I deeply distrust anyone who watches anime
Why don't you trust people that watch anime?
I feel it has more to do with the preference of art more so than the media itself.
You don't have to like anime. But don't judge someone's trustworthiness based on their like of it.
Anime is way too freaky and should be banned from the internet.
It sounds like you are basing your judgement on a stereotype. You should just let people enjoy whatever they like without judging them so harshly.