Was it too judgmental of me to think a guy that followed me out of a store to ask if I was single was creepy
How did the guy creep you out?
Well because he was totally following me and hitting on me
He creeps you out because the guy was probably giving off that vibe which your intuition picked up. In other words, it's good to go with your gut feeling. Otherwise, you might end up getting kidnapped by over trusting strangers.
Well I'm glad I shook him off then. I even ended up having a good time that night.
You did the right think by trusting your gut. You really can't be too careful with all the creeps these days. There are great guys out there too, but it can be hard to tell.