Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Create About page explaining who owns/manages Thunderbird, and relationship to Mozilla #55

Closed
chrisilias opened this issue Aug 2, 2018 · 19 comments

Comments

@chrisilias
Copy link

@chrisilias chrisilias commented Aug 2, 2018

We sometimes come across both users and contributors who say something like "I thought Thunderbird was dead" or in my latest experience "is Mozilla planning on keeping Thunderbird? I remember a while ago they were looking to dump Thunderbird and give it to some other open source organization"

I looked for a page that explains who owns Thunderbird, what the council is, and what the relationship between Thunderbird and Mozilla is, but I couldn't find anything. The closest was this blog post.

I was thinking of creating a support article for it, but I think it would be more appropriate on thunderbird.net.

@wsmwk
Copy link

@wsmwk wsmwk commented Aug 2, 2018

@kewisch
Copy link

@kewisch kewisch commented Aug 3, 2018

We'd have to keep the history short though to avoid tldr. I would very much enjoy having a page that introduces the council, along with a quick mission statement, and said short history.

@ryanleesipes
Copy link
Collaborator

@ryanleesipes ryanleesipes commented Aug 4, 2018

Sounds like an About page is in order.

@markrousell
Copy link

@markrousell markrousell commented Aug 31, 2018

I was going to create a new issue on this subject but I see that we have this one already. I'll just add some further thoughts.

(1) Yes, a 'Governance' section is definitely needed on thunderbird.net. This issue was discussed recently here: https://groups.google.com/d/msg/mozilla.general/rR_3o-tM1uY/aG3OAC6eAgAJ (I see that Wayne has commented above here too).

(2) There is no roadmap or strategy document for Thunderbird on thunderbird.net. As per my comments in http://lists.thunderbird.net/pipermail/maildev_lists.thunderbird.net/2018-August/001262.html it seems to me that the lack of on the website of (a) as above, a governance section (detailing the Council and the ESC, if and when it is properly formed) and (b) a detailed and agreed roadmap for Thunderbird are harming people's perceptions of Thunderbird.

The lack of both these sections/documents is feeding into the "I thought Thunderbird was dead" meme.

I realise that getting a roadmap/strategy document (both a public version and a much more detailed version for developers to follow) is an issue that is outside of the scope of website design and content, but some kind of TB roadmap is surely needed even if it's a pro tem entry until the Council, ESC, or someone can produce such a roadmap.

@jotasprout
Copy link

@jotasprout jotasprout commented Oct 16, 2018

Can I take this on? I've been wanting to get started with contributing to Mozilla forever. Tried very hard to get my foot in with Sea-Monkey but never happened. I'd love to do this.

@mkmelin
Copy link
Contributor

@mkmelin mkmelin commented Oct 17, 2018

@jotasprout great! Please go ahead.
@markrousell I think a roadmap probably doesn't belong on that page, but elsewhere on more developer targetting pages. It also wouldn't be localized etc.

@jotasprout
Copy link

@jotasprout jotasprout commented Oct 17, 2018

Woo-hoo! I am on the case!

@jotasprout
Copy link

@jotasprout jotasprout commented Oct 19, 2018

Should a link to this go under the Thunderbird menu in the top nav? Would changing the name of that menu to "About" be better and call this new page "Who We Are"?

@Sancus
Copy link
Member

@Sancus Sancus commented Oct 20, 2018

Usually this kind of page is called something like "About Us", and yeah I think it should go under the Thunderbird menu. I don't think that the name of that menu should be changed, it links to some very important pages and hovering a menu named "About" to see the Features or Beta pages doesn't make much sense.

@jotasprout
Copy link

@jotasprout jotasprout commented Oct 22, 2018

On the website, the Thunderbird menu contains "Features", "Beta", and "Releases" among other items. In the repo, however, features is a sibling folder to thunderbird. Should this About page be "website/thunderbird/about/index.html" or "website/about/index.html"?

@Sancus
Copy link
Member

@Sancus Sancus commented Oct 22, 2018

website/about/index.html - the /thunderbird/ dir is for stuff related to thunderbird application versions and downloading them specifically.

@mkmelin mkmelin changed the title Create page explaining who owns/manages Thunderbird, and relationship to Mozilla Create About page explaining who owns/manages Thunderbird, and relationship to Mozilla Nov 16, 2018
@ryanleesipes
Copy link
Collaborator

@ryanleesipes ryanleesipes commented Nov 28, 2018

@jotasprout are you still looking at this? We should sync up on what content you need from us!

@markrousell
Copy link

@markrousell markrousell commented Mar 3, 2019

@markrousell I think a roadmap probably doesn't belong on that page, but elsewhere on more developer targetting pages. It also wouldn't be localized etc.

(Apologies for the delay in replying!)

Exactly where a roadmap should go is an important question but a roadmap is definitely important not just for devs or wouldbe devs but for end users themselves and, critically, for influencers.

People (both end users and those who influence them or who choose software for end users to actually use) badly need to know that a project is alive, healthy, and has a clearly defined future that people are working towards. Ways to do this include a clearly-visible roadmap, together with achievements ticked off (or otherwise clearly visible) as they are reached.

A roadmap is a marketing tool for the general public (and businesses). It's not just something of interest to developers.

@ryanleesipes
Copy link
Collaborator

@ryanleesipes ryanleesipes commented Mar 19, 2019

#94 is a good first step to this. Could use some more work though.

@ryanleesipes ryanleesipes self-assigned this Mar 19, 2019
@wsmwk wsmwk mentioned this issue Mar 20, 2019
@Sancus Sancus closed this in 5390c79 Mar 28, 2019
@Sancus
Copy link
Member

@Sancus Sancus commented Mar 28, 2019

https://www-stage.thunderbird.net/en-US/about/

This is now on stage, last chance for any critical feedback.

@ryanleesipes Actually, I can't remember if we decided to localize this or not. I think maybe yes?

@wsmwk
Copy link

@wsmwk wsmwk commented Mar 28, 2019

Third sentence under TB and foundation seems awkward, in part because it is unclear whether the part after the dash refers to MoFo or MoCo. Unclear how best to improve it - maybe something like "The Foundation is also the sole shareholder in the Mozilla Corporation; the Foundation's focus is on advocacy issues and keeping the Internet healthy, whereas the Corporation's focus is on developing and delivering Firefox."?

The Foundation is also the sole shareholder in the Mozilla Corporation, the maker of Firefox - but has its focus on advocacy issues and keeping the Internet healthy.

@Sancus
Copy link
Member

@Sancus Sancus commented Mar 28, 2019

Third sentence under TB and foundation seems awkward, in part because it is unclear whether the part after the dash refers to MoFo or MoCo.

This didn't really bother me, but, I think you can increase clarity here just by moving the order around ->

The Foundation is focused on advocacy issues and keeping the Internet healthy, but is also the sole shareholder in the maker of Firefox, the Mozilla Corporation.

@wsmwk
Copy link

@wsmwk wsmwk commented Mar 28, 2019

@Sancus great suggestion.

@Sancus
Copy link
Member

@Sancus Sancus commented Mar 30, 2019

I edited that Mozilla Foundation paragraph to make it flow better and not repeat "The (Mozilla) Foundation" so many times.

I also pulled URLs out of the strings so we can change them without blowing up l10n, added a wiki URL function and removed newlines from the strings because gettext picks them up.

I also added a Trello task to myself to document all the quirks of adding pages to the website in more detail. Even I forget things sometimes.

The page is submitted for localization, I will probably leave it on stage only for a week or so to give localizers some time to do their thing before it goes live.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Linked pull requests

Successfully merging a pull request may close this issue.

None yet
8 participants