Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

[DK] Death Coil problems #1927

Closed
Bonecek opened this issue Jun 10, 2011 · 16 comments
Closed

[DK] Death Coil problems #1927

Bonecek opened this issue Jun 10, 2011 · 16 comments

Comments

@Bonecek
Copy link

Bonecek commented Jun 10, 2011

Death coil, as a shadow damage, is reduced by armor.

DC as well has probably wrong coefficient. I mean lower than it should have. It can be caused by spell Impurity (http://www.wowwiki.com/Impurity). This spell boost DC only about 10%, and not about 20%. So at first it is necessary to fix armor reduction, then repair the Impurity boost and then finaly the standart coefficient of Attack power to DC damage.

other DC boosting talents are fine (Black Ice, Morbidity)

@ghost
Copy link

ghost commented Jun 10, 2011

on TrinityCore Hash: bdc75eb+ (Win64, Release (little-endian))
Death coil does not get affected by armor and the Coefficient is 443+(0.15*AP) I don't know if that is correct, but at least for 3.1 it is and that is how I found it ingame

@ghost
Copy link

ghost commented Jun 10, 2011

After some more Testing it seems that impurity does not increase the Death coil damage like it should.
According to me If you have Impurity 5/5 The Death coil Coefficient should be 443+(0.35_ap) But after some testing it seems like it turns the Coefficient into 443+(0.1791044776_AP) which is obviously way less than what it should be.

@kbinside
Copy link

for me work fine.

@Bonecek
Copy link
Author

Bonecek commented Jun 10, 2011

I tested it really hard and my first posts are facts - I compared it with Dr.Damage. (that coeff) and armor tested with DK with blood presence and frost presence and the damage was lower

@elenar
Copy link

elenar commented Jun 10, 2011

Frost presence also reduces all damage by 8%

@Bonecek
Copy link
Author

Bonecek commented Jun 10, 2011

yeah it should be, But I also tested it with paladin and there has been a slightly lower dmg with higher armor (other stats were controled such as talents and resilience)

@Bonecek Bonecek closed this as completed Jun 10, 2011
@Bonecek Bonecek reopened this Jun 10, 2011
@Greymane
Copy link
Contributor

After some more Testing it seems that impurity does not increase the Death coil damage like it should.
According to me If you have Impurity 5/5 The Death coil Coefficient should be 443+(0.35*ap) But after some testing it seems like it turns the Coefficient into 443+(0.1791044776*AP) which is obviously way less than what it should be.

Wrong, the contribution from the talent applyes as a percentage of the base coeff of DC, not adding 20% on the coeff.
this (0.1791044776*AP) is what dr damage shows after you choose the talent, since Dr damage formulas are taken from the DBC and not from the server, everything is fine.

@Bonecek
Copy link
Author

Bonecek commented Jun 10, 2011

Then why the DC makes lower damage to than Dr.Damage shows. Tested on guys with no talents or reductions of damage and DC makes a lower dmg about about 20%! We should answer this.

@Greymane
Copy link
Contributor

Dont forget that the damage dr.damage display is based if you attack a "defenseless" target, not a ressilient/damage reduce-talented one.

My DC hits every well geared player for ~2100 damage, 3600-3800 on crits, i rly dont see any problems with it

@Bonecek
Copy link
Author

Bonecek commented Jun 11, 2011

thats what I mentioned. Player with no talents, resists, gear, no armor. Then the damage should be there pure, and it is not.

@Aristoo
Copy link
Contributor

Aristoo commented Jun 11, 2011

Main problem with DC is [Unholy Blight].... this debuff should stack like Ignite (fire mage), but does not worksso DPS is low...

EDIT: Heh... http://www.wowwiki.com/Attack_power_coefficient . DC should have 15% attack power coeficient, but try

select * from spell_bonus_data where entry = 47541;
Empty set

More DK spells don't have set coeficients (DaD, UB for example)

@Greymane
Copy link
Contributor

Yeah yeah, now i see, but i guess thats not a spell_bonus_data entry problem, you can enter whoever entry you like, the damage wont change.

@Aristoo
Copy link
Contributor

Aristoo commented Jun 12, 2011

Try use DrDamage addon. This addon perfectly calculate real spells damage and use offi values.

@Bonecek
Copy link
Author

Bonecek commented Jun 22, 2011

Hope someone can fix this =)

@durrrr
Copy link

durrrr commented Mar 31, 2012

Still bugged @ b23ff22 .

@Star-lion
Copy link
Contributor

select * from spell_bonus_data where entry = 47632;

47632 -1 -1 0.15 -1 Death Knight - Death Coil
^ that is the correct spell id as that is ther DAMAGE spell

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

7 participants