Three of the seven demo apps included:
Live Previews: http://addyosmani.github.com/todomvc/
In many cases it comes down to very subtle differences between these frameworks, so how do you choose exactly?. In my previous posts on structured application development I've attempted to distinguish the pros and cons of such solutions, but when it comes down to the MVC coding style they offer perhaps there's another way these differences can be compared.
You may know that many frameworks now come with their own variation of the 'Todo' example. It's a simple demo that illustrates how models, views and controllers may be used to write a completely functional list-based application.
There's no standard or specification around how the Todo application should be written - indeed, some may ask if a demo app even needs one.
Regardless, this is why although some frameworks will implement the example with similar features and a look/feel consistent with their peers, others will stray away from this quite heavily.
This is an issue because if you're attempting to directly compare how one framework might achieve a task vs another, very disparate implementations make this significantly more difficult to do.
I can't speak for all developers, but after reviewing the feature list on such solutions, my first port of call is usually to look for their Todo app as I find this the quickest way to determine whether I'm going to like using their brand of MVC for structuring my apps. This isn't in any way stating an incapability of determining this from code samples in a frameworks docs, but rather, I prefer to review differences in a complete application. I know that other developers feel the same about this too.
So, I had an idea (which you may or may not find useful):
- Why not create a centralized fork of the various framework Todo examples
- Attempt to make these Todo examples more consistent in features, look and feel
- Add a Todo app for those that are missing one altogether or don't have an officially 'endorsed' implementation.
The initial result of my efforts is TodoMVC - a library of (almost) consistent Todo demo apps for MVC frameworks which include:
- SproutCore 2.0
- KnockoutJS (MVVM)
At the end of the day, I want to make it easier for developers to make a choice between frameworks and this may be just one other source of information about their differences which you may find of assistance.
TodoMVC is built on the efforts of a number of other developers including: Jérôme Gravel-Niquet (who I believe created the first version of this style of Todo app), Justin Meyer, Alex MacCaw, Brandon Aaron, Ashish Sharma, Christoph Burgdorf and Tom Dale.
Q:Framework authors with a Todo example update their versions at regular intervals. Will TodoMVC be integrating the same changes into its versions?
A: Time permitting, yes. I want to ensure that all examples in the collection are up to date and relevant to current releases, otherwise whatever learning benefit might be gained from them goes straight out the door.
A:Good question. Whilst this might be considered at some point, I like the idea of developers having a single pack of examples they can grab and study to decide whether a framework is right for them. I'd explored the option of maintaining forks as submodules however decided against it as changes to the demos that the project might suggest may not always be agreed upon, or seen as necessary by framework authors.
A:I'm currently still deciding whether there would be a great benefit to this. I regularly state that OS solutions should contain both tests and documentation, however, a few developers have suggested there not being a need nor expectation as these are essentially usage examples. If enough people request tests, I'm happy to support them.
A:That's a valid viewpoint. I'm not in any way saying that a consistent, common MVC example is going to take all of the headache out of selecting a framework to use for your project, but if I was looking at these for the first time personally I would find this helpful and I hope there are some developers out there that will feel the same way too.