Skip to content
The limitations of test coverage as a valuable metric for improving quality.
Branch: master
Clone or download
Fetching latest commit…
Cannot retrieve the latest commit at this time.
Type Name Latest commit message Commit time
Failed to load latest commit information.

Test Coverage Doesn't Improve Code Quality

This repository shows the limitations with test coverage as valuable a metric for improving quality. The code in this repository shows there is 100% test coverage for all files, yet there is a huge bug not caught by test coverage.

The Issue

I created an alwaysTwelve function that takes two inputs. If both inputs are true, the value is 12. If both values are false, the value is still 12. You can see how this happens if you check out index.js. These two tests are enough to get 100% coverage.

However, there is a bug. If the inputs are true and false or false and true, the value is not 12, but rather 8 and 18 respectively. Though the coverage was 100%, it isn't enough to tell us there are untested paths through the function.

The Reason

The test.js has only two tests that result in 100% coverage which means it covers every possible branch. However, two tests are not enough to cover all possible outcomes of two conditionals. To do so, you need 2^n tests. For this example, it's 2^2 which is four. If we had tested all possible conditions with four tests, we would have found the bug.

A Note on Testing

This not only speaks to the limitations of test coverage as a metric. It also shows that it is impossible to rely on integration tests to cover all possible conditions in a program.

For instance, if you had 20 if statements spread out across your application, it would take 2^20—or over one million—tests to cover all possible conditions. This would be the slowest test suite in the world, not to mention impossible to manage.

Most importantly, it shows integration tests are a bad solution for preventing bugs from making it into production.

So make smaller contexts to tests. Create well-defined boundaries. Use mostly unit tests. Don't rely on integration tests and test coverage to help you catch bugs because they'll fail you.

You can’t perform that action at this time.