Success Criterion 1.2.3 - Audio Description or Media Alternative (Prerecorded) - Level A #21
Labels
small-variation
Small variation in applying the Success Criterion compared to WCAG(2ICT)
Milestone
Discussion:
MATF meeting on June 26, 2024
Source
1.2.3 Audio Description or Media Alternative (Prerecorded) - Level A
JJ: WCAG2ICT states that 1.2.3 applies directly as written. Some notes clarify other terms that might be used to audio descriptions. Interesting that "closed functionality" comes into play.
julianmka: we would produce two versions of the video, one without audio description and one with
ToriClarkA11y: When I worked with video, we ran into issues between different mobile browsers and Android that didn't support additional tracks.
ToriClarkA11y: Now looking at VideoJS which seems promising.
ToriClarkA11y: Worried about closed functionailty when we cannot guarantee that functions are available.
Joe_Humbert: Do we know which video players support audio descriptions?
Joe_Humbert: Android 13+ supports audio descriptions (AD) or at least there's a toggle. iOS video player supports AD.
JJ: Android Media Player doesn't support AD but Exo Player does. Would be interesting to look at other players, especially ones that handle live streaming.
we built off of this at Airbnb IIRC: https://videojs.com/
JJ: Add an issue to Github to discuss video player options.
ToriClarkA11y: Because of internationalization needs, we only supported level A and used enhanced descriptive transcripts.
ToriClarkA11y: Lots of people only provide a basic transcript that doesn't include visual descriptions.
JJ: We could add supporting material about how to do transcripts well.
gleidsonramos: We tried to use YouTube player for transcripts but the mobile embed doesn't include transcripts. Our alternative is to give a mobile button and opens a view with transcript.
JJ: Web view with an accessible video player could be a good solution for this, using an accessible media player. Benefits of this might outweigh the drawbacks of using a web view.
Summary:
WCAG 1.2.3 Application:
Video Versions and Audio Descriptions:
Internationalization and Transcripts:
YouTube Player and Transcripts:
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: