-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 596
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Firebase Analytics google_analytics_automatic_screen_reporting_enabled not working #2225
Comments
I found a few problems with this issue:
|
This happened to me too, using firebase-bom:26.2.0. |
Can confirm, events are sent automatically with the property set to false |
It also doesn't work with firebase-bom:26.1.1 (that includes firebase-analytics 18.0.0). This seems to be a regression because it worked about a month ago with that same firebase-analytics version: #1976. Does it depend on some configuration downloaded from Firebase servers? |
happening with me as well,
|
It seems to depend on particular device or system version. I created a simple Android TV app that lets you test if automatic screen reporting is disabled: https://github.com/piotr767/firebase-analytics-test. When I run it on Android TV emulator with API 28 image it works correctly (no automatic screen events are reported) but when I run it on my physical Android TV device with API 28 it doesn't work (all screen events are reported). @eburley are there any system settings / configs that can affect this option? |
Any update on this issue? |
I am encountering the same issue. Android platform is reporting many (not set) screen view events. I can reproduce the issue on debug builds and release builds (obfuscated). I also noticed that this Which is a good way to debug and check if you are encountering this issue. Dependencies I am not using BoM.
AndroidManifest
Screen Log Call
I am going to try use BoM now and report back my findings. |
I have changed the code to use
|
Not sure if the following will help. I went back to the original PR where I first implemented the manual screen tracking. I checked it and on this old version the manual screen tracking was working. Here is an image of the DebugEvents screen. Compare with the one I posted above. Only one screen event is logged. Here is the dependency tree for this version of analytics (17.5.0)
Plugin Dependencies
|
I am noticing this is well. Samsung S10 running Android 10 and Pixel 2 running Android 11, I encounter the issue yet on a emulator running the same Android version, it seems to be working. I have some data from the analytics itself that may help. The app has been using version 18.0.0 (Non BoM). |
@ersen-lw I did the same check in Firebase Analytics and filtered the |
I'm having the same problem, even putting the value in the manifest, it still sends the screen_view automatically. |
Estou passando pelo mesmo problema utilizando o e ele continua enviando evento automaticamente. |
It still happens in bom 26.7.0. |
Same issue here. I cannot disable auto screen reporting with the metadata. Even if i send the screen_view event i see the log duplicate with auto screen event and the manual event. |
Still happens in BoM 27.0.0 |
Same issue here... |
The gradle version that can be used to block automatic screen view right now is as follows. |
I think it's broken again on Firebase Bom: 28.0.1 and 28.1.0. When I first added google_analytics_automatic_screen_reporting_enabled and set it to false, and upgraded firebase bom to 28.0.1, it worked like the above comment. But today when I checked it, both on 28.0.1 and 28.1.0, they are still logged... |
I'm having this problem with |
I have observed the same issue. When I tried 28.0.1, the manual screen tracking was working, however, today I noticed manual tracking has stopped working where certain Activities started to be logged. |
Still does not work with |
Any update? |
Apologies for the miscommunication, there were issues on our end and the potential fix will instead be out on the next release, scheduled for August 19th. |
@allenktv is it fixed ? |
Looks like there was no Android release yesterday. Any new ETA? I assume this issue has a somewhat high priority for many of us, cause it basically breaks the manual screen tracking. |
The potential fix has been released. Please download the latest version to see if the issue has been resolved. Thanks! |
Still the same issue with |
Can confirm, the issue still exists. |
Also still seeing the issue. Our app requires manual screen tracking so we are hoping for a fix soon |
I'm also still seeing the issue, is there any foreseeable date for the fix? |
Yeah, a fix would be great, I spent that last two days thinking I was doing something wrong only to find this thread and confirm I am as smart as I thought I was. This makes using Path exploration extremely difficult to use (at least for our application) and in some cases totally useless. |
I tried |
@allenktv any news about that ? This is a huge blocker for us |
Our team is looking into the issue now |
Please assign the issue to @chriseman |
Can someone here that is experiencing the issue recreate the issue while capturing the logs and comment the logs below. Please omit any sensitive information. Commands to debug: |
We are still seeing the same issue on the Unity SDK for Android on the latest version 8.3.0.
No other logs to note about Firebase other than it does initialize and track all of Firebase's automatic calls even if we have the |
Hi, Do we have any updates about this issue? |
We need more information about the issue if you are capable please do the following. Recreate the issue while capturing the logs and comment the logs below. Please omit any sensitive information. Commands to debug: |
Hi @chriseman, I am talking about this specific treat issue "Firebase Analytics google_analytics_automatic_screen_reporting_enabled not working #2225". Don't get why I need to provide you details about something that is broken from Dec 2020 and well explained in this treat. At the moment I see different behavior in my android app logs and looks like the automated screen_view event is not anymore being logged but I would like to get also the confirmation from someone else or even better from Firebase. Thanks a lot |
That is good to hear George. For those users that are still experiencing the issue please recreate the issue while capturing the logs and comment the logs below. Please omit any sensitive information. This will help up us solve the general issue. Commands to debug: |
Hi all, I checked the DebugView today and I am no longer seeing any automatic screen events, only the ones I manually track 🎉 . I didn't update the SDK and still using |
I decided to send logs for this issue and sat down to reproduce this, but - much like other commentors before me - cannot do it anymore, neither with standalone what happened here? Does it turn out to have been a server issue, that was therefore fixed "silently"? Would love a quick comment from the team on this, and an info where I can access a changelog for server releases if possible? |
Also wondering what happened here. I'm glad the issue seems to be fixed, but I'd like the peace of mind to know the issue was specifically identified, reproduced and fixed. Otherwise I worry about it randomly starting to happen again |
Not sure if related, but now I don't see ANY events, unless I ENABLE automatic screen reporting 🤦 |
Hi All ,
Then automatic screen capturing ll not performed. As a developer you can customise screen name. Happy Coding :) |
Environment
Steps to reproduce:
I added meta-data google_analytics_automatic_screen_reporting_enabled to false in AndroidManifest.xml to disable screen view event. Yesterday screen_view was not sent as I expected but today with the same codebase, it's keep sending screen_view event. I checked on logcat using adb logcat -v time -s FA FA-SVC) as well as DebugView.
Relevant Code:
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: