Join GitHub today
GitHub is home to over 31 million developers working together to host and review code, manage projects, and build software together.Sign up
`is_fixed_type` does not take account of nested aliases #6331
Original bug ID: 6331
and probably more concerning
Comment author: @garrigue
Actually, the problem is rather that the distinction between private abbreviations and private row types is made on a purely syntactic, and you get an error if the system guessed wrong. I agree that the guessing could be improved: in your example the object type has syntactically no row variable, so both cases should succeed; symmetrically, having several aliases should not change the behavior (but I'm not sure why one would want to pile up aliases in this way).
Another approach would be to do it more semantically: produce a private row type if the type has an unbound row, independently of the syntax. The problem is that it might behave in unexpected ways: a type that syntactically it looks like a private row type could end up generating a private abbreviation.