diff --git a/test/tests/outputs/csv/tests b/test/tests/outputs/csv/tests
index 7521720557ea..6c987c27a569 100644
--- a/test/tests/outputs/csv/tests
+++ b/test/tests/outputs/csv/tests
@@ -110,7 +110,20 @@
     input = 'csv.i'
     cli_args = 'Outputs/csv/execute_postprocessors_on=FINAL'
     expect_err = "The parameters 'execute_postprocessors_on', 'execute_scalars_on', and 'execute_reporters_on' must be the same for CSV output"
-    requirement = "The system shall report an error if post-processors and scalar variables have different output frequency."
+    requirement = "The system shall report an error if post-processors and scalar variables have different CSV output frequency."
+    issues = "#25211"
+  []
+  [pp_reporter_execute_on_mismatch]
+    type = RunException
+    input = 'csv.i'
+    cli_args = "
+      Reporters/reporter/type=ConstantReporter
+      Reporters/reporter/integer_names='value1'
+      Reporters/reporter/integer_values='5'
+      Outputs/csv/execute_scalars_on='NONE'
+      Outputs/csv/execute_reporters_on='FINAL'"
+    expect_err = "The parameters 'execute_postprocessors_on', 'execute_scalars_on', and 'execute_reporters_on' must be the same for CSV output"
+    requirement = "The system shall report an error if post-processors and reporters have different CSV output frequency."
     issues = "#25211"
   []
 []