An open implementation of Pure CFR applied to ACPC poker games.
C++ C
Latest commit 76fe903 Jan 24, 2014 @rggibson Update
Failed to load latest commit information.
acpc_server_code Added tool for printing a player's strategy. Also added Kuhn Poker to… Jul 29, 2013
games Added tool for printing a player's strategy. Also added Kuhn Poker to… Jul 29, 2013
.gitignore Added executables to .gitignore Jan 3, 2014
LICENSE Update LICENSE Aug 2, 2013
Makefile Fixed compile/linking bug by switching -lpthread to -pthread Jul 31, 2013 Update Jan 25, 2014
abstract_game.cpp -Renamed PureCfrPlayer to PlayerModule Jul 30, 2013
abstract_game.hpp Fixed a few compiler warnings and minor bugs Jul 31, 2013
action_abstraction.cpp -Renamed PureCfrPlayer to PlayerModule Jul 30, 2013
action_abstraction.hpp Fixed a few compiler warnings and minor bugs Jul 31, 2013
betting_node.cpp -Renamed PureCfrPlayer to PlayerModule Jul 30, 2013
betting_node.hpp -Renamed PureCfrPlayer to PlayerModule Jul 30, 2013
card_abstraction.cpp -Renamed PureCfrPlayer to PlayerModule Jul 30, 2013
card_abstraction.hpp -Renamed PureCfrPlayer to PlayerModule Jul 30, 2013
constants.cpp -Renamed PureCfrPlayer to PlayerModule Jul 30, 2013
constants.hpp -Renamed PureCfrPlayer to PlayerModule Jul 30, 2013
entries.cpp -Renamed PureCfrPlayer to PlayerModule Jul 30, 2013
entries.hpp -Renamed PureCfrPlayer to PlayerModule Jul 30, 2013
hand.hpp -Renamed PureCfrPlayer to PlayerModule Jul 30, 2013
parameters.cpp -Renamed PureCfrPlayer to PlayerModule Jul 30, 2013
parameters.hpp Fixed a few compiler warnings and minor bugs Jul 31, 2013
player_module.cpp Fixed a few compiler warnings and minor bugs Jul 31, 2013
player_module.hpp Fixed a few compiler warnings and minor bugs Jul 31, 2013
print_player_strategy.cpp Fixed a few compiler warnings and minor bugs Jul 31, 2013
pure_cfr.cpp Fixed minor typo in status printout message Jan 3, 2014
pure_cfr_machine.cpp Fixed bug in hand generator Jan 2, 2014
pure_cfr_machine.hpp -Renamed PureCfrPlayer to PlayerModule Jul 30, 2013
pure_cfr_player.cpp Added pure_cfr_player for actually playing with an ACPC dealer. Jul 30, 2013
utility.cpp -Renamed PureCfrPlayer to PlayerModule Jul 30, 2013
utility.hpp -Renamed PureCfrPlayer to PlayerModule Jul 30, 2013

Open Pure CFR

Pure CFR is a time and memory-efficient variant of the Counterfactual Regret Minimization (CFR) algorithm algorithm for computing strategies for an extensive-form game with imperfect information, such as poker. Unlike Monte Carlo CFR (MCCFR), Pure CFR samples a pure strategy profile (exactly one action assigned probability 1 at every state) on each iteration and performs an update assuming the players and chance follow the sampled pure profile. In practice, strategies improve faster over time than the original CFR algorithm. In addition, while previous CFR algorithms require floating-point values (doubles), Pure CFR uses integer values (ints) and thus uses approximately half the memory of other common variants. Furthermore, Pure CFR retains the theoretical guarantees of MCCFR, and thus converges (probabilistically) to an equilibrium profile in two-player zero-sum games. More details regarding Pure CFR can be found in my PhD dissertation. Credit goes to Oskari Tammelin for inventing the algorithm.

About this Implementation

This implementation of Pure CFR computes poker strategies that are playable in the Annual Computer Poker Competition (ACPC). In addition to games played at the ACPC, this implementation can also be run on any game that can be defined under the project_acpc_server framework. The code runs on both Linux and Windows under Cygwin. The code has not been tested on a Mac, but feel free to give Mac a shot if you are feeling adventurous.


First, you must have both make and gcc-g++ installed on your machine. Then, in your open-pure-cfr directory, simply run make and wait for the code to finish compiling. Once complete, you should have three new programs in your open-pure-cfr directory: pure_cfr, print_player_strategy, and pure_cfr_player.


This is the main program that generates strategies for games specified under the project_acpc_server framework. Sets of three files are generated during the run, a .regrets, .avg-strategy, and .player file. Run ./pure_cfr with no additional arguments to display the usage information. We will now describe in detail each of the required and optional arguments before providing some examples of how to run pure_cfr on a variety of games.

Command-line Arguments

pure_cfr requires two arguments. The first argument must be a file that defines the game to be played. The games provided by the project_acpc_server code can be found in the games/ subdirectory, along with a definition for Kuhn Poker. The second argument is a prefix that specifies where and what name the output files will be and have respectively.

After these two arguments are specified, a number of different options can be selected:

  • --config=<file> - Overwrites the two required arguments and the default options through values specified in file. See parameters.cpp::read_params( ) for details on how to format this file.
  • --rng=<seed1:seed2:seed3:seed4|TIME> - Specifies the seeds to be used to initialize the random number generator, where seed1, seed2, seed3, and seed4 are integer values. The random number generator is used to sample a pure strategy profile on each iteration from chance and the players. Alternatively, passing the option --rng=TIME initializes the random number generator according to the current time.
  • --card-abs=<NULL|BLIND> - Specifies a card abstraction to be used. Only two card abstractions are currently implemented. --card-abs=NULL specifies no card abstraction (not even suit isomorphisms), while --card-abs=BLIND specifies that all hands fall into the same bucket. NULL is only feasible in toy games, like Kuhn Poker, that use very few cards, while BLIND essentially means that the players never look at the public or their private cards.
  • --action-abs=<NULL|FCPA> - Specifies an action abstraction to be used. This option should only be used for nolimit games. --action-abs=NULL specifies that all actions remain legal in the abstract game, while --action-abs=FCPA specifies that only fold, call, pot-sized raises, and all-ins are legal in the abstract game. NULL is only feasible in small nolimit games with low stack sizes.
  • --load-dump=<dump_prefix> - Loads the regrets and (if --no-average is not selected) average strategy from a previous run from the files prefixed by dump_prefix. This prefix should be the full name of the files to be loaded, but without the .regrets or .avg-strategy suffix.
  • --threads=<num_threads> - Specifies the number of threads to use. Additional threads provide a near-linear speed-up in the algorithm, so use as many as you can afford.
  • --status=<dd:hh:mm:ss> - Prints status updates to stderr every dd days, hh hours, mm minutes, and ss seconds.
  • --checkpoint=<start_time[,mult_time[,add_time]]> - Specifies how frequently the program should dump the regrets and average strategy to disk, where start_time, mult_time, and add_time are specified using the dd:hh:mm:ss format. First, the program will dump after start_time has passed from the time the program started. Later dump times depend on whether mult_time and add_time are provided. If mult_time is provided, the next dump will come after start_time * mult_time, then again after start_time * mult_time * mult_time, and so on until the program terminates. If, in addition, add_time is provided, then the next dump will come after start_time * mult_time + add_time, then again after (start_time * mult_time + add_time) * mult_time + add_time, and so on. If mult_time is not specified, then the next dumps will occur at 2 * start_time, then again after 3 * start_time, and so on.
  • --max-walltime=<dd:hh:mm:ss> - Specifies when it is time to perform a final dump of regrets and average strategy to disk. After the final dump, the program is terminated.
  • --no-average - Specifies that no average strategy is to be computed. Currently, average strategy computation in games with more than two players is not supported, and so for such games, this option is mandatory.


Let's start with a very simple example that requires very little computing resources to run:

./pure_cfr games/ test.kuhn --status=1 --max-walltime=30

This runs pure_cfr on unabstracted Kuhn Poker for 30 seconds, with status updates printed every second. In all likelihood, the resulting average strategy should be an approximate Nash equilibrium profile. Once complete, you should have three files that look something like:

  • test.kuhn.iter-???.secs-60.regrets - This is a binary file that contains the accumulated regret for both players at every information set in the game.
  • test.kuhn.iter-???.secs-60.avg-strategy - This is another binary file that specifies the (sampled) average strategy for both players.
  • test.kuhn.iter-???.secs-60.player - This is a human-readable wrapper file that contains information about the command-line arguments specified and the prefix of the binary files. On repeated runs, you can instead pass in --config=test.kuhn.iter-???.secs-60.player rather than specifying the options on the command line. In addition, the DO_AVERAGE line in this file specifies whether the average strategy (DO_AVERAGE TRUE) or the current strategy (DO_AVERAGE FALSE) is to be played and printed by pure_cfr_player and print_player_strategy respectively.

Our second example converges to an equilibrium for abstract heads-up limit Texas hold'em where neither player looks at the cards dealt:

./pure_cfr games/ test.holdem.2pl --rng=TIME --card-abs=BLIND 
--threads=4 --checkpoint=1:0:0 --max-walltime=1:0:0:0

Here, we specify the random number generator to be initialized by the current time, use 4 processors, dump regrets and average strategy to disk every hour, and terminate after 1 day.

Finally, we also provide an example of running pure_cfr on abstract three-player nolimit Texas hold'em:

./pure_cfr games/ test.holdem.3pn --card-abs=BLIND --action-abs=FCPA 
--threads=4 --max-walltime=3:0:0:0 --no-average

In addition to the players not being able to see any cards, the players may also only take the actions fold, call, pot-sized raise, and all-in. The options specify 4 processors to be used and to terminate after 3 days of computation. In addition, no average strategy is computed (recall that this is currently required for games with more than two players). Thus, upon completion, only the .regrets and .player files are written to disk.


This program is a simple tool for displaying the outputted strategy in a human-readable format. Running ./print_player_strategy with no arguments displays the usage.

One argument is required and a second argument is optional. For the required argument, print_player_strategy takes the filename of a .player file generated from pure_cfr. The optional argument --max-round=<round> can be used to only print the strategy up to and including round round.

For example, we can print our Kuhn Poker strategy generated from the example above as follows:

./print_player_strategy test.kuhn.iter-???.secs-60.player

In addition, you can also display the current strategy specified by the regrets. To do so, in the .player file, change the line DO_AVERAGE TRUE to DO_AVERAGE FALSE and run print_player_strategy again. This strategy may not be an approximate equilibrium.

As a second example, to print out the pre-flop strategy of our heads-up limit hold'em profile generated above after one hour, we would run

./print_player_strategy test.holdem.2pl.iter-???.secs-3600.player --max-round=1


This program allows a strategy profile generated by pure_cfr to be played through the ACPC protocol. It is based on example_player from the project_acpc_server framework that communicates back and forth with a dealer program. Similar to the examples provided by the project_acpc_server package, a bash script or something similar is required to run an agent. For example, to run a heads-up limit hold'em profile generated after 1 hour, write a bash script that looks something like this:

cd path/to/open-pure-cfr/
./pure_cfr_player test.holdem.2pl.iter-???.secs-3600.player $1 $2

(Note that ACPC submissions in the past require the cd path/to/open-pure-cfr/ line to be removed). Save this to a file called, say, test.holdem.2pl.iter-??? and make it executable via chmod +x test.holdem.2pl.iter-??? This bash script can then be used to play through the ACPC protocol. For more information on running a match through the ACPC framework, please see the documentation included with the project_acpc_server framework.

Implementation Quirks


When multiple threads are specified for pure_cfr through the --threads option, these threads act independently on the regrets and average strategy in shared memory. Each thread runs independent iterations through the entire tree visited by the sampled pure strategy profile and no safety precautions are taken to avoid the threads from conflicting with one another. This means that if two threads happen to update the regret at the same location at the same time, one of the updates will be overwritten. Because the chances of this occurring in a large game tree are slim, and because billions of iterations are typically required before competent play is reached, a few iterations of lost updates are not a big concern.

Data Types

As mentioned in the opening of this README, Pure CFR stores regrets and the average strategy using integer values rather than floating-point values. In this implementation, each regret entry is stored as an int and each average strategy entry is stored as an int32_t. One exception to this is that each average strategy entry in the preflop round is stored as an int64_t. The reason 64-bit ints are used in the preflop instead of 32-bit ints is because the preflop entries are updated (incremented) most frequently of all the average strategy entries and will be the first to overflow. I found cases where overflow occurred with 32-bit ints in the preflop long before the strategy had finished improving, and so 64-bit ints are now used to prevent early overflow. Since the preflop round is also the smallest, the increase in memory usage in very minor.


First of all, thanks to Oskari Tammelin for sharing his ideas for Pure CFR. I must also thank Neil Burch and Michael Johanson of the Computer Poker Research Group as many of the optimization tricks in this implementation were learned from them.

More Information

A demo of Pure CFR and other variants are provided by Oskari Tammelin.


Feel free to email me at with any questions about this project.