ITK Community Participation Guidelines
Version 1.0 – Updated May, 2018
The Insight Software Consortium (ISC) as the copyright holder of the Insight Toolkit (ITK) has adopted the following Code of Conduct for ITK.
The primary goal of the ITK community is to be inclusive of the largest number of contributors, with the most varied and diverse backgrounds. Please read our Motivation statement.
Our community is built upon values, and we welcome and encourage members to lead by example. However, we are aware that we must ensure a safe, welcoming and productive environment, where all people should feel safe to participate, introduce new ideas and inspire others. Hence, we acknowledge the importance of providing mechanisms for participants to report unacceptable behavior, and the responsibility of the community to enforce these guidelines.
The following behaviors are expected of all ITK community members:
We invite anyone to participate in our community. We are accepting of all who wish to take part in our activities, fostering an environment where anyone can participate and everyone can make a difference. Members of the community are expected to be open to collaboration in any aspect of the project, whether it's on
- developing cutting-edge features,
- fixing bugs,
- improving documentation,
- adding examples or or enhancing the existing ones,
- improving the testing framework,
- enhancing the code coverage,
- improving the ITK ecosystem with new tools,
- hosting ISC-endorsed events,
- or otherwise.
We are receptive to constructive comment and criticism; gracefully accept others' advice, as the experiences and skill sets of other members contribute to the whole of our efforts.
Remember that we are different. The strength of our community comes from its diversity, people from a wide range of backgrounds. Different people have different perspectives on issues, and all of them may help in finding the most appropriate solution in each situation.
We prefer to use public methods of communication for project-related messages, unless discussing something sensitive (e.g. potential conflicts of interest). This applies to messages for help or project-related support, too; not only is a public support request much more likely to result in an answer to a question, it also ensures that any inadvertent mistakes in answering are more easily detected and corrected. Please avoid seeking for help privately; asking in the official ITK discussion forums will increase your chances of getting an answer.
We strive to be a community that welcomes and supports people of all backgrounds and identities. Be positive and engaging. Refrain from being snarky.
If someone asks for help, it is because they need it. Politely suggest specific documentation or more appropriate venues where adequate. Avoid aggressive or vague responses.
Seek diverse perspectives. Diversity of views and of people on teams powers innovation, even if it is not always comfortable. Encourage all voices. Help new perspectives be heard and listen actively. If you find yourself dominating a discussion, it is especially important to step back and encourage other voices to join in. Be aware of how much time is taken up by dominant members of the group. Provide alternative ways to contribute or participate when possible.
Be inclusive of everyone in an interaction, respecting and facilitating people's participation whether they are:
- Remote (on video or phone)
- Non-native language speakers
- Coming from a different culture
- Using pronouns other than "he" or "she"
- Living in a different time zone
- Facing other challenges to participate
Think about how you might facilitate alternative ways to contribute or participate. Make way for other voices and listen actively to them.
Be civil and considerate
Your work will be used by other people, and you in turn will depend on the work of others. Any decision you take will affect users and colleagues, and you should take those consequences into account when making decisions. Remember that we are a world-wide community. You may be communicating with someone with a different primary language or cultural background.
Members of the community are considerate of their peers. We are thoughtful when addressing the efforts of others, keeping in mind that often times the labor was completed simply for the good of the community.
We are respectful of others, their positions, their skills, their commitments, and their efforts. We are respectful of the volunteer efforts that permeate the ITK community. We are respectful of the processes set forth in the community, and we work within them. When we disagree, we are courteous in raising our issues.
We must be able to speak directly when we disagree and when we think we need to improve. We cannot withhold hard truths. Doing so respectfully is hard, doing so when others do not seem to be listening is harder, and hearing such comments when one is the recipient can be even harder still. We need to be honest and direct, as well as respectful.
Value each other's ideas, styles and viewpoints. When we disagree, try to understand why. Being unable to understand why someone holds a viewpoint does not mean that they are wrong. Be respectful to differing viewpoints and experiences. Disagreements, both social and technical, happen all the time and ITK is no exception. Try to understand where others are coming from, as seeing a question from their viewpoint may help find a new path forward. Be open to different possibilities and to being wrong. Be kind in all interactions and communications, especially when debating the merits of different options. Our goal should not be to "win" every disagreement or argument. A more productive goal is to be open to ideas that make our own ideas better. The best solutions to hard problems rarely come from a single angle. Strive to be an example for inclusive thinking. "Winning" is when different perspectives make our work richer and stronger.
Do not forget that it is human to err: blaming each other does not get us anywhere, while we can learn from mistakes to find better solutions.
Most importantly, disagreement is no excuse for poor manners. We might all experience some frustration now and then, but we cannot allow that frustration to turn into a personal attack. We do not allow disagreement to persist and fester leaving others uncertain of the agreed direction. We work together to resolve conflict, assume good intentions and do our best to act in an empathic fashion. We work together to resolve conflict, and assume good intentions. We may all experience some frustration from time to time, but we do not allow frustration to turn into a personal attack.
A community where people feel uncomfortable or threatened is not a productive one.
What we produce is a complex whole made of many parts, it is the sum of many efforts, long working hours, personal endeavors and sleepless nights. Collaboration between teams that each have their own goal and vision is essential; for the whole to be more than the sum of its parts, each part must make an effort to understand the whole.
Our work will be used by other people, and in turn we will depend on the work of others. When we make something for the benefit of the project, we are willing to explain to others how it works, so that they can build on the work to make it even better. Any decision we make will affect users and colleagues, and we take those consequences seriously when making decisions.
Collaboration reduces redundancy and improves the quality of our work. Internally and externally, we celebrate good collaboration. Wherever possible, we work closely with upstream projects and others in the free software community to coordinate our efforts. We prefer to work transparently and involve interested parties as early as possible.
We recognize that the project works better when we trust the teams closest to a problem to make the decision for the project. We strive to find common ground, and failing that, the matter can be escalated to the ITK governance structure represented by the ISC members and its designated leaders who can review the decision, arbitrate and provide clarity and direction. Ultimately, if a decision has been taken by the people responsible for it, and is supported by the project governance, it will stand. None of us expects to agree with every decision, and we value highly the willingness to stand by the project and help it deliver even on the occasions when we ourselves may prefer a different route.
We value discussion, data, decisiveness and consensus. We gather opinions, data and commitments from concerned parties before taking a decision. We expect leaders to help teams come to a decision in a reasonable time, to seek guidance or be willing to take the decision themselves when consensus is lacking, and to take responsibility for implementation.
The poorest decision of all is no decision: clarity of direction has value in itself. Sometimes all the data are not available, or consensus is elusive. A decision must still be made because it enables the project as a whole to move forward faster and to adapt to times. There is no guarantee of a perfect decision every time - we prefer to err, learn, and err less in future than to postpone action indefinitely.
Resoluteness in decisions demands considerateness; take bold decisions, but do so mindful of the challenges they present for other community members and the use of ITK itself across different projects, and work to soften the impact of those decisions on them. Communicating changes and their reasoning clearly and early on is as important as the implementation of the change itself.
Be careful in the words that we choose
We are careful and respectful in our communication and we take responsibility for our own speech. Be kind to others. Do not insult or put down other participants. We will not accept harassment or other exclusionary behavior.
Take responsibility for our words and our actions
Be aware of your impact and how intense interactions may be affecting people. Be direct, constructive and positive. We can all make mistakes; when we do, we take responsibility for your impact and your mistakes - if someone says they have been harmed through your words or actions, listen carefully, apologize sincerely, and correct the behavior going forward. If someone has been harmed or offended, we listen carefully and respectfully, and work to right the wrong.
A simple apology can go a long way. It can often de-escalate a situation, and telling someone that you are sorry is an act of empathy that does not automatically imply an admission of guilt.
Value each other's time. Keep in mind that what you write once will be read by hundreds of persons. Writing a short message means people can understand the conversation as efficiently as possible. Messages that are brief and to the point take more time to write, but are repaid many times over when other members of the list make the same effort. Short messages should always strive to be empathetic, welcoming, friendly and patient. When a long explanation is necessary, consider adding a summary.
Try to bring new ideas to a conversation so that each message adds something unique to the thread, keeping in mind that the rest of the thread still contains the other messages with arguments that have already been made.
Try to stay on topic, especially in discussions that are already fairly large. If you must change the topic, start a new thread. Also, avoid flooding the list with long threads by reading the entire thread first, instead of responding quickly to many emails in a short period of time.
Nobody knows everything! We will try hard to be responsive and helpful.
Moderate your expectations
Please respect that community members choose how they spend their time in the project. A thoughtful question about your expectations is preferable to demands for another person's time. Respect the time and energy of long-time community members.
Ask for help when unsure
Nobody is expected to be perfect in the ITK community. Asking questions early, and bringing discussions to the table through the appropriate channels, avoids many problems (whether they are technical, such as design flaws, technical debt, etc., or intellectual, etc.) later, so questions are encouraged, though they may be directed to the appropriate forum. Those who are asked should be responsive and helpful.
We do our best to answer to all questions and concerns in a timely manner. But we may fail to do so sometimes. Please, assume good faith and do not feel discouraged. It may be a matter of asking incomplete, poorly formatted or too broad or generic questions; some other times, the questions may have been answered previously. Please take some time by doing research in FAQs, documentation and other ITK resources, as well as with search engines before asking questions.
We welcome new members, and love to see them becoming important people in our community.
Step down considerately
When somebody leaves or disengages from the ITK project, we ask that they do so in a way that minimizes disruption to the Project. They should tell people they are leaving and take the proper steps to ensure that others can pick up where they left off.
Lead By Example
We all lead by example, in debate and in action. We encourage new participants to feel empowered to lead, to take action, and to experiment when they feel innovation could improve the project. Leadership can be exercised by anyone simply by taking action, there is no need to wait for recognition when the opportunity to lead presents itself.
To err is human; whenever we make a mistake, we take responsibility for it, and we work to right the wrong.
We encourage everyone to participate and are committed to building a community for all. Although we may not be able to satisfy everyone, we all agree that everyone is equal. Whenever a participant has made a mistake, we expect them to take responsibility for it.
Code of Conduct violations reduce the value of the community for everyone and we take them seriously.
The following behaviors are considered to be unacceptable under these guidelines:
- Personal attacks and violent threats or language directed against another person, including but not limited to offensive comments related to gender, gender identity and expression, gender identity, sexual orientation, ability, physical appearance, body, age, race, ethnicity, nationality, language, religion or otherwise dimension of diversity.
- Sexist, racist, or otherwise discriminatory jokes and insults.
- Deliberate misgendering or use of "dead" or rejected names.
- Unwelcome comments regarding a person's lifestyle choices and practices, including those related to food, health, parenting, drugs, and employment.
- Derogatory language.
- Sustained disruption of discussion.
- Excessive profanity. Avoid swearwords; people differ greatly in their sensitivity to swearing.
- Publishing (or threatening to publish) other people's personally identifying information and/or material ("doxing").
- Deliberate "outing" of any aspect of a person's identity without their consent except as necessary to protect other community members or other vulnerable people from intentional abuse.
- Sharing of non-harassing private communication, such as emails sent privately or non-publicly, or unlogged forums such as IRC channel history, without the sender's consent.
Harassment will not be tolerated in any of its forms either. Specifically:
- Unwelcome sexual attention or physical contact, including simulated contact (e.g., textual descriptions like "hug" or "backrub"), or otherwise creating sexualized environment.
- Posting gratuitous or off-topic sexually explicit or violent material.
- Incitement of violence towards any individual, including encouraging a person to commit suicide or to engage in self-harm.
- Deliberate intimidation.
- Stalking or following.
- Harassing photography or recording, including logging online activity for harassment purposes
- Pattern of inappropriate social contact, such as requesting/assuming inappropriate levels of intimacy with others.
- Continued one-on-one communication after requests to cease.
Although the above list cannot be exhaustive, we will not tolerate discrimination based on any of the protected characteristics in our Diversity Statement.
The relative anonymity (if any) in the discussion forums is no shelter for unacceptable behavior.
Influencing Unacceptable Behavior
We will treat advocating for, influencing or encouraging other members to cause hostility, or leading to any of the above behavior or activities the same way we treat the activities themselves, and thus the same consequences apply.
When sharing your testing data, either as an input to an ITK contribution or as part of a discussion topic or help request, please bear in mind that you must remove any Personal Identifiable Information (PII) from your images prior to making them available. Please bear in mind that besides cleaning pixel data, other meta-data (such as individual attributes when dealing with DICOM files) may require additional de-identification processes.
For dealing with DICOM files/medical images, please read the related documentation (namely, the DICOM Supplement 55 and DICOM Supplement 142). If you still need help for de-identifying your images, please ask on the ITK discussion.
Please, simply avoid using images that, despite having been used in image analysis and related areas historically (e.g. "Lena"), may be interpreted as being degrading to part of our community, or reinforcing stereotypes.
Community members shall not attempt to identify de-identified images.
Everyone is encouraged to ask questions about these guidelines. We would be happy to hear suggestions to improve any aspect of this Code of Conduct.
If you are organizing an event or activity where ITK is a building block, please reach us for including a policies concerning aspects of ITK.
Modifications to these Guidelines
The ISC may amend these guidelines in order to adapt to, and may also vary the associated procedures where appropriate in a particular case. Community members' agreement to comply with these guidelines will be deemed agreement to any changes to it. In case ISC amends the guidelines, the new guidelines will be reachable as a new version of this document. You can sign up for updates by subscribing to this repository's notifications in your settings.
License and Attribution
This document and all associated processes are only possible with the hard work of many, many ITK community members, and other open-source initiative members. These guidelines have sought inspiration and have drawn content with modification from
- The Open Source Initiative
- The Linux Foundation
- Contributor Covenant
We are grateful to those projects for contributing these materials under open licensing terms for us to easily reuse.
All content on this page is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license.