Join GitHub today
GitHub is home to over 40 million developers working together to host and review code, manage projects, and build software together.Sign up
Comments within a federated share should be made visible to all federated parties #2197
In the context of a (federated) share, we consider comments as a valuable means of communication and hence an essential part of the collaboration effort.
While we appreciate use cases where tags are being contained to the server where they are initially created and stored, we deem it appropriate to make comments within a federated share available to all parties having access to that share.
Steps to reproduce
Parties with access to shareX (i.e. both UserA and UserB) should see all comments in this share's realm.
UserA only sees his/her own shareX comments (stored on ServerA), UserB only sees his/her own shareX comments (stored on ServerB).
Nextcloud version: 10.0.1
Workflow proposal :
We had this discussion some time ago, that sometimes you want to have comments available to any recipients, but sometimes only internal (e.g. when sharing to a partner or customer while having comments with sensitive content). I don't think we had a good idea to solve this back then.