Open software engineering platform and fun adventure game
Switch branches/tags
Nothing to show
Clone or download
epriestley Explicitly shuffle nodes before selecting one for cluster sync
Depends on D19734. Ref T13202. Ref T13109. Ref T10884. See PHI905. See PHI889. We currently rank cluster nodes in three cases:

  # when performing a write, we can go to any node (D19734 should make our ranking good);
  # when performing a read, we can go to any node (currently random, but T10884 discusses ideas to improve our ranking);
  # when performing an internal synchronization before a read or a write, we must go to an up-to-date node.

Currently, case (3) is not-exactly-deterministic but not random, and we won't spread intracluster traffic acrosss the cluster evenly if, say, half of it is up to date and half of it is still synchronizing. For a given write, I believe all nodes will tend to synchronize from whichever node first received the write today.

Instead, shuffle the list and synchronize from any up-to-date node.

(I think we could improve upon this only by knowing which nodes actually have load and selecting the least-loaded -- doable, but not trivial.)

Test Plan: Poked at it locally, will deploy to `secure`. This is hard to measure/test terribly convincingly.

Reviewers: amckinley

Reviewed By: amckinley

Maniphest Tasks: T13202, T13109, T10884

Differential Revision:
Latest commit bc6c8c0 Oct 5, 2018

Phabricator is a collection of web applications which help software companies build better software.

Phabricator includes applications for:

  • reviewing and auditing source code;
  • hosting and browsing repositories;
  • tracking bugs;
  • managing projects;
  • conversing with team members;
  • assembling a party to venture forth;
  • writing stuff down and reading it later;
  • hiding stuff from coworkers; and
  • also some other things.

You can learn more about the project (and find links to documentation and resources) at

Phabricator is developed and maintained by Phacility.


For resources on filing bugs, requesting features, reporting security issues, and getting other kinds of support, see Support Resources.


We do not accept pull requests through GitHub. If you would like to contribute code, please read our Contributor's Guide.


Phabricator is released under the Apache 2.0 license except as otherwise noted.