Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Request for change multiple TP management #28

Closed
paymanz opened this issue Sep 26, 2021 · 9 comments
Closed

Request for change multiple TP management #28

paymanz opened this issue Sep 26, 2021 · 9 comments

Comments

@paymanz
Copy link

paymanz commented Sep 26, 2021

Hello dear developer, would you please consider change the way PSC manages the multiple TP orders to maybe have a fixed distance(maybe a percentage of the main TP or a fixed RR but hidden lines) for additional TPs? sometimes if one of TP lines be in a invalid price level(for a buy position it being lower than entry point) it opens the trade but without stoploss. and also multiple TP lines makes the chart a bit messy and hard to manage when you want open a trade. also if i set TP to be set by point and not price level the additional TPs distance convert to unrealistic point values.

sometimes you just want break your trade into smaller positions and specific TP levels in not important at the time of opening the trade.

is it possible to change it a little bit please? Thanks in advance

@EarnForex
Copy link
Owner

would you please consider change the way PSC manages the multiple TP orders to maybe have a fixed distance(maybe a percentage of the main TP or a fixed RR but hidden lines) for additional TPs?

You can use the quick-fill buttons on the Script tab to set the multiple TPs to percentage of the main TP value. You can combine that with the UseFixedTPDistance parameter to make the distances fixed. To hide the lines, you can click on the Hide lines button.

sometimes if one of TP lines be in a invalid price level(for a buy position it being lower than entry point) it opens the trade but without stoploss.

Yeah, this should be fixed in the next version of the PSC-Trader script.

and also multiple TP lines makes the chart a bit messy and hard to manage when you want open a trade.

Not much I could do with that. Hide lines/Show lines button should help with it.

also if i set TP to be set by point and not price level the additional TPs distance convert to unrealistic point values.

I will look into it.

sometimes you just want break your trade into smaller positions and specific TP levels in not important at the time of opening the trade.

What do you suggest that would solve this?

@paymanz
Copy link
Author

paymanz commented Sep 27, 2021

What do you suggest that would solve this?

i think by solving the missing SL problem of PSC script this issue would also be solved by itself.

thanks for your consideration. 🙏

@Zireael
Copy link

Zireael commented Oct 17, 2021

I came here wanting to raise the exactly same feature request as @paymanz - each TP to be automatically calculated using a specified multiplier. There could be a field in settings on on the main panel (see fields highlighted in orange below) where we could put in a comma-delimited list of TP multiplier values by multiple TP levels:

image

@EarnForex
Copy link
Owner

Partially done in 2.41.

@paymanz
Copy link
Author

paymanz commented Dec 7, 2021

Not much I could do with that. Hide lines/Show lines button should help with it.

is it possible to have an option to hide all additional TPs(their lines and also in panel) and set all TPs on initial TP(TP1).

sorry to bring it up again but that option would be really nice, thanks.

even if it dont hide them and just set all the TPs the same(as TP1) , that still very cool.

just an option like that: set all additional TPs as TP1.

@EarnForex
Copy link
Owner

Do you mean that the script should then open a single trade with a single TP or several trades but all with the same TP?

@paymanz
Copy link
Author

paymanz commented Dec 7, 2021

Do you mean that the script should then open a single trade with a single TP or several trades but all with the same TP?

multiple trades with the same TP.

@EarnForex
Copy link
Owner

I will think what I can do.
However, you might probably achieve a similar result right now by executing the script multiple times with a single TP.

@paymanz
Copy link
Author

paymanz commented Jan 12, 2022

I will think what I can do. However, you might probably achieve a similar result right now by executing the script multiple times with a single TP.

hi dear Earnforex, on this subject i just want make a suggestion that might be more logical thing than i previously suggested.

that is when the TP locked on SL is true to have additional TPs locked on RRR as well , so they are in proper place automatically. so each additional TP can be set by a RRR multiplier instead of price level.

overall it makes it easier to use when you do short term trade/scalp.

cheers!

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants