# svlauer/example_sentences

A LaTeX package for linguistic examples
Switch branches/tags
Nothing to show
Fetching latest commit…
Cannot retrieve the latest commit at this time.

# The example_sentences.sty package for typesetting linguistic examples

Linguists (and scholars in related fields) use example sentences in their writing. There is a fairly accepted standard format for presenting those: Example sentences are numbered continuously throughout a document, and optionally can have subexamples, as in (2) below.

The platonic ideal of a LaTeX package for typesetting such examples would provide an environment that behaves as much as possible as LaTeX's built-in enumerate lists (because, at heart, example lists are just ordered lists). So the above examples would be typeset as:

\begin{examples}
\item This is an example.
\item \begin{examples}
\item This a sub-example.
\item This is another sub-example.
\end{examples}
\end{examples}

The existing packages that I know of fall short of this ideal in several ways. While linguex.sty has a concise syntax that is very readable (which is why I favored it for a long time), it betrays its TeX roots through various quirks. For example, it has very particular whitespace requirements, which can make working with it a hassle. The same is true for expex.sty, which also features a rather exotic syntax that I've always found too difficult to remember. And then there is gb4e.sty, which is more LaTeXy then the other ones, but which has a number of strange inconsistencies.

There is an old style file called examples.sty (written by Alexander Holt at the University of Edinburgh) floating around that provides something closer to the ideal, but it has a number of features that I disliked, so I decided to create my own.

## Installation

As usual, simply place example_sentences.sty some place where TeX can find it (the directory where your tex files live will work if all else fails).

Then you can load in the usual way, by placing the following in the preamble of your document:

\usepackage{example_sentences}

There are a number of package options, described below.

## Basic Usage: Zero learning curve

If you know how to use the enumerate environment LaTeX provides, you already know how to use example_sentences. All that changes for basic usage is that you use the examples environment instead of enumerate:

\begin{examples}
\item This is the first example.
\item This is second example.
\end{examples}

This will produce:

Nesting works, of course, up to three levels deep:

\begin{examples}
\item \begin{examples}
\item An example with sub-examples.
\item \begin{examples}
\item And sub-sub examples, like this one.
\item And a second one.
\end{examples}
\end{examples}
\end{examples}

which will render as:

And, as usual, you can give an optional argument to \item to manually specify the label (e.g., if you are quoting an example, and want to use the original example number):

\begin{examples}
\item[(23)] This example will be numbered (23).
\end{examples}

In fact, this is almost all you need to know in order to produce anything that example_sentences can produce. The only additional thing to know is how to typeset diacritic marks indicating acceptability and such. You can do this explicitly by using the \diacritic{} command:

\begin{examples}
\item \diacritic{*} Bad sentence this sounds.
\end{examples}

Diacritics are typeset in the space between example number and example. So the above will render as:

However, explicit use of the \diacritic{} command is discouraged. Instead, you should use (if possible) the convenience macros described below.

## Syntactic sugar: Some enhancements for \item

If you have xparse.sty available, which is contained in l3packages, a number of enhancements of the basic \item command are available.

### Diacritics with \item<>

All variants of \item (including the ones described below) allow for an optional argument in angle brackets containing a diacritic/acceptability mark:

\begin{examples}
\end{examples}

Renders as

If available, this style is preferred over the explicit use of \diacritic{}.

Note: Writing this documentation, it occurs to me that this style will likely wreak havoc when example_sentences is used with the beamer package to produce slide shows. So there is a chance this will change in the future.

### Assigning labels with \item()

The basic \label{} command works as it always does. However, a more convenient way to assign labels to examples is provided. Simply supply the desired label in parentheses after \item:

\begin{examples}
\item(harlem) If you want to go to Harlem, you have to take the A train.
\end{examples}

This is equivalent to:

\begin{examples}
\item\label{harlem} If you want to go to Harlem, you have to take the A train.
\end{examples}

## Individual examples with \begin{example} ... \end{example}

Some users (including me on certain days) will feel uncomfortable with the environment name examples in case there is only one \item. For those users, there is a synonym example, so you can write:

\begin{example}
\item This is an example.
\end{example}

(You will still have to type \item, though. This may change in future releases.)

This is a true alias of the examples environment, so nothing prevents multiple examples in an example environment.

## Referencing examples in the text: \ref{...}, \ex{...}, and \exref{...}

The standard \ref{} command works for examples. However, it produces the (sub)example number without enclosing parentheses. This means that it would have to be used in running text with explicit parentheses:

The sentence in (\ref{harlem}) is curious in that ...

This is by design, because it is sometimes necessary to access the example identifier itself. An example is if one wants to reference a range of sub-examples, as in:

(\ref{imperatives}a-f) show the varied uses of imperatives.

However, the package provides two handy shortcut for example references. Instead of writing (\ref{harlem}), you can simply write either:

The sentence in \exref{harlem} is curious in that ...

or:

The sentence in \ex{harlem} is curious in that ...

And, as an added nicety, you can provide arbitrary material that is appended to the example label as an optional argument:

\ex{imperatives}[a-f] show the varied uses of imperatives.

(The latter form will only work if xparse.sty is available. Otherwise, you can use \ex[a-f]{imperatives}, which will always work.)

## Typesetting dialogues with \begin{conversation} ... \end{conversation}

Semanticists and pragmaticists often need to typeset short dialogues, like this:

If you load example_sentences with the conversations option, a new environment conversations becomes available, and the above can be typeset as:

\begin{examples}
\item(godot)
\begin{conversation}
\item[Estragon:] Nothing to be done.
\item[Vladimir:] I am beginning to come round to that opinion. All my
life I've tried to put it from me, saying Vladimir, be reasonable, you haven't yet tried everything. And I resumed the struggle.

So you are here again.
\item[Estragon:] Am I?
\end{conversation}
\end{examples}

By default, the width of the labels is determined by the widest label. Configuration options are described in the file README-conversations.md

## Glosses

Currently, the package does not provide its own support for aligned glosses. However, you can use cgloss4e.sty from gb4e together with example_sentences. Then you can use the \gll and \glll macros as usual:

\begin{examples}
\item \gll Das ist kein Beispielsatz.\\
This is no   {example sentence}\\
\trans This is not an example sentence.
\end{examples}

Note: As of this writing, there is a problem with diacritic marks. A workaround is described below under "Known Issues". Alternatively, you can use Alexis Dimitriadis's cgloss.sty, which is a hacked version of cgloss4e that prevents the problem.

## Dependencies

• enumitem is the only required dependency.

(In fact, the main part of example_sentences is just a paper-thin wrapper around enumitem's functionality.]

• The xparse package (available as part of l3packages) is not required, but if it is present, it is used to provide some nice syntactic sugar for the \item commands.

Both of these are available in CTAN and should be part of most recent-ish TeX installations, as far as I know.

## Customization

The examples environment is highly configurable. It is simply a clone of the standard enumerate environment, created by enumitem. As a result, all of the configuration options of that package are available.

For example, if you want to add a bit more space between example number for one particular example list (e.g., to accommodate and extra-long diacritic), you can simply pass configuration options to the example environment:

\begin{examples}[leftmargin=2.5\parindent]
\item<*****> Sentence very a bad is.
\end{examples}

If you want to globally change how lists look, you can use enumitem's \setlist command. Note that this command replaces the list configuration, rather than overwriting individual parameters. Hence, the following won't quite work, because it deletes the settings for how example numbers should be formatted, and so forth:

\setlist[examples,1]{leftmargin=2.5\parindent}

To make it easier to overwrite single settings example_sentences adds configuration options that hold the default values. So instead, write:

\setlist[examples,1]{ex1defaults,leftmargin=2.5\parindent}

ex1defaults holds the default settings for examples of level 1, ex2defaults and ex3defaults those for nested example lists. exdefaults holds the defaults for all lists.

For details about the many configuration options, see the documentation of enumitem.

## Package Options

### Short form commands with shortform

If you cannot live without typing \ex in example environments, you can load the package as \usepackage[shortform]{example_sentences}. This enables the short names exe (for the environment) and \ex (for the \item command). So the initial example can then be rewritten as:

\begin{exe}
\ex \begin{exe}
\ex An example with sub-examples.
\ex \begin{exe}
\ex And sub-sub examples, like this one.
\ex And a second one.
\end{exe}
\end{exe}
\end{exe}

\ex supports all the niceties of the \item command (provided xparse is available), so all of \ex<*>, \ex(label)<\#>, and \ex[(2)]<*> are valid.

For obvious reasons, the reference convenience command \ex will not be work within example environments in shortform mode (it continues to work outside of the environment). You can use its alias \exref instead.

The commands introduced by shortform only are synonyms for the longer commands, which remain in place. So long and short form commands can be mixed freely.

### Compatibility options: Turning of convenience commands

One of the aims of this package is to be compatible with as many LaTeX packages as possible. This has limits, obviously, whenever one of the convenience commands are defined (or modified) by another package. For that reason, the convenience commands can be turned off individually, using package options.

#### Leaving \item alone: the normalitem option

To provide the extended behavior for \item described above, LaTeX's own implementation of this command needs to be overwritten (this happens only in example lists, however). If you use any other packages that modify this command (beamer comes to mind), there could be conflicts and other problems.

For this reason, the loading the package with the option normalitem (i.e., \usepackage[normalitem]{example_sentences}) tells the package to not touch the \item command. In this case, the command \exitem can be used in place of \item, which has all of the advanced behavior of \item described above.

#### Turning off reference commands with the noexref and noex options

LaTeX offers various packages (such as cleverref) that improve on reference handling. If you use such a package, you likely have no use for the convenience commands \exref and \ex to produce reference to examples in the running text. You can turn them off by loading the package as:

\usepackage[noexref,noex]{example_sentences}

Indeed, if you are using another reference package, it is recommended that you use this way of loading example_sentences, to avoid cluttering the LaTex namespace.

#### Turning off all enhancements: noexitem and compat

If, for some reason, even the \exitem command creates incompatibilities, you can turn off its functionality with the option noexitem.

This means the invocation

\usepackage[normalitem,noexref,noex,noexitem]{example_sentences}

would leave you with an examples-environment that behaves in all ways like the standard enumerate-environment (besides being customizable via enumitem's options). If you desire this, there is a shortcut, which also prevents some internal processing that might lead to incompatibilities:

\usepackage[compat]{example_sentences}

Note that compat implies normalitem,noexref,noex,noexitem.

### The enumitemize option

Standardly, example_sentences loads the enumitem package with the loadonly option, which ensures that the standard LaTeX lists (enumerate, itemize and description) are not enhanced by enumitem.

If you want to change this, pass the enumitemize option to example_sentences.

### Other options

All options besides the one described above will be passed through to enumitem.

## Known issues

### Beginning an example with [...] or (...)

Many linguists like to start their examples with a description of the context, enclosed in square brackets [...] or, more rarely, parenthes (...). This is fine, but you have to take extra care if you are using \item without any kind of argument (as you also have to do with enumerate lists).

The problem is that, in the following, [This is a description of the context] will be interpreted as the optional argument of \item (since LaTeX ignores spaces before the first argument).

\begin{examples}
\item [This is a description of the context]\\
This is the example.
\end{examples}

To prevent this behavior, simply put a pair of braces around the context description:

\begin{examples}
\item {[This is a description of the context]}\\
This is the example.
\end{examples}

Alternatively (recommended) make sure to give all your examples a label via the convenient \item(...) command. The following will work without problems:

\begin{examples}
\item(mylabel) [This a description of the context]\\
This is the example.
\end{examples}

### Compatibility with beamer

As of version 0.6.0, there is an issue with using example_sentences together with the beamer package. The problem is that beamer defines an example-environment, which clashes with example_sentences.

A work-around is to load beamer with the notheorems-option, like so:

\documentclass[notheorems]{beamer}

This means you have to manually declare any theorem-style environments that you want to use. However, according to the beamer documentation, the package will still apply its enhancements (e.g., boxes) to such manually-defined environments.

Note: In the next (pre-)release, this issue will likely be solved by deprecating the example-alias of the examples-environment.

(Thanks to Shane Steinert-Threlkeld for pointing out this issue, and the current work-around.)

### Overlays with beamer

Even with the notheorems option, there currently is an issue with overlay specifications: Since overlays cause a frame to be typeset more than once, example number will be increased with each overlay.

The only work-arounds at present are (i) avoiding overlays or (ii) specifying manual labels via \item[(label)].

This problem will likely be fixed in the next release by making example_sentences overlay-aware.

(Thanks to Shane Steinert-Threlkeld for pointing out this issue.)

### Diacritics with cgloss4e

In version 0.5.0, this package does not correctly typeset diacritics when used together with cgloss4e.sty. The only workaround is either to use Alexis Dimitriadis's cgloss.sty in place of cgloss4e, or to include the diacritic manually in the glossed sentence, like so:

\begin{examples}
\item
\gll  \diacritic{*} Ungrammatisch dieser ist Satz.\\
{}           Ungrammatical this   is  sentence\\
\trans (intended) This sentence is ungrammatical.'
\end{examples}

With this, the diacritic will be typeset correctly (i.e., set in the space between example and number). I am currently working on a better way around this problem.

### Footnotes

It is custom to number examples in footnotes differently from the main text: Level one examples have lowercase roman numerals as labels, with counting starting anew for each footnote.

This is difficult to achieve in the general case. example_sentences.sty patches the standard LaTeX footnote commands (i.e., \footnote and footnotetext), for all other methods of typesetting notes, you will have to ensure yourself that the command \footnotizeexamples is called at the beginning of each note (or before the first example) and \unfootnotizeexamples is called at the end of each footnote (or after the last example).

Note on implementation: The example environments used in footnotes is in fact entirely different from the main examples (it is just mostly configured in the same way). If you want to modify the appearance of examples in footnotes, you'll need to use \setlist[fnexamples]{} / \setlist[fnexamples,1]{}, etc. Make sure that you do not use the ex1defaults/ex2defaults/ex3defaults keywords in this case, as this will reuse the main counters. Instead, use fnex1defaults/fnex2defaults/fnex3defaults`.