You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
From HB RequireImport structures.
HB.mixin Record base_m T := { A : T }.
HB.structure Definition base := { T of base_m T }.
HB.mixin Record child1_m T := { C1 : T }.
HB.structure Definition child1 := { T of base T & child1_m T }.
HB.mixin Record child2_m T := { C2 : T }.
HB.structure Definition child2 := { T of base T & child2_m T }.
Axiom ix : Type.
Definition vec T := ix -> T.
Section b.
Variable T : base.type.
HB.instance Definition v_base_m : base_m (vec T) :=
base_m.Build _ (fun _ => A).
End b.
Section c1.
Variable T : child1.type.
HB.instance Definition v_child1_m : child1_m (vec T) :=
child1_m.Build _ (fun _ => C1).
End c1.
Section c2.
Variable T : child2.type.
(* CS lookup for `vec` says yes... but the instance is for a paramter T of different type, kaboom *)
HB.instance Definition v_child2_m : child2_m (vec T) :=
child2_m.Build _ (fun _ => C2).
End c2.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
diff --git a/hb.elpi b/hb.elpi
index 9bb314b..3daff91 100644
--- a/hb.elpi+++ b/hb.elpi@@ -595,15 +595,17 @@ get-canonical-mixins-of T S MSL :- std.do! [
structure-nparams S NParams,
coq.mk-n-holes NParams Holes,
coq.mk-app Sort {std.append Holes [ST]} SortHolesST,
- std.assert-ok! (coq.unify-eq T SortHolesST) "HB: get-canonical-mixins-of: T = sort ST",- % Hum, this unification problem is not super trivial. TODO replace by something simpler- get-constructor S KS,- coq.mk-app (global KS) {std.append Holes [T, C]} KSHolesC,- std.assert-ok! (coq.unify-eq ST KSHolesC) "HB: get-canonical-mixins-of: ST = _ _ C",- C = app Stuff,- std.drop {calc (NParams + 2)} Stuff MIL,- std.map MIL (mixin-srcs T) MSLL,- std.flatten MSLL MSL+ if (coq.unify-eq T SortHolesST ok) (+ % Hum, this unification problem is not super trivial. TODO replace by something simpler+ get-constructor S KS,+ coq.mk-app (global KS) {std.append Holes [T, C]} KSHolesC,+ std.assert-ok! (coq.unify-eq ST KSHolesC) "HB: get-canonical-mixins-of: ST = _ _ C",+ C = app Stuff,+ std.drop {calc (NParams + 2)} Stuff MIL,+ std.map MIL (mixin-srcs T) MSLL,+ std.flatten MSLL MSL+ )+ (MSL = [])
].
pred under-canonical-mixins-of.do! i:term, i:list prop.
The old code just filers looking at the head constant, but this is not sufficient to rule out spurious instances.
Here we tolerate that the sort ? = T unif problem fails, which is the more expensive but correct test IMO.
See: https://coq.zulipchat.com/#narrow/stream/237868-Hierarchy-Builder.20devs.20.26.20users/topic/instance.20family.20bug.3F
Test case:
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: