set xy instead of hue for not Philips Hue Bulbs is not working #11

dercaptainbc · 2019-10-31T14:52:03Z

Again me .. I found out that Verwenden von XY anstelle von hue (nur für nicht-Philips-Geräte) is not working correct. Please take a look on the attached log

first value will be converted to null.

p.s.: Sorry for the hugh amount of reported issues, but thats my job (I'm working as quality assurance engineer 😄

Quelle	Zeit	debug	Meldung
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 15:46:14.721	debug	(15988) Successfully set /lights/13/state/sat on Deckenlampe (to 196).
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 15:46:14.720	debug	(15988) Successfully set /lights/13/state/hue on Deckenlampe (to 40595).
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 15:46:14.718	debug	(15988) Successfully set /lights/13/state/transitiontime on Deckenlampe (to 50).
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 15:46:14.716	warn	(15988) Attempt 1x - Error setting /lights/13/state/xy: invalid value, [null,, for parameter, xy
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 15:46:14.670	debug	(15988) Attempt 1x - Send commands to Deckenlampe (lights/13/state): {"hue":40595,"sat":196,"transitiontime":50,"xy":[null,0]}.
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 15:46:14.668	debug	(15988) State of hue-extended.0.lights.013-deckenlampe.action._commands has changed {"val":"{"hue":223,"sat":196,"transitiontime":50}","ack":false,"ts":1572533174659,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 15:46:09.720	debug	(15988) Successfully set /lights/13/state/hue on Deckenlampe (to 49333).
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 15:46:09.717	warn	(15988) Attempt 1x - Error setting /lights/13/state/xy: invalid value, [null,, for parameter, xy
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 15:46:09.643	debug	(15988) Attempt 1x - Send commands to Deckenlampe (lights/13/state): {"hue":49333,"xy":[null,0.33085697021029925]}.
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 15:46:09.627	debug	(15988) State of hue-extended.0.lights.013-deckenlampe.action._commands has changed {"val":"{"hue":271,"sat":209,"bri":254,"on":true}","ack":false,"ts":1572533169614,"q":0,"from":"system.adapt

Zefau · 2019-10-31T15:54:49Z

Could you try and install v1.1.5 from Github and verify whether this is fixed?

dercaptainbc · 2019-10-31T16:40:20Z

not really. Now both values are 0

dercaptainbc · 2019-10-31T16:41:03Z

Quelle	Zeit	debug	Meldung
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 17:39:32.020	info	(20027) Attempt 1x - Successfully set Deckenlampe.
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 17:39:32.019	debug	(20027) Successfully set /lights/13/state/xy on Deckenlampe (to 0,0).
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 17:39:32.017	debug	(20027) Successfully set /lights/13/state/sat on Deckenlampe (to 209).
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 17:39:32.014	debug	(20027) Successfully set /lights/13/state/transitiontime on Deckenlampe (to 50).
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 17:39:31.978	debug	(20027) Attempt 1x - Send commands to Deckenlampe (lights/13/state): {"sat":209,"transitiontime":50,"xy":[0,0]}.
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 17:39:31.976	debug	(20027) State of hue-extended.0.lights.013-deckenlampe.action._commands has changed {"val":"{"hue":271,"sat":209,"transitiontime":50}","ack":false,"ts":1572539971968,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter

Zefau · 2019-10-31T17:16:17Z

Could you try and install the latest version from Github (version number stays unchanged) ?
Hope that fixes it. Hard for me to test, because I only have Hue lights connected.

dercaptainbc · 2019-10-31T18:58:20Z

ok .. my mistake now it looks good. but the colors are not matching. I send the following command to a hue and to a tradfri bulb : {"hue":271,"sat":209,"on":true,"bri":254}

and the hue is purple but the tradfri is red/orange.

In case that I've send the command to a mixed group (hue and tradfri) the color is alos red/orange not purple (I mean not the really color (this also btw), I mean the color which I can see in the hue app)

I think the converting is not 100% correct at the moment.

Zefau · 2019-10-31T19:22:43Z

Could you provide the log of the commands send to the bridge?

dercaptainbc · 2019-10-31T19:24:47Z

Quelle	Zeit	debug	Meldung
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 20:23:32.671	info	(5910) Attempt 1x - Successfully set test.
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 20:23:32.669	debug	(5910) Successfully set /groups/4/action/xy on test (to 0.6484,0.3309).
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 20:23:32.667	debug	(5910) Successfully set /groups/4/action/bri on test (to 254).
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 20:23:32.665	debug	(5910) Successfully set /groups/4/action/on on test (to true).
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 20:23:32.571	debug	(5910) Attempt 1x - Send commands to test (groups/4/action): {"on":true,"bri":254,"xy":[0.6484,0.3309]}.
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 20:23:32.568	debug	(5910) State of hue-extended.0.groups.004-test.action._commands has changed {"val":"{"hue":271,"sat":209,"on":true,"bri":254}","ack":false,"ts":1572549812558,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.admin

dercaptainbc · 2019-10-31T19:29:39Z

I've checked the values in following calculator : http://colorizer.org/

X = 64.84 (0.6484)
Y = 33.09 (0.3309)

and I guess the issue is on z value side. when z is 0 I get red light but if its 1 its purple.

