HTTPS clone URL
Subversion checkout URL
p0f unofficial git repo
Latest commit 64d0c85 Marek Majkowski p0f-3.07b …
============================= p0f v3: passive fingerprinter ============================= http://lcamtuf.coredump.cx/p0f3.shtml Copyright (C) 2012 by Michal Zalewski <firstname.lastname@example.org> --------------- 1. What's this? --------------- P0f is a tool that utilizes an array of sophisticated, purely passive traffic fingerprinting mechanisms to identify the players behind any incidental TCP/IP communications (often as little as a single normal SYN) without interfering in any way. Some of its capabilities include: - Highly scalable and extremely fast identification of the operating system and software on both endpoints of a vanilla TCP connection - especially in settings where NMap probes are blocked, too slow, unreliable, or would simply set off alarms, - Measurement of system uptime and network hookup, distance (including topology behind NAT or packet filters), and so on. - Automated detection of connection sharing / NAT, load balancing, and application-level proxying setups. - Detection of dishonest clients / servers that forge declarative statements such as X-Mailer or User-Agent. The tool can be operated in the foreground or as a daemon, and offers a simple real-time API for third-party components that wish to obtain additional information about the actors they are talking to. Common uses for p0f include reconnaissance during penetration tests; routine network monitoring; detection of unauthorized network interconnects in corporate environments; providing signals for abuse-prevention tools; and miscellanous forensics. A snippet of typical p0f output may look like this: .-[ 188.8.131.52/1524 -> 184.108.40.206/80 (syn) ]- | | client = 220.127.116.11 | os = Windows XP | dist = 8 | params = none | raw_sig = 4:120+8:0:1452:65535,0:mss,nop,nop,sok:df,id+:0 | `---- .-[ 18.104.22.168/1524 -> 22.214.171.124/80 (syn+ack) ]- | | server = 126.96.36.199 | os = Linux 3.x | dist = 0 | params = none | raw_sig = 4:64+0:0:1460:mss*10,0:mss,nop,nop,sok:df:0 | `---- .-[ 188.8.131.52/1524 -> 184.108.40.206/80 (mtu) ]- | | client = 220.127.116.11 | link = DSL | raw_mtu = 1492 | `---- .-[ 18.104.22.168/1524 -> 22.214.171.124/80 (uptime) ]- | | client = 126.96.36.199 | uptime = 0 days 11 hrs 16 min (modulo 198 days) | raw_freq = 250.00 Hz | `---- A live demonstration can be seen here: http://lcamtuf.coredump.cx/p0f3/ -------------------- 2. How does it work? -------------------- A vast majority of metrics used by p0f were invented specifically for this tool, and include data extracted from IPv4 and IPv6 headers, TCP headers, the dynamics of the TCP handshake, and the contents of application-level payloads. For TCP/IP, the tool fingerprints the client-originating SYN packet and the first SYN+ACK response from the server, paying attention to factors such as the ordering of TCP options, the relation between maximum segment size and window size, the progression of TCP timestamps, and the state of about a dozen possible implementation quirks (e.g. non-zero values in "must be zero" fields). The metrics used for application-level traffic vary from one module to another; where possible, the tool relies on signals such as the ordering or syntax of HTTP headers or SMTP commands, rather than any declarative statements such as User-Agent. Application-level fingerprinting modules currently support HTTP. Before the tool leaves "beta", I want to add SMTP and FTP. Other protocols, such as FTP, POP3, IMAP, SSH, and SSL, may follow. The list of all the measured parameters is reviewed in section 5 later on. Some of the analysis also happens on a higher level: inconsistencies in the data collected from various sources, or in the data from the same source obtained over time, may be indicative of address translation, proxying, or just plain trickery. For example, a system where TCP timestamps jump back and forth, or where TTLs and MTUs change subtly, is probably a NAT device. ------------------------------- 3. How do I compile and use it? ------------------------------- To compile p0f, try running './build.sh'; if that fails, you will be probably given some tips about the probable cause. If the tips are useless, send me a mean-spirited mail. It is also possible to build a debug binary ('./build.sh debug'), in which case, verbose packet parsing and signature matching information will be written to stderr. This is useful when troubleshooting problems, but that's about it. The tool should compile cleanly under any reasonably new version of Linux, FreeBSD, OpenBSD, MacOS X, and so forth. You can also builtdit on Windows using cygwin and winpcap. I have not tested it on all possible varieties of un*x, but if there are issues, they should be fairly superficial. Once you have the binary compiled, you should be aware of the following command-line options: -f fname - reads fingerprint database (p0f.fp) from the specified location. See section 5 for more information about the contents of this file. The default location is ./p0f.fp. If you want to install p0f, you may want to change FP_FILE in config.h to /etc/p0f.fp. -i iface - asks p0f to listen on a specific network interface. On un*x, you should reference the interface by name (e.g., eth0). On Windows, you can use adapter index instead (0, 1, 2...). Multiple -i parameters are not supported; you need to run separate instances of p0f for that. On Linux, you can specify 'any' to access a pseudo-device that combines the traffic on all other interfaces; the only limitation is that libpcap will not recognize VLAN-tagged frames in this mode, which may be an issue in some of the more exotic setups. If you do not specify an interface, libpcap will probably pick the first working interface in your system. -L - lists all available network interfaces, then quits. Particularly useful on Windows, where the system-generated interface names are impossible to memorize. -r fname - instead of listening for live traffic, reads pcap captures from the specified file. The data can be collected with tcpdump or any other compatible tool. Make sure that snapshot length (-s option in tcpdump) is large enough not to truncate packets; the default may be too small. As with -i, only one -r option can be specified at any given time. -o fname - appends grep-friendly log data to the specified file. The log contains all observations made by p0f about every matching connection, and may grow large; plan accordingly. Only one instance of p0f should be writing to a particular file at any given time; where supported, advisory locking is used to avoid problems. -s fname - listens for API queries on the specified filesystem socket. This allows other programs to ask p0f about its current thoughts about a particular host. More information about the API protocol can be found in section 4 below. Only one instance of p0f can be listening on a particular socket at any given time. The mode is also incompatible with -r. -d - runs p0f in daemon mode: the program will fork into background and continue writing to the specified log file or API socket. It will continue running until killed, until the listening interface is shut down, or until some other fatal error is encountered. This mode requires either -o or -s to be specified. To continue capturing p0f debug output and error messages (but not signatures), redirect stderr to another non-TTY destination, e.g.: ./p0f -o /var/log/p0f.log -d 2>>/var/log/p0f.error Note that if -d is specified and stderr points to a TTY, error messages will be lost. -u user - causes p0f to drop privileges, switching to the specified user and chroot()ing itself to said user's home directory. This mode is *highly* advisable (but not required) on un*x systems, especially in daemon mode. See section 7 for more info. More arcane settings (you probably don't need to touch these): -p - puts the interface specified with -i in promiscuous mode. If supported by the firmware, the card will also process frames not addressed to it. -S num - sets the maximum number of simultaneous API connections. The default is 20; the upper cap is 100. -m c,h - sets the maximum number of connections (c) and hosts (h) to be tracked at the same time (default: c = 1,000, h = 10,000). Once the limit is reached, the oldest 10% entries gets pruned to make room for new data. This setting effectively controls the memory footprint of p0f. The cost of tracking a single host is under 400 bytes; active connections have a worst-case footprint of about 18 kB. High limits have some CPU impact, too, by the virtue of complicating data lookups in the cache. NOTE: P0f tracks connections only until the handshake is done, and if protocol-level fingerprinting is possible, until few initial kilobytes of data have been exchanged. This means that most connections are dropped from the cache in under 5 seconds; consequently, the 'c' variable can be much lower than the real number of parallel connections happening on the wire. -t c,h - sets the timeout for collecting signatures for any connection (c); and for purging idle hosts from in-memory cache (h). The first parameter is given in seconds, and defaults to 30 s; the second one is in minutes, and defaults to 120 min. The first value must be just high enough to reliably capture SYN, SYN+ACK, and the initial few kB of traffic. Low-performance sites may want to increase it slightly. The second value governs for how long API queries about a previously seen host can be made; and what's the maximum interval between signatures to still trigger NAT detection and so on. Raising it is usually not advisable; lowering it to 5-10 minutes may make sense for high-traffic servers, where it is possible to see several unrelated visitors subsequently obtaining the same dynamic IP from their ISP. Well, that's about it. You probably need to run the tool as root. Some of the most common use cases: # ./p0f -i eth0 # ./p0f -i eth0 -d -u p0f-user -o /var/log/p0f.log # ./p0f -r some_capture.cap The greppable log format (-o) uses pipe ('|') as a delimiter, with name=value pairs describing the signature in a manner very similar to the pretty-printed output generated on stdout: [2012/01/04 10:26:14] mod=mtu|cli=188.8.131.52/1234|srv=184.108.40.206/80|subj=cli|link=DSL|raw_mtu=1492 The 'mod' parameter identifies the subsystem that generated the entry; the 'cli' and 'srv' parameters always describe the direction in which the TCP session is established; and 'subj' describes which of these two parties is actually being fingerprinted. Command-line options may be followed by a single parameter containing a pcap-style traffic filtering rule. This allows you to reject some of the less interesting packets for performance or privacy reasons. Simple examples include: 'dst net 10.0.0.0/8 and port 80' 'not src host 10.1.2.3' 'port 22 or port 443' You can read more about the supported syntax by doing 'man pcap-fiter'; if that fails, try this URL: http://www.manpagez.com/man/7/pcap-filter/ Filters work both for online capture (-i) and for previously collected data produced by any other tool (-r). ------------- 4. API access ------------- The API allows other applications running on the same system to get p0f's current opinion about a particular host. This is useful for integrating it with spam filters, web apps, and so on. Clients are welcome to connect to the unix socket specified with -s using the SOCK_STREAM protocol, and may issue any number of fixed-length queries. The queries will be answered in the order they are received. Note that there is no response caching, nor any software limits in place on p0f end, so it is your responsibility to write reasonably well-behaved clients. Queries have exactly 21 bytes. The format is: - Magic dword (0x50304601), in native endian of the platform. - Address type byte: 4 for IPv4, 6 for IPv6. - 16 bytes of address data, network endian. IPv4 addresses should be aligned to the left. To such a query, p0f responds with: - Another magic dword (0x50304602), native endian. - Status dword: 0x00 for 'bad query', 0x10 for 'OK', and 0x20 for 'no match'. - Host information, valid only if status is 'OK' (byte width in square brackets):  first_seen - unix time (seconds) of first observation of the host.  last_seen - unix time (seconds) of most recent traffic.  total_conn - total number of connections seen.  uptime_min - calculated system uptime, in minutes. Zero if not known.  up_mod_days - uptime wrap-around interval, in days.  last_nat - time of the most recent detection of IP sharing (NAT, load balancing, proxying). Zero if never detected.  last_chg - time of the most recent individual OS mismatch (e.g., due to multiboot or IP reuse).  distance - system distance (derived from TTL; -1 if no data).  bad_sw - p0f thinks the User-Agent or Server strings aren't accurate. The value of 1 means OS difference (possibly due to proxying), while 2 means an outright mismatch. NOTE: If User-Agent is not present at all, this value stays at 0.  os_match_q - OS match quality: 0 for a normal match; 1 for fuzzy (e.g., TTL or DF difference); 2 for a generic signature; and 3 for both.  os_name - NUL-terminated name of the most recent positively matched OS. If OS not known, os_name is NUL. NOTE: If the host is first seen using an known system and then switches to an unknown one, this field is not reset.  os_flavor - OS version. May be empty if no data.  http_name - most recent positively identified HTTP application (e.g. 'Firefox').  http_flavor - version of the HTTP application, if any.  link_type - network link type, if recognized.  language - system language, if recognized. A simple reference implementation of an API client is provided in p0f-client.c. Implementations in C / C++ may reuse api.h from p0f source code, too. Developers using the API should be aware of several important constraints: - The maximum number of simultaneous API connections is capped to 20. The limit may be adjusted with the -S parameter, but rampant parallelism may lead to poorly controlled latency; consider a single query pipeline, possibly with prioritization and caching. - The maximum number of hosts and connections tracked at any given time is subject to configurable limits. You should look at your traffic stats and see if the defaults are suitable. You should also keep in mind that whenever you are subject to an ongoing DDoS or SYN spoofing DoS attack, p0f may end up dropping entries faster than you could query for them. It's that or running out of memory, so don't fret. - Cache entries with no activity for more than 120 minutes will be dropped even if the cache is nearly empty. The timeout is adjustable with -t, but you should not use the API to obtain ancient data; if you routinely need to go back hours or days, parse the logs instead of wasting RAM. ----------------------- 5. Fingerprint database ----------------------- Whenever p0f obtains a fingerprint from the observed traffic, it defers to the data read from p0f.fp to identify the operating system and obtain some ancillary data needed for other analysis tasks. The fingerprint database is a simple text file where lines starting with ; are ignored. == Module specification == The file is split into sections based on the type of traffic the fingerprints apply to. Section identifiers are enclosed in square brackets, like so: [module:direction] module - the name of the fingerprinting module (e.g. 'tcp' or 'http'). direction - the direction of fingerprinted traffic: 'request' (from client to server) or 'response' (from server to client). For the TCP module, 'client' matches the initial SYN; and 'server' matches SYN+ACK. The 'direction' part is omitted for MTU signatures, as they work equally well both ways. == Signature groups == The actual signatures must be preceeded by an 'label' line, describing the fingerprinted software: label = type:class:name:flavor type - some signatures in p0f.fp offer broad, last-resort matching for less researched corner cases. The goal there is to give an answer slightly better than "unknown", but less precise than what the user may be expecting. Normal, reasonably specific signatures that can't be radically improved should have their type specified as 's'; while generic, last-resort ones should be tagged with 'g'. Note that generic signatures are considered only if no specific matches are found in the database. class - the tool needs to distinguish between OS-identifying signatures (only one of which should be matched for any given host) and signatures that just identify user applications (many of which may be seen concurrently). To assist with this, OS-specific signatures should specify the OS architecture family here (e.g., 'win', 'unix', 'cisco'); while application-related sigs (NMap, MSIE, Apache) should use a special value of '!'. Most TCP signatures are OS-specific, and should have OS family defined. Other signatures, such as HTTP, should use '!' unless the fingerprinted component is deeply intertwined with the platform (e.g., Windows Update). NOTE: To avoid variations (e.g. 'win' and 'windows' or 'unix' and 'linux'), all classes need to be pre-registered using a 'classes' directive, seen near the beginning of p0f.fp. name - a human-readable short name for what the fingerprint actually helps identify - say, 'Linux', 'Sendmail', or 'NMap'. The tool doesn't care about the exact value, but requires consistency - so don't switch between 'Internet Explorer' and 'MSIE', or 'MacOS' and 'Mac OS'. flavor - anything you want to say to further qualify the observation. Can be the version of the identified software, or a description of what the application seems to be doing (e.g. 'SYN scan' for NMap). NOTE: Don't be too specific: if you have a signature for Apache 2.2.16, but have no reason to suspect that other recent versions behave in a radically different way, just say '2.x'. P0f uses labels to group similar signatures that may be plausibly generated by the same system or application, and should not be considered a strong signal for NAT detection. To further assist the tool in deciding which OS and application combinations are reasonable, and which ones are indicative of foul play, any 'label' line for applications (class '!') should be followed by a comma-delimited list of OS names or @-prefixed OS architecture classes on which this software is known to be used on. For example: label = s:!:Uncle John's Networked ls Utility:220.127.116.11 sys = Linux,FreeBSD,OpenBSD ...or: label = s:!:Mom's Homestyle Browser:1.x sys = @unix,@win The label can be followed by any number of module-specific signatures; all of them will be linked to the most recent label, and will be reported the same way. All sections except for 'name' are omitted for [mtu] signatures, which do not convey any OS-specific information, and just describe link types. == MTU signatures == Many operating systems derive the maximum segment size specified in TCP options from the MTU of their network interface; that value, in turn, normally depends on the design of the link-layer protocol. A different MTU is associated with PPPoE, a different one with IPSec, and a different one with Juniper VPN. The format of the signatures in the [mtu] section is exceedingly simple, consisting just of a description and a list of values: label = Ethernet sig = 1500 These will be matched for any wildcard MSS TCP packets (see below) not generated by userspace TCP tools. == TCP signatures == For TCP traffic, signature layout is as follows: sig = ver:ittl:olen:mss:wsize,scale:olayout:quirks:pclass ver - signature for IPv4 ('4'), IPv6 ('6'), or both ('*'). NEW SIGNATURES: P0f documents the protocol observed on the wire, but you should replace it with '*' unless you have observed some actual differences between IPv4 and IPv6 traffic, or unless the software supports only one of these versions to begin with. ittl - initial TTL used by the OS. Almost all operating systems use 64, 128, or 255; ancient versions of Windows sometimes used 32, and several obscure systems sometimes resort to odd values such as 60. NEW SIGNATURES: P0f will usually suggest something, using the format of 'observed_ttl+distance' (e.g. 54+10). Consider using traceroute to check that the distance is accurate, then sum up the values. If initial TTL can't be guessed, p0f will output 'nnn+?', and you need to use traceroute to estimate the '?'. A handful of userspace tools will generate random TTLs. In these cases, determine maximum initial TTL and then add a - suffix to the value to avoid confusion. olen - length of IPv4 options or IPv6 extension headers. Usually zero for normal IPv4 traffic; always zero for IPv6 due to the limitations of libpcap. NEW SIGNATURES: Copy p0f output literally. mss - maximum segment size, if specified in TCP options. Special value of '*' can be used to denote that MSS varies depending on the parameters of sender's network link, and should not be a part of the signature. In this case, MSS will be used to guess the type of network hookup according to the [mtu] rules. NEW SIGNATURES: Use '*' for any commodity OSes where MSS is around 1300 - 1500, unless you know for sure that it's fixed. If the value is outside that range, you can probably copy it literally. wsize - window size. Can be expressed as a fixed value, but many operating systems set it to a multiple of MSS or MTU, or a multiple of some random integer. P0f automatically detects these cases, and allows notation such as 'mss*4', 'mtu*4', or '%8192' to be used. Wilcard ('*') is possible too. NEW SIGNATURES: Copy p0f output literally. If frequent variations are seen, look for obvious patterns. If there are no patterns, '*' is a possible alternative. scale - window scaling factor, if specified in TCP options. Fixed value or '*'. NEW SIGNATURES: Copy literally, unless the value varies randomly. Many systems alter between 2 or 3 scaling factors, in which case, it's better to have several 'sig' lines, rather than a wildcard. olayout - comma-delimited layout and ordering of TCP options, if any. This is one of the most valuable TCP fingerprinting signals. Supported values: eol+n - explicit end of options, followed by n bytes of padding nop - no-op option mss - maximum segment size ws - window scaling sok - selective ACK permitted sack - selective ACK (should not be seen) ts - timestamp ?n - unknown option ID n NEW SIGNATURES: Copy this string literally. quirks - comma-delimited properties and quirks observed in IP or TCP headers: df - "don't fragment" set (probably PMTUD); ignored for IPv6 id+ - DF set but IPID non-zero; ignored for IPv6 id- - DF not set but IPID is zero; ignored for IPv6 ecn - explicit congestion notification support 0+ - "must be zero" field not zero; ignored for IPv6 flow - non-zero IPv6 flow ID; ignored for IPv4 seq- - sequence number is zero ack+ - ACK number is non-zero, but ACK flag not set ack- - ACK number is zero, but ACK flag set uptr+ - URG pointer is non-zero, but URG flag not set urgf+ - URG flag used pushf+ - PUSH flag used ts1- - own timestamp specified as zero ts2+ - non-zero peer timestamp on initial SYN opt+ - trailing non-zero data in options segment exws - excessive window scaling factor (> 14) bad - malformed TCP options If a signature scoped to both IPv4 and IPv6 contains quirks valid for just one of these protocols, such quirks will be ignored for on packets using the other protocol. For example, any combination of 'df', 'id+', and 'id-' is always matched by any IPv6 packet. NEW SIGNATURES: Copy literally. pclass - payload size classification: '0' for zero, '+' for non-zero, '*' for any. The packets we fingerprint right now normally have no payloads, but some corner cases exist. NEW SIGNATURES: Copy literally. NOTE: The TCP module allows some fuzziness when an exact match can't be found: 'df' and 'id+' quirks are allowed to disappear; 'id-' or 'ecn' may appear; and TTLs can change. To gather new SYN ('request') signatures, simply connect to the fingerprinted system, and p0f will provide you with the necessary data. To gather SYN+ACK ('response') signatures, you should use the bundled p0f-sendsyn utility while p0f is running in the background; creating them manually is not advisable. == HTTP signatures == A special directive should appear at the beginning of the [http:request] section, structured the following way: ua_os = Linux,Windows,iOS=[iPad],iOS=[iPhone],Mac OS X,... This list should specify OS names that should be looked for within the User-Agent string if the string is otherwise deemed to be honest. This input is not used for fingerprinting, but aids NAT detection in some useful ways. The names have to match the names used in 'sig' specifiers across p0f.fp. If a particular name used by p0f differs from what typically appears in User-Agent, the name=[string] syntax may be used to define any number of aliases. Other than that, HTTP signatures for GET and HEAD requests have the following layout: sig = ver:horder:habsent:expsw ver - 0 for HTTP/1.0, 1 for HTTP/1.1, or '*' for any. NEW SIGNATURES: Copy the value literally, unless you have a specific reason to do otherwise. horder - comma-separated, ordered list of headers that should appear in matching traffic. Substrings to match within each of these headers may be specified using a name=[value] notation. The signature will be matched even if other headers appear in between, as long as the list itself is matched in the specified sequence. Headers that usually do appear in the traffic, but may go away (e.g. Accept-Language if the user has no languages defined, or Referer if no referring site exists) should be prefixed with '?', e.g. "?Referer". P0f will accept their disappearance, but will not allow them to appear at any other location. NEW SIGNATURES: Review the list and remove any headers that appear to be irrelevant to the fingerprinted software, and mark transient ones with '?'. Remove header values that do not add anything to the signature, or are request- or user-specific. In particular, pay attention to Accept, Accept-Language, and Accept-Charset, as they are highly specific to request type and user settings. P0f automatically removes some headers, prefixes others with '?', and inhibits the value of fields such as 'Referer' or 'Cookie' - but this is not a substitute for manual review. NOTE: Server signatures may differ depending on the request (HTTP/1.1 versus 1.0, keep-alive versus one-shot, etc) and on the returned resource (e.g., CGI versus static content). Play around, browse to several URLs, also try curl and wget. habsent - comma-separated list of headers that must *not* appear in matching traffic. This is particularly useful for noting the absence of standard headers (e.g. 'Host'), or for differentiating between otherwise very similar signatures. NEW SIGNATURES: P0f will automatically highlight the absence of any normally present headers; other entries may be added where necessary. expsw - expected substring in 'User-Agent' or 'Server'. This is not used to match traffic, and merely serves to detect dishonest software. If you want to explicitly match User-Agent, you need to do this in the 'horder' section, e.g.: User-Agent=[Firefox] Any of these sections sections except for 'ver' may be blank. There are many protocol-level quirks that p0f could be detecting - for example, the use of non-standard newlines, or missing or extra spacing between header field names and values. There is also some information to be gathered from responses to OPTIONS or POST. That said, it does not seem to be worth the effort: the protocol is so verbose, and implemented so arbitrarily, that we are getting more than enough information just with a simple GET / HEAD fingerprint. == SMTP signatures == *** NOT IMPLEMENTED YET *** == FTP signatures == *** NOT IMPLEMENTED YET *** ---------------- 6. NAT detection ---------------- In addition to fairly straightforward measurements of intrinsic properties of a single TCP session, p0f also tries to compare signatures across sessions to detect client-side connection sharing (NAT, HTTP proxies) or server-side load balancing. This is done in two steps: the first significant deviation usually prompts a "host change" entry (which may be also indicative of multi-boot, address reuse, or other one-off events); and a persistent pattern of changes prompts an "ip sharing" notification later on. All of these messages are accompanied by a set of reason codes: os_sig - the OS detected right now doesn't match the OS detected earlier on. sig_diff - no definite OS detection data available, but protocol-level characteristics have changed drastically (e.g., different TCP option layout). app_vs_os - the application detected running on the host is not supposed to work on the host's operating system. x_known - the signature progressed from known to unknown, or vice versa. The following additional codes are specific to TCP: tstamp - TCP timestamps went back or jumped forward. ttl - TTL values have changed. port - source port number has decreased. mtu - system MTU has changed. fuzzy - the precision with which a TCP signature is matched has changed. The following code is also issued by the HTTP module: via - data explicitly includes Via / X-Forwarded-For. us_vs_os - OS fingerprint doesn't match User-Agent data, and the User-Agent value otherwise looks honest. app_srv_lb - server application signatures change, suggesting load balancing. date - server-advertised date changes inconsistently. Different reasons have different weights, balanced to keep p0f very sensitive even to very homogenous environments behind NAT. If you end up seeing false positives or other detection problems in your environment, please let me know! ----------- 7. Security ----------- You should treat the output from this tool as advisory; the fingerprinting can be gambled with some minor effort, and it's also possible to evade it altogether (e.g. with excessive IP fragmentation or bad TCP checksums). Plan accordingly. P0f should to be reasonably secure to operate as a daemon. That said, un*x users should employ the -u option to drop privileges and chroot() when running the tool continuously. This greatly minimizes the consequences of any mishaps - and mishaps in C just tend to happen. To make this step meaningful, the user you are running p0f as should be completely unprivileged, and should have an empty, read-only home directory. For example, you can do: # useradd -d /var/empty/p0f -M -r -s /bin/nologin p0f-user # mkdir -p -m 755 /var/empty/p0f Please don't put the p0f binary itself, or any other valuable assets, inside that user's home directory; and certainly do not use any generic locations such as / or /bin/ in lieu of a proper home. P0f running in the background should be fairly difficult to DoS, especially compared to any real TCP services it will be watching. Nevertheless, there are so many deployment-specific factors at play that you should always preemptively stress-test your setup, and see how it behaves. Other than that, let's talk filesystem security. When using the tool in the API mode (-s), the listening socket is always re-created created with 666 permissions, so that applications running as other uids can query it at will. If you want to preserve the privacy of captured traffic in a multi-user system, please ensure that the socket is created in a directory with finer-grained permissions; or change API_MODE in config.h. The default file mode for binary log data (-o) is 600, on the account that others probably don't need access to historical data; if you need to share logs, you can pre-create the file or change LOG_MODE in config.h. Don't build p0f, and do not store its source, binary, configuration files, logs, or query sockets in world-writable locations such as /tmp (or any subdirectories created therein). Last but not least, please do not attempt to make p0f setuid, or otherwise grant it privileges higher than these of the calling user. Neither the tool itself, nor the third-party components it depends on, are designed to keep rogue less-privileged callers at bay. If you use /etc/sudoers to list p0f as the only program that user X should be able to run as root, that user will probably be able to compromise your system. The same goes for many other uses of sudo, by the way. -------------- 8. Limitations -------------- Here are some of the known issues you may run into: == General == 1) RST, ACK, and other experimental fingerprinting modes offered in p0f v2 are no longer supported in v3. This is because they proved to have very low specificity. The consequence is that you can no longer fingerprint "connection refused" responses. 2) API queries or daemon execution are not supported when reading offline pcaps. While there may be some fringe use cases for that, offline pcaps use a much simpler event loop, and so supporting these features would require some extra effort. 3) P0f needs to observe at least about 25 milliseconds worth of qualifying traffic to estimate system uptime. This means that if you're testing it over loopback or LAN, you may need to let it see more than one connection. Systems with extremely slow timestamp clocks may need longer acquisition periods (up to several seconds); very fast clocks (over 1.5 kHz) are rejected completely on account of being prohibited by the RFC. Almost all OSes are between 100 Hz and 1 kHz, which should work fine. 4) Some systems vary SYN+ACK responses based on the contents of the initial SYN, sometimes removing TCP options not supported by the other endpoint. Unfortunately, there is no easy way to account for this, so several SYN+ACK signatures may be required per system. The bundled p0f-sendsyn utility helps with collecting them. Another consequence of this is that you will sometimes see server uptime only if your own system has RFC1323 timestamps enabled. Linux does that since version 2.2; on Windows, you need version 7 or newer. Client uptimes are not affected. == Windows port == 1) API sockets do not work on Windows. This is due to a limitation of winpcap; see live_event_loop(...) in p0f.c for more info. 2) The chroot() jail (-u) on Windows doesn't offer any real security. This is due to the limitations of cygwin. 3) The p0f-sendsyn utility doesn't work because of the limited capabilities of Windows raw sockets (this should be relatively easy to fix if there are any users who care). --------------------------- 9. Acknowledgments and more --------------------------- P0f is made possible thanks to the contributions of several good souls, including: Phil Ames Jannich Brendle Matthew Dempsky Jason DePriest Dalibor Dukic Mark Martinec Damien Miller Josh Newton Nibbler Bernhard Rabe Chris John Riley Sebastian Roschke Peter Valchev Jeff Weisberg Anthony Howe Tomoyuki Murakami Michael Petch If you wish to help, the most immediate way to do so is to simply gather new signatures, especially from less popular or older platforms (servers, networking equipment, portable / embedded / specialty OSes, etc). Problems? Suggestions? Complaints? Compliments? You can reach the author at <email@example.com>. The author is very lonely and appreciates your mail.