diff --git a/data/campaigns/Dead_Water/scenarios/12_Revenge.cfg b/data/campaigns/Dead_Water/scenarios/12_Revenge.cfg
index a026a7c76d52..27d57106e231 100644
--- a/data/campaigns/Dead_Water/scenarios/12_Revenge.cfg
+++ b/data/campaigns/Dead_Water/scenarios/12_Revenge.cfg
@@ -802,6 +802,7 @@
 
     [event]
         name=moveto
+        id=bat_necklace_is_bad
 
         [filter]
             x,y=14,11
@@ -878,83 +879,69 @@
             [option]
                 label= _ "That sounds great! I’ll take it."
                 [command]
+                    {ANKH_NECKLACE 14 11 necklace1}
                     [set_variable]
                         name=get_necklace
-                        value=yes
+                        value=done
                     [/set_variable]
                 [/command]
             [/option]
             [option]
                 label= _ "It doesn’t seem to have helped its previous owner. I don’t want it."
+                [command]
+                    [allow_undo][/allow_undo]
+
+                    # Insert event to obtain the necklace later.
+                    # This is not replay / MP safe, because of the combination with [allow_undo]
+
+                    # In case you do not choose the necklace and undo the event afterwards,
+                    # you will have the possibility to choose the necklace with the event below.
+                    # However, in the replay (same happens for MP btw) [allow_undo] means that
+                    # this all never happened, and the moment the replay shows the scene where you
+                    # move the second time onto the necklace, it's the first time in the replay.
+                    # And thus fires the event above, not the one below.
+
+                    # Because the code does the same (and the options are in the same order, too),
+                    # it may or may not cause replay / MP issues
+
+                    [event]
+                        name=moveto
+                        first_time_only=no
+
+                        [filter]
+                            x=14
+                            y=11
+                            side=1
+                        [/filter]
+                        [filter_condition]
+                            [variable]
+                                name=get_necklace
+                                not_equals=done
+                            [/variable]
+                        [/filter_condition]
+
+                        [message]
+                            speaker=unit
+                            [option]
+                                label= _ "I would like my life force protected."
+                                [command]
+                                    {ANKH_NECKLACE 14 11 necklace1}
+                                    [set_variable]
+                                        name=get_necklace
+                                        value=done
+                                    [/set_variable]
+                                [/command]
+                            [/option]
+                            [option]
+                                label= _ "My life force feels fine as it is."
+                                [command]
+                                    [allow_undo][/allow_undo]
+                                [/command]
+                            [/option]
+                        [/message]
+                    [/event]
+                [/command]
             [/option]
         [/message]
-
-        [if]
-            [variable]
-                name=get_necklace
-                equals=yes
-            [/variable]
-            [then]
-                {ANKH_NECKLACE 14 11 necklace1}
-                [set_variable]
-                    name=get_necklace
-                    value=done
-                [/set_variable]
-            [/then]
-            [else]
-                [allow_undo][/allow_undo]
-                [event]
-                    name=moveto
-                    first_time_only=no
-
-                    [filter]
-                        x=14
-                        y=11
-                        side=1
-                    [/filter]
-
-                    [if]
-                        [variable]
-                            name=get_necklace
-                            not_equals=done
-                        [/variable]
-                        [then]
-                            [message]
-                                speaker=unit
-                                [option]
-                                    label= _ "I would like my life force protected."
-                                    [command]
-                                        [set_variable]
-                                            name=get_necklace
-                                            value=yes
-                                        [/set_variable]
-                                    [/command]
-                                [/option]
-                                [option]
-                                    label= _ "My life force feels fine as it is."
-                                [/option]
-                            [/message]
-                        [/then]
-                    [/if]
-
-                    [if]
-                        [variable]
-                            name=get_necklace
-                            equals=yes
-                        [/variable]
-                        [then]
-                            {ANKH_NECKLACE 14 11 necklace1}
-                            [set_variable]
-                                name=get_necklace
-                                value=done
-                            [/set_variable]
-                        [/then]
-                        [else]
-                            [allow_undo][/allow_undo]
-                        [/else]
-                    [/if]
-                [/event]
-            [/else]
-        [/if]
     [/event]
 [/scenario]