Yoast Adds More bloat #19
Hmmm, I find this a tricky one, especially since the proposed guidelines sort of encourage in-plugin advertising for premium services.
The tab is not hijacking the dashboard or the rest of the plugin and you don't have to click on the tab as it clearly says what you can expect.
I am much more inclined to remove the star though as that is unnecessary attention seeking.
Here's what I will do: I will add a new option that hides the red star by default
File responsible for adding the Go Premium submenu: admin/class-admin.php (the entire code block from L128-L260)
Would that work for you?