { [%eval 1.25] } 37. g3 { [%eval 1.06] } 37... Kh5 { [%eval 1.5] } 38. Kh2 { [%eval 1.06] } 38... Kg6 { [%eval 1.13] } 39. Re1 { [%eval 1.36] } 39... Kf6 { [%eval 1.5] } 40. Kh3 { [%eval 1.39] } 40... Rg8 { [%eval 1.48] } 41. Rb3 { [%eval 1.41] } 41... Bb5 { [%eval 1.51] } 42. Rg1 { [%eval 1.08] } 42... h5 { [%eval 1.34] } 43. g4 $6 { [%eval 0.81] } 43... hxg4+ { [%eval 0.87] } 44. Rxg4 { [%eval 0.8] } 44... Rh8 { [%eval 1.07] } 45. Kg3 { [%eval 0.93] } 45... Ke5 { [%eval 1.18] } 46. Rg5+ { [%eval 1.09] } 46... f5 { [%eval 1.29] } 47. h5 { [%eval 1.36] } 47... Be2 { [%eval 1.6] } 48. Kh4 { [%eval 1.43] } 48... Bb5 { [%eval 1.63] } 49. Rg6 { [%eval 1.27] } 49... Kf4 { [%eval 1.25] } 50. Rxe6 $6 { [%eval 0.47] } 50... Be2 $6 { [%eval 1.07] } 51. Kh3 $4 { [%eval #-3] } 51... Rxh5+ { [%eval #-2] } 52. Kg2 { [%eval #-2] } 52... Rg5+ $6 { [%eval #-4] } 53. Kh2 { [%eval #-4] } 53... Rh5+ { [%eval #-3] } 54. Kg2 { [%eval #-2] } 54... Rg5+ $4 { [%eval -6.61] } 55. Kh2 $4 { [%eval #-6] } 55... Rh5+ $4 { [%eval 0.0] } 56. Kg2 { [%eval #-2] } 1/2-1/2

And the corresponding game from lichess: https://lichess.org/cclZlRwO

Notice that the PGN claims that evaluation of move 6 is mate in 3: 6... g6 $4 { [%eval #3] }. One the other hand the data on lichess looks just fine. There are other less noticeable differences. Like the first move is evaluated as 0.17 in PGN and as 0 on the site (almost every move has differences which can't be due to the rounding errors.

Any idea why this is happening?

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions