Checking Oxford University Press journal DOIs
Latest commit cd6048f Feb 6, 2017 @rossmounce committed on GitHub Update README.md
Permalink
Failed to load latest commit information.
initial-pilot moved pilot data to pilot folder Feb 6, 2017
main all OUP DOIs I tested Feb 6, 2017
LICENSE Initial commit Jan 24, 2017
README.md Update README.md Feb 6, 2017

README.md

Checking-OUP-DOIs

Cite as: Ross Mounce. (2017). rossmounce/Checking-OUP-DOIs: failwhale [Data set]. Zenodo. http://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.268915 DOI

Intro

I am fed-up of broken DOIs that do not resolve to the article landing page that they should. I therefore decided to test a sample of DOIs across ALL journals that Oxford University Press (OUP) publishes.

Brief description of methods

I tested across 394 OUP journals, using the CrossRef API to return me the 100 most recent DOIs from each journal and the 100 oldest DOIs from each journal. In total 70,907 unique DOIs were checked.

Across this sample I found that 1692 of these DOIs were 'broken' - they did not resolve to an article landing page and instead they return the HTTP 404 Not Found error message. This is 2.386 % of the sample of DOIs tested.

I would expect an error rate of less than 0.5% and competent publishers that care about this issue could ensure that there are no broken DOIs. I wonder if and when OUP might fix all these broken DOIs?

Full list of broken DOIs that are the responsiblity of OUP

/main/all-unique-404-OUP-dois.txt

Full list of 70,907 sampled DOIs

/main/uniq-OUP-dois-tested.txt