diff --git a/gui/saveload-dialog.cpp b/gui/saveload-dialog.cpp
index f159a12ff253..4bf23b897434 100644
--- a/gui/saveload-dialog.cpp
+++ b/gui/saveload-dialog.cpp
@@ -474,14 +474,14 @@ void SaveLoadChooserSimple::reflowLayout() {
 		int thumbY = y + kLineHeight;
 
 		int textLines = 0;
-		if (!_saveDateSupport)
+		if (_saveDateSupport)
 			textLines += 2;
-		if (!_playTimeSupport)
+		if (_playTimeSupport)
 			textLines++;
-		if (_saveDateSupport || _playTimeSupport)
-			textLines--; // add a line of padding at the bottom
+		if (textLines > 0)
+			textLines++; // add a line of padding at the bottom
 
-		_container->resize(x, y, w, h - (kLineHeight * textLines));
+		_container->resize(x, y, w, h + (kLineHeight * textLines));
 		_gfxWidget->resize(thumbX, thumbY, thumbW, thumbH);
 
 		int height = thumbY + thumbH + kLineHeight;
diff --git a/gui/themes/default.inc b/gui/themes/default.inc
index e68ebc05306d..23488a8cd091 100644
--- a/gui/themes/default.inc
+++ b/gui/themes/default.inc
@@ -1829,7 +1829,7 @@ const char *defaultXML1 = "<?xml version = '1.0'?>"
 "<widget name='List' />"
 "<widget name='Thumbnail' "
 "width='180' "
-"height='200' "
+"height='155' "
 "/>"
 "</layout>"
 "<layout type='horizontal' padding='0,0,0,0'>"
diff --git a/gui/themes/scummclassic.zip b/gui/themes/scummclassic.zip
index bff0388d3e81..acb6d20a990b 100644
Binary files a/gui/themes/scummclassic.zip and b/gui/themes/scummclassic.zip differ
diff --git a/gui/themes/scummclassic/classic_layout.stx b/gui/themes/scummclassic/classic_layout.stx
index 9d9fe28a168f..2bb07d914c5b 100644
--- a/gui/themes/scummclassic/classic_layout.stx
+++ b/gui/themes/scummclassic/classic_layout.stx
@@ -1285,7 +1285,7 @@
 				<widget name = 'List' />
 				<widget name = 'Thumbnail'
 						width = '180'
-						height = '200'
+						height = '155'
 				/>
 			</layout>
 			<layout type = 'horizontal' padding = '0, 0, 0, 0'>
diff --git a/gui/themes/scummmodern.zip b/gui/themes/scummmodern.zip
index 983f727f6a04..055c82ad3ce2 100644
Binary files a/gui/themes/scummmodern.zip and b/gui/themes/scummmodern.zip differ
diff --git a/gui/themes/scummmodern/scummmodern_layout.stx b/gui/themes/scummmodern/scummmodern_layout.stx
index 25a95845aa96..0a1c377aea3b 100644
--- a/gui/themes/scummmodern/scummmodern_layout.stx
+++ b/gui/themes/scummmodern/scummmodern_layout.stx
@@ -1299,7 +1299,7 @@
 				<widget name = 'List' />
 				<widget name = 'Thumbnail'
 						width = '180'
-						height = '200'
+						height = '155'
 				/>
 			</layout>
 			<layout type = 'horizontal' padding = '0, 0, 0, 0'>