Skip to content

IDependencyResolver changes for MVC4 RC #2

wants to merge 4 commits into from

4 participants



I took a shot at making the required changes to get this to work with the MVC4 RC changes to IDependencyResolver. The main changes that I made were based on the following:

Blog Post & Comments:
Source code from blog post:

I also updated the SampleApplication to be an MVC4 RC website. Finally, I did the work in the VS 2012 RC, so the Solution and Projects were upgraded, but they are backwards compatible with VS 2010.

Let me know if you have any suggestions or questions.



BeginScope can also just return this since the NinjectDependencyResolver itself already inherits Ninject Scope and has a reference to the kernel already.

I just made this change and added the commit to the pull request. Thanks for pointing this out.

@paigecook paigecook Begin scope can just return this, since NinjectDependencyResolver alr…
…eady inherits NinjectScope and has a refernce to the kernel already
jacobe commented Jun 18, 2012

I actually don't think BeginScope should return this - please see my version here:
I wanted the NinjectResolver to be disposed but not the NinjectScope.


@jacobe I do not see any difference in returning a new NinjectScope or this, since as @StephenHead pointed out, NinjectResolver already inherits from NinjectScope... It is due to the ability to Dispose of the _kernel.

jacobe commented Jun 19, 2012

@paigecook Yep - you're right. The only difference of matter is to make sure _kernel is disposed.


@jacobe Actually I now see that the Dispose method on NinjectScope is marked as virtual as well. Sorry I missed that yesterday. Making your suggested change breaks functionality, because we are back to Disposing the entire _kernel as the NinjectResolver is disposed after each use and since _kernel is a reference to the actual Kernel object created in the Application Start, we effectively throw the whole thing away if we do this... Again this is a case where letting ASP.NET try to manage the per-request scoping will not work, because Ninject already handles that for us. If you pull my fork, make your changes and run the SampleApplication navigating to the /api/values url, you will see the error.

Ninject member

Added support for MVC4 final in c0b1a97

@remogloor remogloor closed this Jan 8, 2013
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Something went wrong with that request. Please try again.