Skip to content

Files, which are NOT midi files and thus will not play. #144

@bassklampfe

Description

@bassklampfe

@feross First of all: I'm really impressed by your site!

I listened a lot, but some files just don't want to play. Example: Super Smash Brothers - Fountain Of Dreams.mid Then I downloaded the file to find, it wasn't a midi file at all, but (in this case) a Finale Music Project.

As I am a midi collector by myself, I have several scripts to verify midi files (all written in Lua). I decided to let one of them run over bitmidi.com. I don't wanted to abuse your site, so I limited my script to about 1 Midi per 5 … 10 seconds, so this should not become a denial-of-service. I hope this is OK for you.

Please find attached the report of my scripts: bitmidi.com-report.txt Files mentioned in this report are identified as not being midi files at all.

Some special remarks:

  • LHA, RAR, ZIP archive : may contain midis, I have not checked this yet.
  • MIDI with garbage : maybe can be fixed, I have not checked this yet.
  • data, text : these may contain midi in some encoded form (e.g. uue or base64), I have not checked this yet.

I also have scripts to verify the internal structure of midi files (truncated files, incomplete tracks, illegal midi events). I will wait to run these until I get a message from you.

Regards.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions