here's the changelog in minidom https://gitlab.com/xmpp-rs/xmpp-rs/-/blob/main/minidom/CHANGELOG.md

looks like they now Force namespaces on Element

Minidom is at v.0.14 now and requires a NS declaration, which is NOT compliant with XML spec.

Reproduction:

    assert!(Element::from_str(r#"<a b="1"><x/></a>"#).is_err()); // <-- this is a totally well formed XML, but minidom fails it

    assert!(Element::from_str(r#"<a xmlns="ns1" b="1"><x/></a>"#).is_ok()); // <- adding a NS fixes it

    assert!(Element::from_str(r#"<a xmlns="" b="1"><x/></a>"#).is_ok());

All 3 versions of the XML in the example above are correct, but minidom fails to parse the first one with no xmlns declaration.

They have an issue for this under https://gitlab.com/xmpp-rs/xmpp-rs/-/issues/41. The maintainer said they are not interested in fixing it because it works for them (XMPP has NS for everything and then some)

It may be wiser to switch to a more generic XML parser like https://github.com/RazrFalcon/roxmltree.

It looks like a better tool with a similar API. I think we can make a backward-compatible release with it.

@AlecTroemel , thoughts?

@rimutaka I have no problem switching away from minidom/xmpp-rs. roxmltree looks promising. I dont think we're mutating any part of the xml "DOM", so the fact that its read only should be ok. I'll have time to look into it more later this week!

Hello,

Recently, compiling my projects leads to the following warning message from the cargo utility:

% cargo build --release
    Finished release [optimized] target(s) in 0.31s
warning: the following packages contain code that will be rejected by a future version of Rust: quick-xml v0.17.2
note: to see what the problems were, use the option `--future-incompat-report`, or run `cargo report future-incompatibilities --id 2`

I did some digging, and the real culprit is quickxml_to_serde, because it has the following outdated dependency (see source):

minidom = "0.12"

which in turn has the following outdated dependency (see source):

quick-xml = "0.17"

Therefore, quickxml_to_serde is entirely responsible for the warning.

Hey all, sorry for the inactivity on this. Im finally spending some time getting this project updated.

The warnings were bothering me enough that I switched now to xml2json-rs. It provides a build_from_xml function, which replaces quickxml_to_serde for my needs. I'll return back to quickxml_to_serde if I encounter problems.

Have a nice weekend!