-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 2.8k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
fix(ignore): Fixed BTicino K4027C family detection #6423
Conversation
* 067776A: added additional HW version for BTicino whitelabels
This is fine, let's iterate further based on the user feedback. |
i have a bticino (no tilt) and now is show legrand (with tilt) all is btcino K4027C |
Hi; can you please send us the hardwareVersion of the device or attach the database.db to this issue ?
|
Please ceck. it is already attached |
Hi @Bobsilvio, The ones having HwVersion 4 are more problematic! As a matter of fact we have users reporting that devices with that HwVersion are actually Legrand 067776A switches (or more precisely 067726A devices) here. @Koenkk: With reference to PR#6423, this is unfortunately the situation we wanted to avoid. @Bobsilvio: Do you have the original gateway / app ? Is it a Legrand App ? If so, do the switches show up as BTicino switches? I just wonder how the original GW / APP is able to tell them apart. |
@FabianMangold if that's the case, we cannot distinguish them indeed. In that case I propose to keep detecting them as Legrand with tilt. |
I also have 1 bticino 4027c which I see as a legrand. |
Reference:
Koenkk/zigbee2mqtt#19509 (comment)
Hi @Koenkk,
One more user report for that shutter switch!
I am starting to question the approach.
Only Legrand can actually tell how to keep those switches apart in the end. I'll try to reach out to them via their forum, and for now am okay to maintain a list of "hardware Versions" in the fingerprint.
Still, we cannot but cannot ensure 100% that this doesn't break things for other users and if wonder if you have any other ideas or if you've seen similar situations in the past.
What do you think ?
Known hardware versions:
067776A (NLLVs) -> HW version 1
??? -> HW version 4
BTicino 4027C -> HW version 9 and 13