Motivation, Background, and Whitepaper
Further discussion of the NIST casino beyond what is in this document is provided in
and is available at http://184.108.40.206:5000/static/report.pdf for download. This includes discussions
of the NIST Casino's security guarantees, as well as a comparison to previous work in trusted
cryptographic games of chance.
A sample deployment of the NIST casino can be accessed at http://220.127.116.11:5000/
Note that this deployment operates over HTTPS, and should not be trusted with games whose outcome affects real funds.
To install, simply:
- Install Python, Python-pip
- Install PyCrypto dependencies (on Ubuntu/Debian, sudo apt-get install libgmp-dev build-essential python-dev)
- sudo pip install -r requirements.txt
To run the NIST Casino after installation, simply change the values in config.py and run
python web_interface.py from the main folder.
To play a NIST casino game, a player must first generate a ticket.
A ticket request, sent to the house, includes only the public key of a player-stored RSA key. The ticket request can be generated either server or client-side, for a balance of trustless operation and ease of use.
The public key is provided to the NIST casino as a ticket request, after which it is encoded into a ticket. The ticket includes an RSA public key and all of the parameters required to process the user's action in a given game (for example, Blackjack-like games can include a 'hit or stay' parameter determining user action). The ticket is then saved by the user as "proof of purchase", along with their private key (required to claim winnings if they have the winning ticket). A ticket is also signed by the house once it is accepted, so that if the house attempts to later revoke the ticket, valid proof of purchase can be proven by the user.
Each game has a "casino chain", which consists of one block every sixty seconds containing all the tickets sold during that time period. The initial casino chain block also contains the dealer's RSA key information and the game parameters, used to compute the final outcome when the game is finished and to sign users' tickets as they are distributed.
Each block is timestamped, signed by the dealer, carries a hash reference to the previous block (for unmodifiability), and contains the NIST beacon value released after block creation (to prevent precomputation of blocks by the house). For the dealer to modify any user's ticket in the chain, it would also have to modify subsequent blocks, an obvious attack that is easily detectable.
The game ends after the time period defined in the initial block has elapsed. Once the game ends, the NIST
Casino page will display a winner. Users can also verify the winner locally by running
python check.py and inputting a file containing the full caino chain to check. This will verify that
each block has the correct NIST beacon value and is correctly signed by both dealers and participants.
An example chain is provided for use with the checking utility in the
Determining Winners and Creating New Games
As previously stated, winners can be computed entirely client side. The rules by which winners are decided are written as an easily auditable Python program. This program must implement three functions:
def get_id(self) def is_valid_ticket(self, ticket) def get_game_result(self, chain, randint)
The first function,
get_id, simply returns the plaintext game name (eg - 'Lotto').
The second function,
is_valid_ticket, takes a ticket object and returns whether the ticket should
be considered valid. Only valid tickets are considered in the computation of the final winner. An
example of the valid ticket rules for the Lotto game are as follows:
def is_valid_ticket(self, ticket): try: dollar_value = int(ticket) return (dollar_value > 0) except: return False
where a valid ticket has a positive integer dollar amount associated with it.
The last function, get_game_result, takes a Casino chain (downloadable from the house) and a random integer value. This value is obtained from the NIST beacon API, using the block generated at the predetermined time and encoded in the first block of the casino chain. It is intended to be easily auditable and simple. Here it is for a basic lottery:
def get_game_result(self, chain, randint): result = '' total_tickets = 0 # Calculate total number of tickets, ignoring first block for block in chain[1:]: block = json.loads(block) for transaction in block['transactions']: ticket = transaction['ticket'] if not self.is_valid_ticket(transaction['ticket']): return 'Error: invalid transaction ' + str(transaction) total_tickets += int(ticket) if (total_tickets == 0): return 'No winner! No tickets sold :(' # Use entropy to calculate winning ticket result += 'Total tickets: ' + str(total_tickets) + '\n' winning_ticket = randint % total_tickets result += 'Winning ticket: ' + str(winning_ticket) + '\n' current_ticket = 0 # Find winning ticket in chain and return for block in chain[1:]: block = json.loads(block) for transaction in block['transactions']: ticket_value = int(transaction['ticket']) if ((current_ticket + ticket_value) > winning_ticket) and (current_ticket <= winning_ticket): result += 'Won on index ' + str(current_ticket) + '\n' result += 'Winning transaction (ID ' + transaction['id'] + '):' + str(transaction) return result current_ticket += ticket_value return 'Error: No winner found.'
As previously mentioned, each ticket has a dollar amount. The total number of dollars sold (total_tickets) is first calculated. Then, the winner is calculated from the entropy modulo the sales. The winning ticket is identified in the chain and printed to the screen.
We also include CoinToss, a game where each user submits a ticket with a number of coin tosses they would like performed. The result is a sequence of non-precomputable coin tosses, and can be used for remote coin tosses where fairness is critical.
Other more advanced games, like Blackjack, Roulette, and traditional casino games, are easily encodable into the above framework. For simplicity (both legal and technical), we do not include such games.
Further Avoiding Precomputation
The last block of any casino chain must be empty (with more empty blocks potentially required based on configuration). This is to prevent manipulation of the last block by the house after the NIST entropy source is revealed, and to give players the time to download the unaltered chain for independent output computation before the outcome is determined by the entropy reveal by NIST.