Skip to content

Incorrect Answer Sudoku #22

Open
Open
@sebastianherreramonterrosa

Description

A few days ago, I create a Request od Sudoku Image.

Image

The evaluatios is here:
https://visioncheckup.com/assessments/sudoku-puzzle-extraction/

I addition, the image is not displayed of the web, I think the evaluation is incorrect. Here my evaluation:

Model Exact board? Correct cells Accuracy Extracted grid (rows separated by a blank)
ChatGPT-4o 46 / 81 56.8 % ...4.8... .6.7..1.. 72.9.5.4. .97.4..3. ..7.5.8.. .896.5... 941.7.8.. 7..6..4.. ..2.7....
Claude 3.7 Sonnet 63 / 81 77.8 % ....48... .6...7..1 7.2.9.5.4 .9.74.3.. ..7.5.8.. .8.96.5.. 9.4.1.7.8 .7...6.4. ....27...
Claude 4 Opus 81 / 81 100 % ...4.8... .6..7..1. 7.2.9.5.4 .9.7.4.3. ..7.5.8.. .8.9.6.5. 9.4.1.7.8 .7..6..4. ...2.7...
Claude 4 Sonnet 58 / 81 71.6 % ...4.8... .6..7...1 7.2.9.5.4 .9.7.4..3 ..7.5.8.. ..8.9.6.5 9..4.1.7.8 .7...6..4 ...2.7...
GPT-4.1 38 / 81 46.9 % ..4.8.... .6.7..1.. 72.9.5.4. 9.7.4..3. ..7.5.8.. 8.9.6..5. 941.7.8.. 7..6..4.. ..2.7....
GPT-4.1 Mini 53 / 81 65.4 % ..4.8.... .6..7..1. 7.29.5.4. .9.7.4.3. .7.5.8... 8.9.6.5.. 9.4.1.7.8 .7..6..4. ..2.7....
Gemini 2.0 Flash 80 / 81 98.76 % ...4.8.. .6..7..1. 7.2.9.5.4 .9.7.4.3. ..7.5.8.. .8.9.6.5. 9.4.1.7.8 .7..6..4. ...2.7...
Gemini 2.0 Flash Lite 43 / 81 53.1 % ....4.8.. ..6..7.1. 7.2.9.5.4 ..9.7.4.3 ...7.5.8. ..8.9.6.5 9.4.1.7.8 ..7..6.4. ....2.7..
Gemini 2.5 Pro 81 / 81 100 % ...4.8... .6..7..1. 7.2.9.5.4 .9.7.4.3. ..7.5.8.. .8.9.6.5. 9.4.1.7.8 .7..6..4. ...2.7...
OpenAI O1 40 / 81 49.4 % ...4..8.. 6..7....1 72.9.5..4 97..4...3 7...5.8.. 89...6.5. 94178.... 764...... .......27
OpenAI O4 Mini 57 / 81 70.4 % ...4.8... .6..7..1. 72..9.5.4 .9.7.4.3. .7..5..8. ..8.9.6.5. 941.7..8. ..7.6..4. ....27...
Qwen 2.5 VL 7B 12 / 81 14.8 % . . 4 8 . . . 6 7 . . 1 . 7 2 9 5 4 . 9 7 4 3 . . 7 5 8 . 8 9 6 5 . 9 4 1 7 8 . 7 . 6 4 . 2 . 7 .

Correct answer: ...4.8... .6..7..1. 7.2.9.5.4 .9.7.4.3. ..7.5.8.. .8.9.6.5. 9.4.1.7.8 .7..6..4. ...2.7...

Only Claude 4 Opus and Gemini 2.5 Pro cpmplete the task correctly.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions