Conversation
waynew
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Definitely want a changelog entry or two, and I'll probably want to give this a bit deeper dive, but mostly it looks good 👍
8adee57 to
8a3bfe9
Compare
4642234 to
ee05034
Compare
|
re-run full pre-commit |
4242b8c to
cee8054
Compare
|
Only noticed this PR after it's been merged, but having huge commits like a6ac184 or generic commit messages like "hot fix" or "fix pre" is not good for the general repository hygiene. IMHO those should be either handled properly or be rebased as long as a PR is still WIP. As an outsider I can't really dictate any policies here, but as someone debugging those kind of issues quite often I can surely tell that this makes it really hard in being helpful providing valuable information in bug reports, e.g. pointing out a specific line or so which introduced a certain bug or finding commits by scanning over their messages. |
|
I agree with @eliasp, Saltstack is a great product, but it should have stronger discipline with changes. The biggest issue with saltstack is that every release is like a lottery, it might fix your bug (like currently this one is the biggest one for me), but it can introduce another bug. It makes people hesitant to recommend it, because while it solves a lot of issue and in better ways than other CMs its weak part is stability. This should be actually 2 PRs:
|
|
Agreed. I've cleaned it up to look like this for us: https://gist.github.com/fzipi/af135b5e1f78128ffdafff3f8240caa9 |
|
I see this issue has been closed and changes merged but I'm still seeing this behavior with a RHEL7.9 Workstation OS acting as Salt Master with a Ubuntu 20.04 minion using the Latest salt-master-3002.1-1.el7.noarch.rpm installation, my installs on the RHEL7 system are performed using the SaltStack repo (https://repo.saltstack.com/py3/redhat/7Workstation/x86_64/latest/) via a local Satellite mirror that syncs weekly and my Ubuntu installs are performed using a local mirror that syncs to the latest Ubuntu SaltStack repo. |
|
I recently upgraded to 2019.2.7 from 2019.2.4 for the latest CVE fixes. I am now seeing this hang issue as well. I'm on Ubuntu 18.04. |
Applying this patch has resolved the hang issue for me. Thank you @fzipi for committing it! @jakehilton - applying the patch has made my 2019.2.7 install consistently work without having to disable zmq transport. Regards, |
Fixes bsc#1181368
Fixes bsc#1181368
Fixes bsc#1181368 (cherry picked from commit 4abaaee)
Fixes bsc#1181368
What does this PR do?
stops zmq from deconstructing it self. zmq can deconstruct out of order
What issues does this PR fix or reference?
Fixes:
#57856
#57574
Merge requirements satisfied?
[NOTICE] Bug fixes or features added to Salt require tests.
Commits signed with GPG?
Yes