Option -i seems not working anymore in VSCode V1.31.1

[Nounours31]

Hello,
In VSCode I cannot set the increment anymore (my shfmt version is 2.5.1)
Whatever the -i number I used I have 5 whitespace in my script.
Please note

• In VSCode, all others options are working well (I tested -p, -ci, -h, -w ...)
• In VSCode "terminal windows" -i option is working well

I really think it is not linked to shfmt himself but it's integration in VSCode.
Perhaps something is running at 'Format document' after shfmt which change the indent to '5'

But I have no idea of how I can debug this.

Note than before this was integrated to the 'system' Format Document, I had no problem ... I am so sad ...

In order to help you, is there a way to debug this?

Thanks in advance for your help, regards,
Pierre

The code
#!/bin/sh
if [ "${a}" = "a" ]; then
echo "toto"
echo "toto" > tata
fi
the options:
"shellformat.flag": "-i 0 -p -ci -sr -kp",
"shellformat.path": "E:\programfiles\shfmt\shfmt.exe",
"shellformat.showError": true,

[foxundermoon]

on your setting

"editor.tabSize": 5

[Nounours31]

Hello,
sorry but no, I have set it to 2.
Here my whole settings:
{
"editor.fontSize": 12,
"editor.tabSize": 2,
"editor.formatOnSave": false,
"editor.renderWhitespace": "all",
/* /
"window.zoomLevel": 0,
/ /
"php.validate.executablePath": "E:\wamp\bin\php-7.2.3\php.exe",
"php.executablePath": "E:\wamp\bin\php-7.2.3\php.exe",
/ /
"shellformat.flag": "-i 2 -p -ci -sr -kp",
"shellformat.path": "E:\programfiles\shfmt\shfmt.exe",
"shellformat.showError": true,
/ */
"todo-tree.showCountsInTree": true,
"todo-tree.statusBar": "total",
"todo-tree.customHighlight": {
"TODO": {
"icon": "alert",
"type": "text",
"foreground": "black",
"background": "#ff0000",
"opacity": 90,
"iconColour": "blue"
},
"FIXME": {
"icon": "alert",
"type": "text",
"foreground": "black",
"background": "#70f21a",
"opacity": 90,
"iconColour": "blue"
},
},
"todo-tree.tags": [
"TODO",
"FIXME",
],
"python.linting.enabled": true,
}

[foxundermoon]

the value of "editor.tabSize" equal the command args -i value

[virgilwashere]

What about .editorconfig?

[kelbyers]

I have editor.tabSize set to a value of 4, and I have the shell-format extension installed in my VS Code. Whenever I tell the editor to format an open shell script file, I get a pop-up telling me to configure editor.tabSize. It is configured, already.

[LaurentOngaro]

Same issue for me
in my settings.json
...
"shellformat.flag": "-i 2 -ci -sr -s"
...
"editor.tabSize": 2,

and error
"config by "editor.tabSize": your tabSize https://git.io/tabsize"

when I try to format a bash file.

the issue has been solved for me by changing the settings to
"shellformat.flag": "-ci -sr -s"

[foxundermoon]

Setting both places will cause inconsistency, so the -i option is disabled

[foxundermoon]

Edited and formatted indent also inconsistent

[foxundermoon]

#v5.0.1 support both -i and editor.tabSize setting