Do you think it is okay to make cookies specifically for my boyfriend but share them with everyone.
I don't know. That seems like a strange plan.
Why do you think that's weird?
It's good to make cookies specifically for your boyfriend, and it's also fine to make them for everyone you know. But if you tell your boyfriend that you made him something special, you shouldn't then turn around and give it away to everyone else, because that will make your boyfriend feel ignored and deceived.
Wow, I just realized but I really don't care about my boyfriend.
Well then you should let him know before he gets more involved with you. But when it comes to the cookies it is good to share with everybody. I am sure that they will like it.