is tts:textShadow required? #13
Thanks, I was just about to open the very same issue! The question in summary is: if
Mentioning @mikedo who was asked about this in the (now merged) pull request, to alert him to the fact that the discussion has moved.
The Working Group just discussed
The full IRC log of that discussion<nigel> Topic: is tts:textShadow required? imsc-vnext-reqs#13
<nigel> github: https://github.com//issues/13
<nigel> Pierre: It sounds like textShadow and textOutline have different sweet spots and don't conflict.
<nigel> .. textShadow is supported by CSS so my plan is to support both in IMSC 1.1.
<nigel> Nigel: It's a small point, but do we need to point out in the spec in an informative note why both are needed?
<nigel> Pierre: Good examples as in TTML2 will show the difference. They're really different effects.
<nigel> Cyril: I definitely don't want to remove textOutline because we're using it.
<nigel> Pierre: I've also heard the same for textShadow.
<nigel> RESOLUTION: textShadow is required, no spec change needed.