Selective preview icons #1149

skurfer opened this Issue Oct 1, 2012 · 0 comments


None yet
1 participant

skurfer commented Oct 1, 2012

The icons displayed in Quicksilver should be the best available. Currently, it displays a preview icon generated by the QuickLook system, but that's not always better. Some examples:

  • The “naked” icon for Preference Panes is much better than the QuickLook preview version (which is a sort of document icon with a tiny item-specific image in the center).
  • Connections for Microsoft’s Remote Desktop application are stored as XML. As a result, the icon for .rdp files always appears as tiny, illegible XML text instead of the document type’s nicer icon.
  • This could be personal preference, but as a general rule, previews for documents are not helpful. At that size, it can be hard to tell the difference between a text file, a Word document, or a spreadsheet. The generic type-based icon for such files is very identifiable. There’s a lot of overhead associated with the previews, too.

So what can we do about it?

  1. Hard code a list of file types for which the QuickLook preview is worse than the actual icon
  2. Hard code a list of types for which previews should be enabled and disable them by default
  3. Add a bunch of fiddly stuff to the preferences so users can make their own list
  4. Nothing

Again, this could be personal preference, but I think the only time the preview is desirable over the plain icon is for images, PDFs, and videos. If there’s general agreement on that, then option 2 makes the most sense. We should be able to simply check if a file’s UTI conforms to public.image, com.adobe.pdf, or and enable previews. Disable them otherwise.

We should also provide a way for plug-ins to enable previews for additional types or specific objects. I have some thoughts on implementation, but that can wait.

skurfer was assigned Oct 12, 2012

skurfer closed this in 5836b06 Oct 16, 2012

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment