Implementation of a MockSpecializedLiftActor and MockLiftActor #1467

merged 3 commits into from Jul 6, 2013

2 participants

Lift Web Framework member

Operating off of the premise of achieving better separation in unit tests, I wanted to implement a MockSpecializedLiftActor and MockLiftActor so that we are able to separate out the testing of if an actor has received a message and the testing of how an actor processes a message. You can read the mailing list discussion if you want the long form explanation and discussion, but below I'm going to demonstrate the goal in code form.

Given a snippet such that:

object MyAwesomeSnippet extends MyAwesomeSnippet {
  // My awesome actor is a singleton LiftActor.
  val myAwesomeActor: LiftActor = MyAwesomeActor
trait MyAwesomeSnippet {
  def myAwesomeActor: LiftActor

  def sendTheActorAMessage {
    myAwesomeActor ! SomeMessage

... I want to test that the actor behind myAwesomeActor gets SomeMessage. Using a real actor, we can't. The mailbox for the actor isn't exposed to us in any way shape or form. So, presently, the only way to check in tests to see if the actor received this message is to check the side-effects of that message being processed (database changes, etc), which isn't very good unit separation.

Ideally, I'd like the ability to write the following test:

"My Awesome Snippet" should {
  "Dispatch the SomeMessage message to the MyAwesomeActor" in {
    val myAwesomeSnippetMock = new MyAwesomeSnippet {
      val myAwesomeActor = new MockLiftActor()


    myAwesomeSnippetMock.myAwesomeActor.messageCount must_== 1
    myAwesomeSnippetMock.myAwesomeActor.hasReceivedMessage_?(SomeMessage) must_== true

By injecting the MockLiftActor into the snippet, I'm able to test that the snippet is sending the message to the actor, without worrying over the details of what the real actor will do with it. (We can let integration tests worry with that, instead.)

@fmpwizard fmpwizard merged commit 6a301fb into master Jul 6, 2013
Lift Web Framework member

rebased to master, thanks!

@fmpwizard fmpwizard deleted the msf_issue_1467 branch Jul 6, 2013
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment