Skip to content
This repository has been archived by the owner on May 23, 2023. It is now read-only.

Problem to create route #1377

Closed
Vanquish081 opened this issue Nov 30, 2016 · 17 comments
Closed

Problem to create route #1377

Vanquish081 opened this issue Nov 30, 2016 · 17 comments
Assignees

Comments

@Vanquish081
Copy link
Contributor

This route have issue in curve of field...

Example

@Satissis Satissis added enhancement postponed will be looked into later labels Nov 30, 2016
@Satissis Satissis self-assigned this Nov 30, 2016
@Satissis
Copy link
Contributor

Yeah that's an know old issue, that we can't really do anything about right now, since that would require an new avoidance system to go from one endpoint to the start point on the opposite side of the obstacle.

I might have an idea to how to work around this, but that will not be an easy task right here and now and is something that would have to wait for an later date.

@sootysax
Copy link

sootysax commented Dec 1, 2016

this is classic CP behavior, if you would have run the course North/South, it would have worked fine.

@fudoido
Copy link

fudoido commented Dec 1, 2016

while in "fieldwork" mode, it wont do any obstacle avoidance while operating, best solution is to find the best direction to avoid those field "gaps" and avoid obstacles.
as @sootysax mentioned, doing it on a north/south direction instead of east/west would be a better choice in that field, since doing N/S will find less gaps and obstacles in the paths created, loosing the benefit of having less turns to harvest the full field.

(thats the kind of field where auto-combine/tractor would be needed, shame creators wont be updating it to fs17 sniffs )

@Vanquish081
Copy link
Contributor Author

@sootysax Yes, I did it.

@Satissis
Copy link
Contributor

Satissis commented Dec 1, 2016

I have added it to our pivotal Tracker, so once we start getting some free time, I will have an look into this :)

@Satissis
Copy link
Contributor

@Vanquish081 do you remember what map you were using here ?

@Vanquish081
Copy link
Contributor Author

@Satissis Yes, Hof Bergmann Map in #FS15

@Vanquish081
Copy link
Contributor Author

Vanquish081 commented Jan 31, 2017

The next image is in FS17, isn't the same error, but loses a piece of field

Example

@Vanquish081 Vanquish081 reopened this Jan 31, 2017
@Satissis
Copy link
Contributor

Satissis commented Feb 1, 2017

Hmm if we don't have an FS17 map with that kind of shaped field, I won't be able to have something to test on.

Regarding your second problem, then that's not something I want to do anything about, since that's a question about making 1 single headland around the field to clean that up.

@Vanquish081
Copy link
Contributor Author

Vanquish081 commented Feb 2, 2017

Ok, I modified the next map where you can see this error:

--> Test Map <--

Example

Example

@Sythos
Copy link

Sythos commented Feb 15, 2017

Actually i've "workarounded" setting by hand 2 or more edges (fieldXX-part1, fieldXX-part2, fieldXX-part3, etc.etc.) picking the slices to avoid critical lanes, so loaded to append one to other. This seem work, but is very nasty and time consuming, can be done something alike via CP? Should be like a check if a lane go outside outer lane or field edge, if yes so "split" the field area perpendicular where the lane go out (i know, is simple to say, maybe not so much code in LUA :D )

@Blackmankot
Copy link

@Satissis Can this issue be closed? To cleanse the topic.

@pops64
Copy link
Contributor

pops64 commented Apr 29, 2017

This will stay open until it is resolved. Which won't be until after the release.

@Blackmankot
Copy link

Blackmankot commented Apr 29, 2017

@pops64 I understand you. Thank you.

@LGRDDOG
Copy link

LGRDDOG commented May 26, 2017

For the U-shaped fields, I found that adding headland rows quite often fixed it so that it no longer left the field (however it Would cross over the inside of the U's headland area when doing the straight portion.

As for the field being cut off (as in image #2) I've only had that happen on really large fields when I have the distance between points for the field border edging set too low. Apparently, there is a maximum # of reference points that it can use for border detection, and once it hits that max, it simply makes a straight line from the last point it could make, to the first. Increasing the distance setting (in the courseplaysettings.xml decreased the field edge accuracy, however, reduced the number of points so that it could actually make an edge path for the field.

Not sure if the second thing is the same as what I've experienced, however I figure it never hurts to try. I only discovered that fix since as soon as I started a new map, I always exited and set the point distance down from the default of 5, to 1 for better edge accuracy. :)

@pvaiko
Copy link
Contributor

pvaiko commented May 26, 2017

You probably want to take a look at https://github.com/pvajko/course-generator, also pvaiko/course-generator#12, the discussion at #1793 and maybe https://github.com/pvajko/courseplay

@pvaiko
Copy link
Contributor

pvaiko commented Jul 10, 2017

Closing this as the new course generation can handle this situation.

@pvaiko pvaiko closed this as completed Jul 10, 2017
@pops64 pops64 added fixed and removed postponed will be looked into later labels Jul 10, 2017
Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

9 participants