-
-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 3.8k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
[Problem] CAM - EdgeWalker has no edges to load #12601
Comments
could you try this with the current weekly builds as there were some changes to the PathWB: https://github.com/FreeCAD/FreeCAD-Bundle/releases/tag/weekly-builds |
I've tested this build but got the same result |
Hi @maxwxyz, any idea who's working on CAM wb these days beside sliptonic ? |
no. @djmdjm @davidgilkaufman did a few PRs recently. |
I am struggling to reproduce the bug -- I've got some guesses, but if they are not relevant then I need more precise instructions to reproduce. Here's what I've done:
The instructions here seem to successfully recreate the extensions shown in jescombe's screenshot, which I think is what Siltti is looking for. In this process I did not generate any EdgeWalker errors. I did some additional messing around and managed to produce "EdgeWalker has no edges to load" errors by deleting geometry items used by operations, but I don't think that is a bug. I'd agree that the error could be a lot clearer, but it is correct for those operations to produce an error in this situation. This is my best guess for how @gagagu gets these errors, but it's hard to be sure. As an additional test, I tried creating a Pocket operation in this new job to mirror what I think the Iso Kuoppa operation is supposed to do. I added all of the bounded faces and (just to make a clear screen shot) turned the step over down to 10%. It seems to work as I would expect -- screenshot attached I'd be willing to look again with more specific reproduction instructions, but barring more details I would close this bug as "cannot reproduce" |
@davidgilkaufman thanks for the feedback!
Any suggestions on what that would look like ? |
I'd say that whenever we understand what went wrong we should print that explanation, in a message crafted for users to read, instead of printing an exception and backtrace. I'd have to read the code more closely to be sure what's appropriate, but something along the lines of: "Error, base geometry items are missing" We don't do this anywhere else (as far as I know) so I'm a little reluctant to suggest it, but it bothers me that we print error messages to the console without a clear indication of which operation produced them. I would consider adding the operation name to that error message as well. |
The operation fails because the selected base geometry is a spline. Interestingly, the profile operation works just fine with the spline boundary. This should be a relatively easy solution. |
Is there an existing issue for this?
Problem description
Hi,
i've created a flat panel from an imported SVG file and add a path job.
I will always get an error on Poket operation on a hole and I don't know why.
09:34:42 Recompute failed!
I've spend hours to get it working but no success. The only way is to export it as *.stl and import it but than all circles are segmented. I've created a "simpe copy","refined copy", delete all jobs and create new, export as step and import it again.
I've created a Post in the Freecad Forum and the Users thinks that it could be a bug and suggested me to create this ticket.
Full version info
Subproject(s) affected?
CAM
Anything else?
12601.zip
I've uploaded an Image, the FreeCad file and the ToolBit file to my share hereCode of Conduct
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: