Last night I had to watch one of the shows my boyfriend likes instead of what I wanted to watch.
That's sounds nice, was he happy that you watched a show he enjoys?
No, he was upset. I don't think he was that happy with me.
Why would he get upset? I think that it is adorable that you are trying to show interest in some of the shows that he likes.
I guess I criticized the show too much and he wasn't happy about that.
If you're going to try to share one of his interests, try not to criticize something he likes. Think about how you would feel if that happened to you? Understand that he may be sensitive about things like this.