Can't get timer details from other resource

[MrDadosz]

Describe the bug
You can't check timer details from timer, that was created in other resource. isTimer function is working, but getTimerDetails isn't.

To reproduce

1. create resource "test" with serverside file
2. create resource "test2" with serverside file
3. paste this code inside resource "test" and run it:

function outputSomething()
  outputChatBox("I'm working, you can get my details!")
end
local timer = setTimer(outputSomething, 1000, 0)
setElementData(root, "myTimer", timer)

4. paste this code inside resource "test2" and run it:

local timerIsWorking = isTimer(getElementData(root, "myTimer"))
local timeLeft, amout, executions = getTimerDetails(getElementData(root, "myTimer"))
outputChatBox(tostring(timerIsWorking)..", "..tostring(timeLeft)..", "..tostring(amount)..", "..tostring(executions))

5. resource "test2" will show info on chat:
   true, false, nil, nil

Expected behaviour
You could check timer details even if they're created in other resource.

Version
Server: Ubuntu 14, MTA:SA Server v1.5.6-release-14688
Client: Windows 10, Multi Theft Auto v1.5.6-release-16068.8.014

[Lpsd]

I notice in your "test2" resource, it's returning true for isTimer. With the following code I'm returning false for both isTimer and getTimerDetails

resource 1:

addEvent("onTimerFire", true)

timer = false

function init()
	timer = setTimer(timerFunc, 10000, 0)
end
addEventHandler("onResourceStart", resourceRoot, init)

function timerFunc()
  triggerEvent("onTimerFire", root, timer)
end

resource 2

function checkTimerDetails(timer)
	print(isTimer(timer), toJSON(getTimerDetails(timer)))
end
addEventHandler("onTimerFire", root, checkTimerDetails)

outputs: false [ false ]

[patrikjuvonen]

Is this an old or recent bug?

[MrDadosz]

Sorry, I spent a lot of time figuring out why my script isn't working and I'm wrong about isTimer. Script returns: false, false, nil, nil
You can't use getTimerDetails and isTimer but you can check type of the variable and it returns wrong data.
In the resource where you created timer it returns lua-timer02000288. In other resource when you're using getElementType on the timer it returns userdata02000288.
In my opinion you should be able to check if variable is a timer and get details from it etc. or update info about it on wiki:

https://wiki.multitheftauto.com/wiki/Timer
"Also timers are not under the resource hierarchy, because they are not elements, for instance, if you create a timer, it will not be destroyed when the resource in which it was created is stopped, so in this case you should kill the timer manually." - stopping the resource kills the timer (or you can't access it from other resources).

resources.zip
Same resource: true, -5, nil, 1000, lua-timer02000288 - everything is okay
Other resource: false, false, nil, nil, userdata02000288 - shows timer as userdata, can't check if it's a timer and can't get details of it.

[moon91210]

I can confirm isTimer and isElement both return false on a timer from another resource.
The timer is passed through an exported function. You can't destroy it or interact with it at all.
It's a real bummer cause I have this system in my gamemode where it destroys elements from certain resources.

[FileEX]

Fixed in c3a1ddf