configure gutter width #27

joeyh opened this Issue Mar 12, 2013 · 7 comments


None yet
3 participants

joeyh commented Mar 12, 2013

The plugin adds a 2 character wide gutter, but as I have it only configured to show git and quickfix signs, all signs appear in the first column, and the second is unused. I'd like to turn it off to save screen space, but I cannot find a way to do it in the documentation or source.


tomtom commented Mar 12, 2013

I could be wrong but I don't think users can configure the width of the
sign column. quickfixsigns itself doesn't do anything about the sign
column. IIRC the sign column is shown as soon as you place a sign. You
might want to ask at the vim user group if there is a way to configure
the width of the sign column. You're right that quickfixsigns makes use
only of one cell for textual signs. Images are displayed in 2 cell
width, though. I guess that's also the reason why the column is 2 cells

freeo referenced this issue in neovim/neovim Jul 24, 2014


sign column: variable width #990


vhda commented Jul 28, 2015

Why not merging the symbols?
For example, if git is set in the first column and quickfix in the second all information would available, don't you think?


tomtom commented Jul 29, 2015

VIM's sign API doesn't provide for such a thing. You can only display one sign per line. You could of course write a library that handles this for you and somehow merges multiple signs on a line (and quickfixsigns was originally intended as such an approach) but then all plugins would have to use this library, which won't happen unless it becomes part of standard vim. And this most likely won't happen either.


vhda commented Jul 29, 2015

But isn't quickfixsigns setting the sign value to "-1" when one line was deleted when compared with git HEAD? And if it is, why can't it set it to "+A" when there is a new line and the mark A?


tomtom commented Jul 30, 2015

You'd have to define new signs for all possible combinations but you
still wouldn't be able to deal with graphical signs. A better approach
would be to rotate signs at the same line but that's complex too.

IMHO it's a waste of time trying to display multiple signs in the sign
column. VIM isn't prepared for that. Quickfixsign will display mulitple
signs in the balloon text, which IMHO is sufficient. Most other editors
I know handle this problem similar to VIM.


vhda commented Jul 31, 2015

I understand your point and I agree that graphical signs are not easy to deal with, but I think you are focusing too much on gvim, which I assume is what you are using.
With standard vim there are no balloons and there are only text signs. Since there is no icon limitation and there are 2 columns available I really think this plugin would benefit from this by allowing "merging" up to 2 signs.


tomtom commented Aug 1, 2015

I don't think it's doable so that the result justifies time & effort that would goes into implementing this from a vimscript plugin. One could of course change the VIM source code to do what you want but this would have to be implemented by somebody else who has too much spare time.

tomtom closed this Aug 1, 2015

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment