Join GitHub today
GitHub is home to over 40 million developers working together to host and review code, manage projects, and build software together.Sign up
OKD project state and relation to OpenShift #26
I am deeply confused by the current state of OKD project. Until release of version 4, I thought that OpenShift was developed in an open source process typical for Red Hat - i.e. that OKD was the upstream project where development work was done and OpenShift Container Platform was the supported version, based on OKD code.
However, something has changed along with the release of OpenShift 4. I don't understand what is the current relation between OpenShift and OKD. There was no official OKD release for version 4, despite OpenShift already being at version 4.2. The OKD web page suggests that latest release was 3.11.
Could you please explain what is the current development model for OpenShift, and the relation between OKD and OpenShift?
Right, in OCP/OKD 4 things are bit more complicated.
So both OCP4 and OKD4 Preview are open source products -
Note, that one component doesn't have a commit URL - its
This brings us to the difference between OCP4 and OKD4 - the base OS. In OKD4 we use Fedora CoreOS instead of RHEL CoreOS (however it can be any rpm-ostree based system driven by Ignition). There are quite a few changes between these, most important would be Ignition version 2 in FCOS instead of Ignition 0.33 in RHCOS. This change has forced us to temporarily fork installer and machine-config-daemon.
Most components - for instance console - are built using Red Hat UBI 7, so this image can be used on both OCP4 and OKD4 without any rebuild (previously OKD images were centos and were rebuilt using RHEL before appearing in OCP4). Machine-os-content in OKD is being built from FCOS (in OCP its being built from RHCOS). The releases, CI and other infra parts are the same for both. So the best term we have for OKD4 and OCP4 are "sibling distributions".
OKD4 is currently in Preview mode since CI and release controller jobs are not yet fully setup - and installer doesn't support as many platforms as OCP4.
Thank you for the thorough explanation. I believe posting an article about this on developer.redhat.com would be very beneficial - I talked with many colleagues about OpenShift/OKD and they were as confused as me. This suggests that communication regarding the changes in development model after version 4 was not clear enough.