diff --git a/dwbp-implementation-report.html b/dwbp-implementation-report.html index 3abe998..f28ebee 100644 --- a/dwbp-implementation-report.html +++ b/dwbp-implementation-report.html @@ -45,7 +45,7 @@ {"ProvidedBy": "Williams Alc\u00e2ntara", "OrganizationName": "Data.gov.uk", "DataCatalogue": "CKAN", "Category": "Dataset", "OrganizationSite": "http://data.gov.uk", "Link": "https://data.gov.uk/dataset/land-registry-monthly-price-paid-data", "Reach": "UK", "ID": "D14", "Domain": "Government Data\n", "WBGThesaurus": "http://vocabulary.worldbank.org/thesaurus/1627071"}, {"ProvidedBy": "Williams Alc\u00e2ntara", "OrganizationName": "Data.gov.uk", "DataCatalogue": "CKAN", "Category": "Dataset", "OrganizationSite": "http://data.gov.uk", "Link": "https://data.gov.uk/dataset/uk-civil-service-high-earners/", "Reach": "UK", "ID": "D15", "Domain": "Government data\n", "WBGThesaurus": "http://vocabulary.worldbank.org/thesaurus/1627072"}, {"ProvidedBy": "Phil Archer", "OrganizationName": "Datawheel, Deloitte", "DataCatalogue": "no", "Category": "Dataset", "OrganizationSite": "https://datausa.io/", "Link": "https://datausa.io/about/datasets/", "Reach": "USA", "ID": "D16", "Domain": "Government Data\n", "WBGThesaurus": "http://vocabulary.worldbank.org/thesaurus/1627071"}, - {"ProvidedBy": "Markus Freudenberg", "OrganizationName": "DBpedia", "DataCatalogue": "no", "Category": "Dataset", "OrganizationSite": "https://dbpedia.org", "Link": "https://dbpedia.org", "Reach": "Global", "ID": "D17", "Domain": "Cross-domain", "WBGThesaurus": ""}, + {"ProvidedBy": "Markus Freudenberg", "OrganizationName": "DBpedia", "DataCatalogue": "proprietary (uses DCAT)", "Category": "Dataset", "OrganizationSite": "https://dbpedia.org", "Link": "https://dbpedia.org", "Reach": "Global", "ID": "D17", "Domain": "Cross-domain", "WBGThesaurus": ""}, {"ProvidedBy": "Bernadette loscio", "OrganizationName": "EMPREL", "DataCatalogue": "CKAN", "Category": "Dataset", "OrganizationSite": "http://www.emprel.gov.br/", "Link": "http://dados.recife.pe.gov.br/dataset/monitoramento-das-areas-de-riscos", "Reach": "Brazil", "ID": "D18", "Domain": "Government Data\n", "WBGThesaurus": "http://vocabulary.worldbank.org/thesaurus/1627071"}, {"ProvidedBy": "Antoine Isaac", "OrganizationName": "Europeana", "DataCatalogue": "proprietary", "Category": "Data Portal", "OrganizationSite": "http://www.europeana.eu/", "Link": "http://labs.europeana.eu/", "Reach": "Europe", "ID": "D19", "Domain": "Cultural Heritage\n", "WBGThesaurus": "http://vocabulary.worldbank.org/thesaurus/1527374"}, {"ProvidedBy": "Milos Jovanovik", "OrganizationName": "Faculty of Computer Science and Engineering - Skopje, Macedonia", "DataCatalogue": "CKAN (datahub)", "Category": "Dataset", "OrganizationSite": "http://finki.ukim.mk/en", "Link": "https://datahub.io/dataset/linked-drugs", "Reach": "", "ID": "D20", "Domain": "Pharmaceutical Consumption", "WBGThesaurus": "http://vocabulary.worldbank.org/thesaurus/1850134"}, @@ -87,8 +87,7 @@ {"ProvidedBy": "Newton Calegari", "OrganizationName": "Wikidata", "DataCatalogue": "no", "Category": "Dataset", "OrganizationSite": "http://wikidata.org", "Link": "https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Wikidata:Data_access", "Reach": "Global", "ID": "D56", "Domain": "Cross-domain", "WBGThesaurus": ""}, {"ProvidedBy": "Bernadette", "OrganizationName": "World Bank", "DataCatalogue": "proprietary", "Category": "Dataset", "OrganizationSite": "http://data.worldbank.org/", "Link": "http://data.worldbank.org/data-catalog/ed-stats", "Reach": "Global", "ID": "D57", "Domain": "Education", "WBGThesaurus": "http://vocabulary.worldbank.org/thesaurus/1490669"}, {"ProvidedBy": "Ghislain Atemezing", "OrganizationName": "Southampton Open Data Service", "DataCatalogue": "proprietary", "Category": "Data Portal", "OrganizationSite": "http://data.southampton.ac.uk/", "Link": "http://id.southampton.ac.uk/dataset/university-timetable", "Reach": "", "ID": "D58", "Domain": "Educational Administration", "WBGThesaurus": "http://vocabulary.worldbank.org/thesaurus/1492991"}, - {"ProvidedBy": "Markus Freudenberg", "OrganizationName": "DBpedia", "DataCatalogue": "no", "Category": "Dataset", "OrganizationSite": "https://dbpedia.org", "Link": "http://wiki.dbpedia.org/projects/dbpedia-dataid#", "Reach": "Global", "ID": "D59", "Domain": "Cross-domain", "WBGThesaurus": ""}, - {"ProvidedBy": "Eric Stephan", "OrganizationName": "CEDA - Center for Environmenatl Data Analysis", "DataCatalogue": "yes", "Category": "Dataset", "OrganizationSite": "http://www.ceda.ac.uk/", "Link": "http://catalogue.ceda.ac.uk/uuid/8fb58cd1a37b4ade8cb5a3f62a240574", "Reach": "", "ID": "D60", "Domain": "Environment", "WBGThesaurus": "http://vocabulary.worldbank.org/thesaurus/1490737"}] + {"ProvidedBy": "Eric Stephan", "OrganizationName": "CEDA - Center for Environmenatl Data Analysis", "DataCatalogue": "yes", "Category": "Dataset", "OrganizationSite": "http://www.ceda.ac.uk/", "Link": "http://catalogue.ceda.ac.uk/uuid/8fb58cd1a37b4ade8cb5a3f62a240574", "Reach": "", "ID": "D59", "Domain": "Environment", "WBGThesaurus": "http://vocabulary.worldbank.org/thesaurus/1490737"}] datasetPortalsTable = document.getElementById('table-datasetportals'); var tbody = datasetPortalsTable.getElementsByTagName('tbody')[0]; @@ -111,41 +110,41 @@ function createBpEvidenceTable(){ bpEvidenceJson = [ - {"bp": "BP1", "evidence": ["D02", "D03", "D04", "D06", "D08", "D11", "D12", "D13", "D18", "D19", "D20", "D21", "D22", "D31", "D38", "D45", "D49", "D50", "D51", "D52", "D53", "D55", "D55", "D56", "D57", "D58", "D59", "D60", "R10","G03", "G04", "G07", "G08", "G09", "G11", "G13", "G14", "G15", "G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP2", "evidence": ["D02", "D06", "D08", "D11", "D12", "D13", "D19", "D20", "D21", "D22", "D23", "D38", "D45", "D49", "D50", "D51", "D52", "D53", "D54", "D56", "D57", "D58", "D59", "D60", "R10","G01", "G07", "G08", "G11", "G13", "G14", "G15", "G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP3", "evidence": ["D04", "D06", "D08", "D17", "D20", "D21", "D31", "D45", "D49", "D50", "D52", "D59", "D60", "R10","G01", "G02", "G03", "G07", "G08", "G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP4", "evidence": ["D02", "D03", "D04", "D05", "D08", "D11", "D12", "D13", "D20", "D22", "D25", "D38", "D45", "D49", "D51", "D52", "D53", "D55", "D56", "D58", "D59", "D60", "G01", "G02", "G03", "G08", "G10", "G13", "G15", "G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP5", "evidence": ["D01", "D06", "D11", "D12", "D13", "D16", "D20", "D21", "D24", "D38", "D52", "D53", "D58", "D59", "R11","G01", "G03", "G08", "G13", "G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP6", "evidence": ["D06", "D08", "D13", "D16", "D49", "D50", "D52", "D54", "D58", "D60", "R11","G03", "G10", "G15", "G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP7", "evidence": ["D01", "D02", "D05", "D08", "D12", "D13", "D20", "D41", "D45", "D46", "D47", "D50", "D51", "D59", "D60", "R11","R12", "G07", "G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP8", "evidence": ["D12", "D13", "D20", "D45", "D46", "R04","R10","R12", "G08", "G11", "G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP9", "evidence": ["D03", "D04", "D05", "D11", "D12", "D13", "D14", "D20", "D21", "D22", "D41", "D49", "D51", "D52", "D53", "D55", "D56", "D57", "D58", "D59", "D60", "R10", "G01", "G02", "G03", "G04", "G06", "G07", "G11", "G13", "G14", "G15", "G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP10", "evidence": ["D02", "D03", "D04", "D05", "D06", "D08", "D11", "D13", "D14", "D16", "D17", "D19", "D20", "D21", "D37", "D49", "D51", "D52", "D53", "D55","D58", "G04", "G08", "G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP11", "evidence": ["D06", "D11", "D13", "D14", "D20", "D32", "D59", "G01", "G02", "G07", "G15", "G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP12", "evidence": ["D01", "D02", "D03", "D04", "D05", "D08", "D11", "D12", "D13", "D16", "D17", "D19", "D20", "D21", "D22", "D28", "D30", "D37", "D45", "D49", "D51", "D52", "D53", "D55", "D56", "D57", "D58", "D60", "G02", "G04", "G07", "G08", "G10", "G11", "G13", "G14", "G15", "G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP13", "evidence": ["D03", "D04", "D06", "D08", "D11", "D18", "D20", "D21", "D51", "D53", "D55", "D56", "D59","G13"]}, + {"bp": "BP1", "evidence": ["D02", "D03", "D04", "D06", "D08", "D11", "D12", "D13", "D17", "D18", "D19", "D20", "D21", "D22", "D31", "D38", "D45", "D49", "D50", "D51", "D52", "D53", "D55", "D55", "D56", "D57", "D58", "D59", "R10","G03", "G04", "G07", "G08", "G09", "G11", "G13", "G14", "G15", "G16"]}, + {"bp": "BP2", "evidence": ["D02", "D06", "D08", "D11", "D12", "D13", "D17", "D19", "D20", "D21", "D22", "D23", "D38", "D45", "D49", "D50", "D51", "D52", "D53", "D54", "D56", "D57", "D58", "D59", "R10","G01", "G07", "G08", "G11", "G13", "G14", "G15", "G16"]}, + {"bp": "BP3", "evidence": ["D04", "D06", "D08", "D17", "D20", "D21", "D31", "D45", "D49", "D50", "D52", "D59", "R10","G01", "G02", "G03", "G07", "G08", "G16"]}, + {"bp": "BP4", "evidence": ["D02", "D03", "D04", "D05", "D08", "D11", "D12", "D13", "D17", "D20", "D22", "D25", "D38", "D45", "D49", "D51", "D52", "D53", "D55", "D56", "D58", "D59", "G01", "G02", "G03", "G08", "G10", "G13", "G15", "G16"]}, + {"bp": "BP5", "evidence": ["D01", "D06", "D11", "D12", "D13", "D16", "D17", "D20", "D21", "D24", "D38", "D52", "D53", "D58", "R11","G01", "G03", "G08", "G13", "G16"]}, + {"bp": "BP6", "evidence": ["D06", "D08", "D13", "D16", "D49", "D50", "D52", "D54", "D58", "D59", "R11","G03", "G10", "G15", "G16"]}, + {"bp": "BP7", "evidence": ["D01", "D02", "D05", "D08", "D12", "D13", "D17", "D20", "D41", "D45", "D46", "D47", "D50", "D51", "D59", "R11","R12", "G07", "G16"]}, + {"bp": "BP8", "evidence": ["D12", "D13", "D17", "D20", "D45", "D46", "R04","R10","R12", "G08", "G11", "G16"]}, + {"bp": "BP9", "evidence": ["D03", "D04", "D05", "D11", "D12", "D13", "D14", "D17", "D20", "D21", "D22", "D41", "D49", "D51", "D52", "D53", "D55", "D56", "D57", "D58", "D59", "R10", "G01", "G02", "G03", "G04", "G06", "G07", "G11", "G13", "G14", "G15", "G16"]}, + {"bp": "BP10", "evidence": ["D02", "D03", "D04", "D05", "D06", "D08", "D11", "D13", "D14", "D16", "D17", "D19", "D20", "D21", "D37", "D49", "D51", "D52", "D53", "D55", "D58", "G04", "G08", "G16"]}, + {"bp": "BP11", "evidence": ["D06", "D11", "D13", "D14", "D17", "D20", "D32", "G01", "G02", "G07", "G15", "G16"]}, + {"bp": "BP12", "evidence": ["D01", "D02", "D03", "D04", "D05", "D08", "D11", "D12", "D13", "D16", "D17", "D19", "D20", "D21", "D22", "D28", "D30", "D37", "D45", "D49", "D51", "D52", "D53", "D55", "D56", "D57", "D58", "D59", "G02", "G04", "G07", "G08", "G10", "G11", "G13", "G14", "G15", "G16"]}, + {"bp": "BP13", "evidence": ["D03", "D04", "D06", "D08", "D11", "D17", "D18", "D20", "D21", "D51", "D53", "D55", "D56", "G13"]}, {"bp": "BP14", "evidence": ["D01", "D02", "D03", "D04", "D05", "D06", "D12", "D13", "D14", "D17", "D19", "D22", "D23", "D37", "D45", "D49", "D51", "D52", "D53", "D55", "D56", "D57", "R10","G02", "G07", "G08", "G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP15", "evidence": ["D02", "D03", "D04", "D06", "D08", "D11", "D12", "D13", "D17", "D19", "D20", "D21", "D22", "D42", "D49", "D50", "D51", "D52", "D53", "D55", "D58", "D60", "R10","G01", "G02", "G07", "G08", "G10", "G11", "G13", "G14", "G15", "G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP16", "evidence": ["D03", "D04", "D06", "D11", "D16", "D19", "D20", "D21", "D37", "D45", "D49", "D50", "D51", "D52", "D53", "D55", "D58", "G07", "G08"]}, - {"bp": "BP17", "evidence": ["D01", "D05", "D11", "D13", "D18", "D20", "D44", "D48", "D49", "D52", "D53", "D56", "D57", "D58", "D60", "G04", "G08", "G16"]}, + {"bp": "BP15", "evidence": ["D02", "D03", "D04", "D06", "D08", "D11", "D12", "D13", "D17", "D19", "D20", "D21", "D22", "D42", "D49", "D50", "D51", "D52", "D53", "D55", "D58", "D59", "R10","G01", "G02", "G07", "G08", "G10", "G11", "G13", "G14", "G15", "G16"]}, + {"bp": "BP16", "evidence": ["D03", "D04", "D06", "D11", "D16", "D17", "D19", "D20", "D21", "D37", "D45", "D49", "D50", "D51", "D52", "D53", "D55", "D58", "G07", "G08"]}, + {"bp": "BP17", "evidence": ["D01", "D05", "D11", "D13", "D17", "D18", "D20", "D44", "D48", "D49", "D52", "D53", "D56", "D57", "D58", "D59", "G04", "G08", "G16"]}, {"bp": "BP18", "evidence": ["D03", "D04", "D05", "D11", "D13", "D16", "D17", "D29", "D33", "D44", "D45", "D49", "D52", "D53", "D55", "R05","G08", "G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP19", "evidence": ["D03", "D04", "D08", "D13", "D19", "D20", "D21", "D49", "D51", "D53", "D55", "D56", "D57", "D58", "R06","R07","G07", "G15", "G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP20", "evidence": ["D05", "D22", "D45", "R01","R14","G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP21", "evidence": ["D01", "D05", "D06", "D11", "D12", "D13", "D18", "D19", "D21", "D22", "D38", "D45", "D49", "D51", "D53", "D57", "D58", "D60", "G08", "G12", "G15", "G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP22", "evidence": ["D05", "D06", "D43", "D45", "D54", "D56", "D60", "G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP23", "evidence": ["D02", "D03", "D04", "D11", "D12", "D13", "D14", "D15", "D16", "D19", "D20", "D21", "D22", "D28", "D44", "D45", "D48", "D49", "D52", "D53", "D55", "D56", "D57", "D60", "R15","G04", "G05", "G08"]}, + {"bp": "BP