Join GitHub today
GitHub is home to over 28 million developers working together to host and review code, manage projects, and build software together.
Sign upFeature: paginate all comments #394
Comments
jcs
added
the
featurereq
label
Aug 30, 2017
This comment has been minimized.
Show comment
Hide comment
This comment has been minimized.
pushcx
Oct 3, 2017
Member
Adding on this: it's a big enough change that it needs to be discussed on-side in a meta thread, but I think this page should list the users' comments without threads. This page also does double-duty for users looking for replies, so it couldn't change anyways until #218 is done.
There's a number places the site does/should do pagination (homepage, search, user stories, user comments, mod log, newest stories, recent stories, recent comments, probably more I'm forgetting) without consistent UI or stable URLs. I'm open to broadening this issue to a general cleanup of pagination if someone wants to take it on.
|
Adding on this: it's a big enough change that it needs to be discussed on-side in a meta thread, but I think this page should list the users' comments without threads. This page also does double-duty for users looking for replies, so it couldn't change anyways until #218 is done. There's a number places the site does/should do pagination (homepage, search, user stories, user comments, mod log, newest stories, recent stories, recent comments, probably more I'm forgetting) without consistent UI or stable URLs. I'm open to broadening this issue to a general cleanup of pagination if someone wants to take it on. |
This comment has been minimized.
Show comment
Hide comment
This comment has been minimized.
pushcx
May 4, 2018
Member
Also - it would be nice if pages were numbered oldest-to-newest for stable URLs. I've seen bots pages over and over, perhaps because it looks /page/183 is still getting new content... when really it's just old comments being pushed farther back by new stuff.
|
Also - it would be nice if pages were numbered oldest-to-newest for stable URLs. I've seen bots pages over and over, perhaps because it looks |
ngoldbaum commentedAug 28, 2017
Currently it's only possible to see the last month or so of comments on
http://lobste.rs/u/<user>. It would be nice to be able to see older comments as well.