Repository navigation
[FEATURE REQUEST] OCIS: "Share to" allows only upload to personal "space" #4088
Description
Actual behaviour
With Owncloud Infinite Scale server:
If I want to share a file from another android app and selecting owncloud I am asked for which account I would like to upload (I have two, an OCIS and a classic OC). Selecting the OCIS, I can only upload to my personal space (or a subfolder of that).
Expected behaviour
After asking for which account I should be able to select where to upload the file, either to personal space, a shared folder or to a space. This selection never appears, only the personal space appears.
Currently a killer for me for OCIS.
Steps to reproduce
- Open some android app (e.g. gallery), and share this with own
- Select one or many files
- Using the share button, select owncloud
- Owncloud opens the personal space directly
Can this problem be reproduced with the official owncloud server? --> no, classic owncloud has a different concept of spaces and shares
(url: https://demo.owncloud.org, user: test, password: test)
Environment data
Android version: 13
Device model: Samsung Galaxy A51
Stock or customized system: Stock
ownCloud app version: 4.0 (26ccad5)
ownCloud server version:
ownCloud | Infinite Scale
Community
3.1.0-next.1+4ac9df17a
Logs
n/a
Activity
JuancaG05 commentedon Jul 3, 2023
Hi @rmk-ch! Thanks for opening a new issue!
In this case, we're not talking about a bug but about a known restriction we currently have for oCIS accounts. Shares are not totally stable on the backend yet, so at the moment we only allow sharing within personal space from other apps. Of course, we have this in mind for future versions 😁.
rmkl-ch commentedon Jul 5, 2023
Hi @JuancaG05 Thanks a lot for the response. Good to hear it's on the roadmap (although I thought ocis was already more stable ;) ).
Nevertheless, looking forward for more features - keep up the good work!
rmkl-ch commentedon Aug 2, 2023
@JuancaG05 Is there a roadmap with some target date? I only find outdated roadmaps saying that OCIS 2.0 will be stable. We're approaching OCIS 3.1 now and I have no clue what's still on the plan and whatnot (incl. the android client).
Due to the EOL of PHP 7.4 and some hosting companies not allowing outdated PHP versions we need to take a decision whether my new instance will be owncloud, OCIS or even nextcloud.
tbsbdr commentedon Aug 3, 2023
Hi @rmk-ch we have a public roadmap that shows major milestones for Infinite Scale: https://owncloud.com/roadmap
[-][BUG] OCIS: Share to allows only upload to personal "space"[/-][+][FEATURE REQUEST] OCIS: Share to allows only upload to personal "space"[/+]jesmrec commentedon Aug 3, 2023
This is the current status and the new expected behaviour (dev team)
Current:
New:
Personalmichaelstingl commentedon Aug 8, 2023
Could look like the Space selector when using the "Copy" feature:
rmkl-ch commentedon Aug 8, 2023
Thanks a lot. That is a much better link than the official docs: https://owncloud.dev/ocis/release_roadmap/
rmkl-ch commentedon Aug 8, 2023
Thanks @michaelstingl and @jesmrec! Would this also work with a shared folder? My understanding is that shared folders are neither in the personal nor in another space.
jesmrec commentedon Aug 9, 2023
if the folder is shared by you, you can put inside as many items as you wish.
if the folder is shared with you, it depends on the permission level you are granted by the owner.
rmkl-ch commentedon Aug 9, 2023
Agreed, this works.
This folder does not appear in the personal space (in the webapp and in the android app) but in its own category (shared). Therefore, in my opinion the android app should also show the shared folders as an option to where to upload the selected files (number 4 in the proposal #4088 (comment)).
[-][FEATURE REQUEST] OCIS: Share to allows only upload to personal "space"[/-][+][FEATURE REQUEST] OCIS: "Share to" allows only upload to personal "space"[/+]