You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
See title and screenshots for current and proposed state below.
Btw, this is related to / mentioned here: #8582 - "Please remove tracker" #8831 - "Make a higher starting level of privacy for new iD-users" #7040 - "Privacy Policy"
Screenshots
Current screen & logic (red marker):
Proposed screen & logic (green marker) a) or b):
a)
b)
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
I think what you are looking for is a radio button group.
(*) Show third party icons like Logos
(_) Show generic icons only
Changing the label of a checkbox based on the selected input breaks with established interface design guidelines and user expectations. The checkbox and label work in sync; you can read the checkbox as "yes" (checked) as in "yes: show third party icons" and "no:" (unchecked) "no: show third party icons"
What about a third option, to show only icons from Wikimedia Commons? Though Wikimedia is still a third party, it’s present anyways via the ubiquitous ℹ️ button and dropdown suggestions for the Wikipedia and Wikidata fields, not to mention the OSM Wiki and taginfo. NSI provides Commons images for many brands, but iD either uses them as a last resort or not at all. Then again, a third option would be even more upfront complexity for someone who hasn’t even gotten to the walkthrough yet…
Description
See title and screenshots for current and proposed state below.
Btw, this is related to / mentioned here:
#8582 - "Please remove tracker"
#8831 - "Make a higher starting level of privacy for new iD-users"
#7040 - "Privacy Policy"
Screenshots
Current screen & logic (red marker):
Proposed screen & logic (green marker) a) or b):

a)
b)

The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: