Allow byArtist to accept a Person as well as a MusicGroup #2020
Comments
|
@vholland so we are saying that our Group Types should be considered restricted for use of MORE THAN 1 PERSON ? I'm fine with that restriction. In some databases, a Music Group could be used for either 1 person or a group. We might want to mention something about our restriction in our MusicGroup and PerformingGroup definitions ? |
|
@thadguidry Yes, that was my thought. Both definitions would need updating. |
|
SGTM. Can you make a PR (with a line giving docs/releases.html text ideally:) |
|
I will tomorrow. I was being lazy and wanted to make sure there were no shouts of "For the love of all that is good in data modeling, NOOOOO!" before I did any work. |
|
When I said tomorrow, I must have meant in the metaphorical sense. Anyway, see PR #2038 |
|
Implemented in release 3.5 |
http://schema.org/MusicAlbum and http://schema.org/MusicRecording use http://schema.org/byArtist to designate the artist credited with an album. Currently, the only acceptable type is http://schema.org/MusicGroup.
While MusicGroup's description says it can be used for individual artists, it is a subtype of http://schema.org/PerformingGroup, which does not.
Given it makes distinguishing groups from individuals, the simplest thing would be to expand the range of
byArtistto accept http://schema.org/Person as well.The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: