2014 10_Meeting_IRC_Log

Michal Čihař edited this page Apr 14, 2016 · 2 revisions
(12:03:20) Marc9: Start of 2014-10 meeting
(12:03:33) Marc9: Item 1: Committee membership voting
(12:03:35) madhuracj: Thanks smita and dstorm
(12:03:56) Marc9: Voting by alphabetic order :)
(12:04:25) Marc9: Which current committee member is in favor of accepting Chirayu?
(12:04:31) madhuracj: I vote in favor
(12:04:32) Marc9: I am in favor, and Michal too
(12:05:06) ibennetch-mobile: I also vote in favor for both.
(12:05:17) smita_: me too in favor :-)
(12:05:39) Marc9: Sorry Smita, you cannot vote yet
(12:06:20) Marc9: By the way, the quorum is 50% of current members, which means 4 members. As Michal already voted, the quorum is there
(12:06:42) Marc9: Chirayu is accepted, congratulations
(12:06:44) madhuracj: Great!
(12:06:50) madhuracj: Congratulations!
(12:06:59) ***dstorm thanks everyone
(12:06:59) Marc9: Now, who is in favor of accepting Smita?
(12:07:05) Marc9: I am in favor and Michal too
(12:07:08) ibennetch-mobile: Excellent. Thank you Marc9 for that information.
(12:07:35) Marc9: dstorm can vote now
(12:07:37) ***dstorm thinks he can vote now being member
(12:07:54) ibennetch-mobile: To be clear, I also vote in favor.
(12:08:12) dstorm: I also vote in favor
(12:08:14) madhuracj: In favor
(12:08:26) Marc9: Smita is accepted, congratulations
(12:08:40) ibennetch-mobile: Congratulations to you both! And welcome.
(12:08:41) Marc9: Item 2: Roadmap to version 4.3
(12:08:53) smita_: thank you team :-)
(12:09:06) Marc9: I see two show-stoppers for 4.3.0-alpha
(12:09:20) Marc9: First, the regression about importing SQL
(12:09:36) Marc9: Second, the "insanely slow" problem with thousands of databases
(12:10:06) madhuracj: I agree, specially the import problem
(12:10:08) dstorm: I can notice significant slowness in QA_4_2 and master even with 3-4 databases
(12:10:09) Marc9: The first one has already been discussed but I believe we should remove the mbstring functions in this part of the code
(12:10:27) Marc9: dstorm, talking about import or in general?
(12:10:32) dstorm: in general
(12:11:05) Marc9: I did not notice that; which MySQL version?
(12:11:36) dstorm: 5.5.38-0ubuntu0.12.04.1
(12:11:47) Marc9: and is it since Hugues has merged the PMA_String stuff all over?
(12:12:16) dstorm: I also encountered execution timeout at home page (after login)
(12:12:24) Marc9: But first, are there other problems blocking 4.3.0-alpha?
(12:12:30) dstorm: most probably after that PMA_String stuff
(12:13:00) madhuracj: I do not see anything major other than those two
(12:13:13) Marc9: dstorm, if you could check to confirm that, and add a comment to the relevant commit in github
(12:13:25) smita_: I think we have got many reports as well for slow issue .. after PMA_string
(12:13:27) Warped [~Warped@108.85.160.119] a rejoint le salon.
(12:13:31) dstorm: Sure. I'll check that
(12:13:48) Marc9: smita: for importing or other things?
(12:14:04) ibennetch-mobile: I also am not aware of any other blockers, but both of those are rather important issues to resolve.
(12:14:06) smita_: btw I get execution timeout on home page many a time due to git version update..
(12:14:22) dstorm: those slow issues we are getting since 4.2 maybe
(12:14:44) dstorm: but still I can see difference in 4.2 and master branch
(12:14:49) Marc9: smita, be careful when you switch your git repo, better close and reopen your browser
(12:14:50) ibennetch-mobile: I also have been noticing some strange behavior relating to the git version check.
(12:14:56) smita_: no, in general.. not specifically import
(12:15:32) dstorm: yeah, in git version check. just got one now. It is pointing to StringMB class
(12:15:39) smita_: yeah marc, right. mostly i get when  change the repo. thanks, 'll keep in mind .
(12:15:49) Marc9: so this should be reported as a bug please
(12:16:21) smita_: Sure, I'll report.
(12:16:24) Marc9: dstorm, can you see the differences also on demo.phpmyadmin.net ?
(12:16:46) dstorm: IIRC, I saw something similar already reported. I'll see that's same or something else
(12:17:57) dstorm: not on demo.phpmyadmin.net
(12:18:23) Marc9: dstorm, so it might be specific to your environment; please post more details in a bug ticket
(12:18:25) dstorm: I think its because of caching on demo.phpmyadmin.net
(12:18:45) dstorm: Performance tends to improve after a while of caching but at start it is slow
(12:19:27) madhuracj: Anyway it's best to have a bug report to keep track of the issue and we probably can discuss more about the problem there
(12:19:33) Marc9: To recap: PMA_String has introduced a regression (import) and a possible slowdown in general (to be confirmed)
(12:19:47) Marc9: madhuracj: right
(12:20:17) Marc9: About the other problem (thousands of db): this is not regression but I believe we should make an effort for 4.3
(12:20:41) madhuracj: I believe it's there since version 4.0
(12:21:08) Marc9: By the way, I started to test a version from labs.mysql.com that includes a new dictionary, which is supposed to help information_schema performance
(12:21:12) dstorm: Marc9: Is there any particular reason why it is slow with huge amount of db's in newer version
(12:21:39) Marc9: dstorm: because we stopped using "SHOW DATABASES" in favor of polling information_schema
(12:22:10) dstorm: madhuracj: 4.0 is pretty fast, as per bug reports.
(12:22:24) Marc9: So we could, in 4.3.0, offer an option that reintroduces using "SHOW DATABASES", but reduces the feature set
(12:22:45) dstorm: Marc9: how will that affect the feature set?
(12:22:59) madhuracj: Marc9: I see. Yes, that is an option
(12:23:11) Marc9: even if the new version (for MySQL 5.7 ?) is better, we should help users who will stay on MySQL 5.5 for years
(12:23:25) Marc9: dstorm: for example, the db filter in the navi panel
(12:24:06) ZweiSteinSoft [590fed21@gateway/web/freenode/ip.89.15.237.33] a rejoint le salon.
(12:24:16) dstorm: Hi Ann+J.M
(12:24:16) Marc9: dstorm, you can try "git grep information_schema" to get an idea; not all of these queries are translatable to SHOW DATABASES
(12:24:23) ZweiSteinSoft: Hi everybody
(12:24:27) Marc9: Hi JM
(12:24:30) ibennetch-mobile: I like this suggestion. Users will be stuck on slow MySQL installations for years.
(12:24:31) madhuracj: Hi JM
(12:24:38) ibennetch-mobile: Hello JM
(12:24:42) smita_: Hello JM
(12:24:52) ZweiSteinSoft: Hi team, we're here short because we're on mobile.
(12:25:05) dstorm: Marc9: yeah i'll try that
(12:25:13) ZweiSteinSoft: We vote accepting both. We should go for GSoC 2015.
(12:25:31) Marc9: So is everyone in favor of putting back an option to exclusively use SHOW DATABASES (off by default) ?
(12:25:41) ZweiSteinSoft: 4.3.0-alpha.1: It depends on Marc's tests with the shared hosting server...
(12:26:13) Marc9: JM: there are still not 150000 grants on this server and I'm still waiting for your answer about which query takes minuts
(12:26:16) Marc9: minutes
(12:26:37) ibennetch-mobile a quitté le salon (quit: Remote host closed the connection)
(12:26:40) dstorm: I am in favor of performance over some features
(12:26:49) Marc9: By the way, I believe that Madhura will need an access to this server
(12:27:10) madhuracj: Indeed, if I am to work on these issues
(12:27:22) J_Steen [~J_Steen@ip51cdd230.speed.planet.nl] a rejoint le salon.
(12:27:39) Marc9: madhura, we'll see this during item 4 :)
(12:27:42) smita_: yeah, I m in favor. better than having slow performance ..
(12:27:42) ZweiSteinSoft: We'll be back tomorrow evening on broadband, answering all the mails, this one too.
(12:27:46) ibennetch-mobile [~ibennetch@mobile-166-171-059-184.mycingular.net] a rejoint le salon.
(12:27:47) madhuracj: :)
(12:28:00) Marc9: Anything else to say for item 2?
(12:28:41) Marc9: Note that the slow performance for thousands of db is only for root, not for their users
(12:28:42) J_Steen a quitté le salon
(12:29:21) Marc9: Item 3: GSoC 2015
(12:29:33) Marc9: It has been officially announced
(12:29:46) Marc9: If we participate, what would be the goals?
(12:29:49) ZweiSteinSoft: :)
(12:30:09) madhuracj: I think we should still take part with the aim of attracting new developers
(12:30:11) dstorm: We should. We have lot of bug reports and rfe
(12:30:16) Marc9: (taking into consideration that we have a full-time developer)
(12:30:36) dstorm: +scrutnizer issues and test coverage too
(12:31:11) ibennetch-mobile: This is a good question. I was just thinking about this because madhuracj is fixing many of the things I would want to mentor :-)
(12:31:15) Marc9: Do we have a way to know which code is not covered?
(12:31:37) Marc9: ibenneth: you mean in the feature requests, right?
(12:31:43) dstorm: yeah, coverage reports provide good detail on that
(12:31:49) ZweiSteinSoft: Code Coverage report? in Scrutinizer perhaps?
(12:32:03) dstorm: coverage-html being very user friendly showing every line of code i.e. covered or not
(12:32:10) Marc9: ok thanks
(12:32:26) dstorm: phpunit with coverage-html
(12:33:16) ZweiSteinSoft: We will read the rest of this chat tomorrow evening... have a nice time (around the world—from India over Europe + the States to Canada…)
(12:33:45) ZweiSteinSoft: Until soon! —Ann + J.M.
(12:33:47) ibennetch-mobile: Yes I mean feature requests
(12:33:56) madhuracj a quitté le salon (quit: Read error: Connection reset by peer)
(12:34:15) ibennetch-mobile: Doofus ZweiSteinSoft
(12:34:16) ibennetch-mobile: Gah! Stupid autocorrect.
(12:34:21) Marc9: The problem is, we almost never got a project idea from a student, it came from the team
(12:34:33) ibennetch-mobile: I mean goodbye!!! Sorry about that.
(12:34:55) ZweiSteinSoft: ibennetch-mobile: :)
(12:35:04) Marc9: Bye JM
(12:35:19) dstorm: Marc9: for a project idea from student, he must be well known with phpMyAdmin as user.
(12:35:23) madhuracj [~kvirc@175.157.166.150] a rejoint le salon.
(12:35:35) Marc9: dstorm, right
(12:35:37) ZweiSteinSoft a quitté le salon (quit: )
(12:36:12) smita_: we may even have responsive themes for UI .. as current themes are not responsive
(12:36:15) Marc9: So, we could have one project about improving unit tests coverage, and ???
(12:36:33) dstorm: refactoring, maybe
(12:36:52) Marc9: smita, I believe we discussed producing themes for a GSoC project and it was not acceptable
(12:37:40) ***dstorm wonders how we will accomodate so many things on mobile display
(12:37:56) smita_: hmm .. is there any specific reason?
(12:38:02) Marc9: Ok, so we'll open new GSoC 2015 pages and everyone who wants to mentor, can add his/her idea
(12:38:39) Marc9: Just a quick question: who is available/willing to be a mentor?
(12:38:50) ***Marc9 is
(12:38:56) ibennetch: I am also
(12:39:08) ***dstorm is not sure
(12:39:25) smita_: Since I'll still be student so I might be participating ..
(12:39:31) Marc9: Michal is probably available
(12:39:31) madhuracj: I am also
(12:39:48) Marc9: Smita: good point
(12:39:49) ***dstorm is not more a student :(
(12:40:35) Marc9: Anything else about GSoC 2015?
(12:40:49) smita_: BTW how about having some app, android or iOS ? if possible
(12:41:46) Marc9: Smita, this was discussed but we really did not know if it was appropriate
(12:41:55) smita_: may be for tablets n iPad for managing few stuffs with limited features..
(12:41:56) dstorm: maybe we need RESTful APIs for it.
(12:42:16) smita_: yeah .. we'll certainly need API's
(12:42:25) Marc9: It's also a question of maintenance for the future code
(12:42:38) madhuracj: We might have problems maintaining android and iOS apps
(12:42:45) madhuracj: exactly :)
(12:42:45) ibennetch: Tablets and phones were discussed some time ago, I believe as part of an IRC meeting. We decided we didn't have the resources or user interest to make it worthwile at that time.
(12:43:12) Marc9: Isaac: I remember this, but I don't remember which meeting
(12:44:01) smita_: marc9: agree, we'll need active android/iOS developers for maintainance
(12:44:11) Marc9: Item 4: Suggestions for contract developer
(12:44:21) Marc9: Madhura, we are listening...
(12:44:41) madhuracj: Your ideas are most welcome in order to prioratize work
(12:45:22) Marc9: I would like to release 4.3.0-alpha ASAP so the two subjects above would be my priority, so
(12:45:28) madhuracj: During the first week I attended mostly to bugs, security issues and some refactoring
(12:45:39) ibennetch: About the tablet version, I think this was it: https://wiki.phpmyadmin.net/pma/2014-01_Meeting_IRC_Log
(12:45:52) dstorm: I would say (in order), Bug fixing should be given priority then test code
(12:45:54) Marc9: if you can work with Hugues about the PMA_String thing (evaluate the impact, fix the import bug)
(12:46:22) Marc9: and then add the option for deactivating information_schema, this would be fantastic
(12:46:46) dstorm: Marc9: that would be really great
(12:46:54) Marc9: After, there could be some bug fixing to prepare 4.2.10 in two weeks
(12:46:57) madhuracj: Marc9: Sure I will work on them
(12:47:21) Marc9: thanks Isaac
(12:48:56) ***Marc9 has a dream: an empty bug tracker
(12:49:06) madhuracj: :)
(12:49:25) ***dstorm too (zero defect = quality)
(12:49:39) Marc9: Of course, some old tickets can be closed because they are out of date or we got no answer
(12:50:02) Marc9: dstorm: we noticed that since the start of refactoring effort, quality has improved
(12:50:05) madhuracj: I started attending to those age old ones
(12:50:05) ibennetch-mobile a quitté le salon (quit: Quit: Colloquy for iPhone - http://colloquy.mobi)
(12:50:08) ibennetch: I've been very pleased with the progress in this first week and think the others have good suggestions.
(12:50:32) ibennetch: I suggest prioritizing 4.3.0-alpha, of course, then going through to eliminate some outdated bugs.
(12:50:36) ibennetch: *bug reports*
(12:50:54) ibennetch: Which I've noticed you doing anyway.
(12:51:02) Marc9: You see, once 4.3.0-alpha (or beta) are released, we will get more bug reports about it
(12:51:33) ibennetch: I also think there are some improvements to be made on the error reporting server, though I'm not clear on what the issues are with it.
(12:51:50) madhuracj: Marc9: Indeed, the bug rush will begin
(12:51:51) Marc9: also, I would like Madhura to add new features for 4.4, not for 4.3. This means a shorter release cycle for 4.3.0.
(12:51:55) smita_: what about giving some time on testing the release version before the release ofcourse ?
(12:52:04) smita_: that we can even do ..
(12:52:19) Marc9: Smita: we always have alpha, beta and release candidates
(12:52:56) Marc9: and I will put -alpha in production at my work ;) once the two issues are fixed
(12:53:20) dstorm: Marc9: brave :)
(12:53:22) madhuracj: So I will not take and rfes until we have QA_4_3
(12:53:46) Marc9: madhura, yes I think it would be better this way
(12:53:54) madhuracj: any*
(12:53:56) ibennetch: If I may add on here, I think we could overhaul the priority tag of the trackers.
(12:54:32) ibennetch: That might help madhuracj prioritize his work, also - but right now I feel like we're not clear on what the difference between the priorites are.
(12:55:00) Marc9: Well, we only use 5 and 1
(12:55:32) Marc9: What do you suggest?
(12:56:20) glebihan_ a quitté le salon (quit: Remote host closed the connection)
(12:56:20) nisargjhaveri [~nisargjha@14.139.82.6] a rejoint le salon.
(12:56:26) Marc9: (meeting ends in 4 minutes)
(12:56:43) ibennetch: We can use the status tag to mark when something's been fixed or released and change the priority tag to actually show the priority (1 would be release-blocking, 5 is wishlist). Something like that.
(12:57:13) ibennetch: That's the gist of my suggestion; I can take it to the mailing list so the meeting can end on time.
(12:57:17) Marc9: Ok, we can discuss this on phpmyadmin-devel list
(12:57:33) Marc9: If there is nothing else, I smell the end of meeting...
(12:57:49) ibennetch: I have nothing. Thank you all, this has been quite productive
(12:57:59) Marc9: Thanks to all
(12:58:14) Marc9: END OF MEETING
Clone this wiki locally
You can’t perform that action at this time.
You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session. You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.
Press h to open a hovercard with more details.