I started pity-dating my boyfriend and fell in love with him
Does it ever make you feel bad?
Well, it's not like I don't feel bad because I do, and he is very caring
I'm glad it worked out, but it's not a good way to start a relationship. You should be honest with your boyfriend about how your feelings evolved.
I'm bad with knowing how people interpret things. Maybe I'll tell him how I felt one day.
That sounds like a good idea. You should be honest with your partner so there's an expectation of trust in your relationship.