The base R boxplot has additional control over several graphical features of the boxplots compared to geom_boxplot(). I've searched the issues if this has been mentioned before, but couldn't find it, so I'll summarise here.
These features are:
- Staples, the little horizontal lines at the end of the whiskers. Along with staple parameters:
staplewex Size of staples relative to box widthstaplelty Linetype of staplesstaplelwd Linewidth of staplesstaplecol Colour of staples
- Whisker parameters:
whisklty Linetype of whiskerswhisklwd Linewidth of whiskerswhiskcol Colour of whiskers
- Median line parameters:
- Option for drawing a point at the median, along with parameters:
medpch shape of the median pointmedcex size of the median pointmedbg fill of the median point
A little bit to my surprise, geom_boxplot() does support the medlwd linewidth of the median line through the fatten argument that is documented in geom_crossbar() (but not in geom_boxplot()).
Probably, it isn't worthwhile to support the median point, because it is easily added with stat_summary(fun = median).
However, I do think it might be worthwhile to implement staples and the extra parameters for whiskers and the median line. These should use e.g. whisker.linetype, median.colour etc. instead of the base R names. Moreover, an alias for fatten might help make it more clear that this refers to the median line.
I don't think these should be mapped aesthetics, rather I'd see them as static parameters similar to the outlier parameters that are inherited from the main boxplot aesthetics by default.
If the maintainers agree, I can put together a PR to review.
The base R boxplot has additional control over several graphical features of the boxplots compared to
geom_boxplot(). I've searched the issues if this has been mentioned before, but couldn't find it, so I'll summarise here.These features are:
staplewexSize of staples relative to box widthstapleltyLinetype of staplesstaplelwdLinewidth of staplesstaplecolColour of stapleswhiskltyLinetype of whiskerswhisklwdLinewidth of whiskerswhiskcolColour of whiskersmedltyLinetype of median linemedcolThe colour of the median line (see also Allow independent color modification of median in boxplot #3459)medpchshape of the median pointmedcexsize of the median pointmedbgfill of the median pointA little bit to my surprise,
geom_boxplot()does support themedlwdlinewidth of the median line through thefattenargument that is documented ingeom_crossbar()(but not ingeom_boxplot()).Probably, it isn't worthwhile to support the median point, because it is easily added with
stat_summary(fun = median).However, I do think it might be worthwhile to implement staples and the extra parameters for whiskers and the median line. These should use e.g.
whisker.linetype,median.colouretc. instead of the base R names. Moreover, an alias forfattenmight help make it more clear that this refers to the median line.I don't think these should be mapped aesthetics, rather I'd see them as static parameters similar to the outlier parameters that are inherited from the main boxplot aesthetics by default.
If the maintainers agree, I can put together a PR to review.