[MPMD-396] Impractical to fail build on violation

[jira-importer]

Delany opened MPMD-396 and commented

Let me start with what I'm trying to achieve. I have a multi-module build and I want it to fail on a violation, quickly.

I'm not interesting in producing a report.
The build may include anything from a single module to all modules. In each case, I don't want PMD to try parse the entire code base if I only asked Maven to build a single module.

I notice that if I use the "aggregate-pmd-check" goal, I get log lines like
[WARNING] org.apache.maven.plugins.pmd.AggregatorPmdReport - Unable to locate Source XRef to link to - DISABLED

Why is AggregatorPmdReport being invoked? Sounds like a legacy issue.

I also notice that unlike most Maven plugins, the pmd-maven-plugin goal is always forking, indicated by chevrons in the output <<< pmd:3.22.0:check

With a single custom XPath rule, the time to complete a build becomes impractical.
I was hoping to add pmd to my list of static analysis checkers/formatters like checkstyle, impsort, sortpom, errorprone, modernizer etc which are all able to parse source code and do various checks without becoming a burden.

With the current state of the pmd-maven-plugin (v3.22.0) that does not look likely.

---

Affects: 3.22.0

[jira-importer]

Michael Osipov commented

Regardless of the forking, one needs to check the code for the follwing: checking mojos and report mojos. In your case it should really be a checker mojo.