19", "evidence": ["D03", "D04", "D08", "D13", "D17", "D19", "D20", "D21", "D49", "D51", "D53", "D55", "D56", "D57", "D58", "R06","R07","G07", "G15", "G16"]}, + {"bp": "BP20", "evidence": ["D05", "D17", "D22", "D45", "R01","R14","G16"]}, + {"bp": "BP21", "evidence": ["D01", "D05", "D06", "D11", "D12", "D13", "D17", "D18", "D19", "D21", "D22", "D38", "D45", "D49", "D51", "D53", "D57", "D58", "D59", "G08", "G12", "G15", "G16"]}, + {"bp": "BP22", "evidence": ["D05", "D06", "D43", "D45", "D54", "D56", "D59", "G16"]}, + {"bp": "BP23", "evidence": ["D02", "D03", "D04", "D11", "D12", "D13", "D14", "D15", "D16", "D17", "D19", "D20", "D21", "D22", "D28", "D44", "D45", "D48", "D49", "D52", "D53", "D55", "D56", "D57", "D59", "R15","G04", "G05", "G08"]}, {"bp": "BP24", "evidence": ["D03", "D04", "D12", "D13", "D14", "D15", "D16", "D17", "D19", "D20", "D21", "D22", "D44", "D45", "D49", "D53", "D55", "R16"]}, {"bp": "BP25", "evidence": ["D02", "D07", "D12", "D13", "D14", "D15", "D16", "D17", "D19", "D21", "D22", "D27", "D37", "D45", "D48", "D49", "D52", "D53", "D56", "D57", "R15"]}, - {"bp": "BP26", "evidence": ["D03", "D04", "D11", "D14", "D15", "D21", "D45", "D53", "D55", "R17"]}, - {"bp": "BP27", "evidence": ["D04", "D11", "D17", "D60", "R10", "G01", "G11", "G14", "G16", "R22"]}, + {"bp": "BP26", "evidence": ["D03", "D04", "D11", "D14", "D15", "D17", "D21", "D45", "D53", "D55", "R17"]}, + {"bp": "BP27", "evidence": ["D04", "D11", "D17", "D59", "R10", "G01", "G11", "G14", "G16", "R22"]}, {"bp": "BP28", "evidence": ["D11", "D58", "R08","R10"]}, {"bp": "BP29", "evidence": ["D01", "D02", "D04", "D05", "D06", "D12", "D13", "D14", "D15", "D17","D19", "D20", "D21", "D36", "D45", "D51", "D52", "D53", "D56", "D57", "D58", "G01", "G04", "G08", "G11", "G12", "G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP30", "evidence": ["D05", "D13", "D14", "D15", "D17", "D20", "D34", "D51", "D60", "R13","G04", "G16"]}, + {"bp": "BP30", "evidence": ["D05", "D13", "D14", "D15", "D17", "D20", "D34", "D51", "D59", "R13","G04", "G16"]}, {"bp": "BP31", "evidence": ["D04", "D05", "D16", "D17", "D19", "D20", "D49", "R03","G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP32", "evidence": ["D01", "D02", "D05", "D16", "D19", "D20", "D26", "D45", "D52", "D53", "D55", "D57", "D58", "R02"]}, + {"bp": "BP32", "evidence": ["D01", "D02", "D05", "D16", "D17", "D19", "D20", "D26", "D45", "D52", "D53", "D55", "D57", "D58", "R02"]}, {"bp": "BP33", "evidence": ["D06", "D19", "D35", "D45", "D49", "D52", "R09","G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP34", "evidence": ["D04", "D05", "D09", "D11", "D16", "D17", "D20", "D40", "D45", "D49", "D52", "D55", "D56", "D58", "D60", "G04", "G08", "G09", "G15", "G16"]}, - {"bp": "BP35", "evidence": ["D01", "D04", "D06", "D11", "D16", "D17", "D19", "D20", "D21", "D38", "D45", "D49", "D52", "D57", "D58", "D59", "D60", "G16"]}]; + {"bp": "BP34", "evidence": ["D04", "D05", "D09", "D11", "D16", "D17", "D20", "D40", "D45", "D49", "D52", "D55", "D56", "D58", "D59", "G04", "G08", "G09", "G15", "G16"]}, + {"bp": "BP35", "evidence": ["D01", "D04", "D06", "D11", "D16", "D17", "D19", "D20", "D21", "D38", "D45", "D49", "D52", "D57", "D58", "D59", "D59", "G16"]}]; bpEvidenceTable = document.getElementById('table-bp-evidence'); var tbody = bpEvidenceTable.getElementsByTagName('tbody')[0]; @@ -416,7 +415,7 @@

Datasets, Data portals and Vocabularies

Evidence URI Category Domain - Data Catalog? + Data Catalog?* @@ -424,6 +423,7 @@

Datasets, Data portals and Vocabularies

+

* This column indicates if a data catalog solution is used to provide the data. The data catalog can be based on an existing solution like CKAN or can be a proprietary one. @@ -569,7 +569,7 @@

DWBP and Data Catalogs

Concerning BP27 none of the data catalog solutions implement it. In general, when a dataset is not available then just a 404 error message is returned.

-

Some Best Practices related to metadata are partially implemented by the data catalog solutions. Note that almost all data catalog solutions are compatible with DCAT, which means that metadata covered by DCAT may be completely or partially available both in human-readable and machine-readable formats. In general, it means that just a human-readable or a machine-readable version of the metadata is available, as detailed in the following. +

Some Best Practices related to metadata are partially implemented by the data catalog solutions. Note that almost all data catalog solutions are compatible with DCAT, which means that metadata covered by DCAT may be completely or partially available both in human-readable and machine-readable formats. In general, it means that just a human-readable or a machine-readable version of the metadata is available, as detailed in the following.

-

As a general analysis with regards to the Data on the Web Challenges, we can say that Metadata, Data Licenses and Data Formats challenges are a main concern of the data catalog solutions. The Data Access challenge has also been recognized as an important one except when it concerns real-time data. The use of Data Access APIs is a consensus. The major data catalog solutions also deal with the Data Identification challenge, however just part of the problem has been solved. The Data Vocabularies challenge has also been considered as an important one since data catalog solutions reuse existing vocabularies, e.g. DCAT, when publishing metadata about the data catalogs. Other challenges like Data Provenance, Data Versioning and Feedback have been superficially dealt with in the data catalog solutions. In general, Data Quality, Data Preservation, Data Enrichment and Data Republications are challenges still not explored by the major data catalog solutions.

+

As a general analysis with regards to the Data on the Web Challenges, we can say that Metadata, Data Licenses and Data Formats challenges are a main concern of the data catalog solutions. The Data Access challenge has also been recognized as an important one except when it concerns real-time data. The use of Data Access APIs is a consensus. The major data catalog solutions also deal with the Data Identification challenge, however just part of the problem has been solved. The Data Vocabularies challenge has also been considered as an important one since data catalog solutions reuse existing vocabularies, e.g. DCAT, when publishing metadata about the data catalogs. Other challenges like Data Provenance, Data Versioning and Feedback have been superficially dealt with in the data catalog solutions. In general, Data Quality, Data Preservation, Data Enrichment and Data Republications are challenges still not explored by the major data catalog solutions.