Skip to content
This repository

extract autotest support to an rspec-autotest gem #285

Closed
dchelimsky opened this Issue January 21, 2011 · 8 comments

4 participants

David Chelimsky Myron Marston Jon Rowe Aaron Kromer
David Chelimsky
Owner

No description provided.

Myron Marston

@dchelimsky -- I agree 100% with the goal to remove autotest-related code from rspec-core, but it seems like most of the community has moved on to guard and/or watchr at this point--so I'm wondering if we need to preserve the code in a gem at all? (I admit I've never been an autotest user and am not totally sure what extra integration rspec is providing here that a user couldn't easily get on their own using public autotest APIs).

If we do move it into a separate gem, I'd want it to have a "not maintained" notice -- the main thing I'm concerned about here is adding another gem we need to maintain. Extracting it and doing one release to get it out there wouldn't be too bad, though.

David Chelimsky
Owner

re: maintenance, there is very, very little. I'd either commit to maintaining, find someone else to commit to it, or leave it as/is.

Myron Marston

By "leave it as/is" do you mean leave the code in rspec-core? Or extract the code into an external gem, and then leave as-is in that gem?

David Chelimsky
Owner

I mean just leave it in rspec-core. I think minitest should be supported. Guard is supported by that project, so we don't need to worry about it.

Jon Rowe
Collaborator

I'd favour removing autotest support to a separate gem, mainly because ZenTest is a PITA. Most people I know moved onto autotest-standalone and then guard to avoid it.

Aaron Kromer
Collaborator

I'm probably one of the remaining few who still use autotest. I like it because I can have it installed locally and it works without messing with the rest of the project (Guard adds it's own config file). However, that being said, I'm pretty much the only person in the projects I'm involved in who uses it. My co-workers don't have an alternative, they just manually run tests.

That being said I have no real preference if it says or goes. If it makes life easier, I'm :+1: for removal.

Jon Rowe
Collaborator

Just FYI, we are planning to extract support for autotest from rspec into a separate gem come the release of rspec 3

Myron Marston
Owner

Closing as @JonRowe has done this.

Myron Marston myronmarston closed this August 13, 2013
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Something went wrong with that request. Please try again.