Zefau · 2019-10-31T19:37:34Z

Could you try and use _commands with the input {"on":true,"xy":[0.6484,0.3309]} (no bri because it should be included in xy).

dercaptainbc · 2019-10-31T19:40:13Z

Its still red.

Is it possible to set the Z value? From my point of view I guess a fix value of 50 (0.5) would be good.

dercaptainbc · 2019-10-31T19:40:41Z

Quelle	Zeit	debug	Meldung
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 20:38:47.844	info	(5910) Attempt 1x - Successfully set Badezimmer.
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 20:38:47.843	debug	(5910) Successfully set /groups/2/action/xy on Badezimmer (to 0.6484,0.3309).
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 20:38:47.797	debug	(5910) Attempt 1x - Send commands to Badezimmer (groups/2/action): {"xy":[0.6484,0.3309]}.
hue-extended.0	2019-10-31 20:38:47.793	debug	(5910) State of hue-extended.0.groups.002-badezimmer.action._commands has changed {"val":"{"on":true,"xy":[0.6484,0.3309]}","ack":false,"ts":1572550727785,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.admin.0","us

Zefau · 2019-10-31T20:14:25Z

Where on the page you've linked do you see the xy values?
If I type in the HSB hsb(271, 82, 100) values I get RGB rgb(154, 46, 255). Where do you see xy values?

dercaptainbc · 2019-10-31T20:30:33Z

At the end you can open a closed view with xyz values

Zefau · 2019-10-31T20:31:40Z

That shows 32.34, 16.03, 96 for me?

Zefau · 2019-10-31T20:36:16Z

I think the correct colors for purple is {"on":true,"xy":[0.2496, 0.1029]}.

dercaptainbc · 2019-10-31T20:51:50Z

in my script i used the following hue and sat values

var huePurple = 271;
var satPurple = 209;

and this values I send per _commands

and when I add this in the converter hue = 271 , sat = 82,28 (instead of 209) V = 100
I get x 32.24 (0.3224) y 15,94 (0.1594) and z 95.99 and yes RGB is rgb(154, 45, 255)

Zefau · 2019-10-31T21:02:34Z

I think the Hue xy is different from the standard color space xyz.

Could you try {"on":true,"xy":[0.2496, 0.1029]} (in _commands) just to see the result?

dercaptainbc · 2019-10-31T21:07:45Z

yes. its purple not exatly that kind of purple which I used in my script but yes purple.

Zefau · 2019-10-31T22:05:04Z

Updated again just now. Could please try and install current version from Github and test if the color works?

dercaptainbc · 2019-11-01T11:19:19Z

at the moment also for hue lamps (in my case hue play and hue e14) the XY value will used not hue and sat anymore.

and its still not the same color.

Zefau · 2019-11-01T11:23:54Z

You have reinstalled the current version from Github, right?

What is your exact configuration? Are you setting a group with those two lights being part of it?
What does the state manufacturername of these lamps hold?

Could you additionally please provide the log from the time you trigger until the command is applied by the adapter?

Thanks for your support.

dercaptainbc · 2019-11-01T11:35:19Z

Yes, exactly!

My group setup (Zone) is 2 x Hue Plays ( manufacturername : Philips ) and 1 x Hue color candle ( manufacturername : Philips )

Quelle	Zeit	debug	Meldung
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:21.640	info	(23853) Attempt 1x - Successfully set Balkon.
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:21.639	debug	(23853) Successfully set /lights/23/state/xy on Balkon (to 0.7126,0.2874).
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:21.596	info	(23853) Attempt 1x - Successfully set Hue play Rechts.
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:21.594	debug	(23853) Successfully set /lights/24/state/xy on Hue play Rechts (to 0.1444,0.0327).
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:21.497	info	(23853) Attempt 1x - Successfully set Hue play Links.
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:21.495	debug	(23853) Successfully set /lights/25/state/xy on Hue play Links (to 0.1444,0.0327).
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:21.460	debug	(23853) Attempt 1x - Send commands to Balkon (lights/23/state): {"xy":[0.7126,0.2874]}.
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:21.458	debug	(23853) State of hue-extended.0.lights.023-balkon.action._commands has changed {"val":"{"hue":271,"sat":209,"bri":254,"on":true}","ack":false,"ts":1572608001429,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.ja
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:21.451	debug	(23853) Attempt 1x - Send commands to Hue play Rechts (lights/24/state): {"xy":[0.1444,0.0327]}.
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:21.449	debug	(23853) State of hue-extended.0.lights.024-hue_play_rechts.action._commands has changed {"val":"{"hue":223,"sat":196,"bri":254,"on":true}","ack":false,"ts":1572608001429,"q":0,"from":"system.a
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:21.436	debug	(23853) Attempt 1x - Send commands to Hue play Links (lights/25/state): {"xy":[0.1444,0.0327]}.
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:21.434	debug	(23853) State of hue-extended.0.lights.025-hue_play_links.action._commands has changed {"val":"{"hue":223,"sat":196,"bri":254,"on":true}","ack":false,"ts":1572608001428,"q":0,"from":"system.ad
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:15.071	info	(23853) Attempt 1x - Successfully set Balkon.
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:15.068	debug	(23853) Successfully set /lights/23/state/xy on Balkon (to 0.7126,0.2874).
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:15.060	debug	(23853) Successfully set /lights/23/state/sat on Balkon (to 209).
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:15.025	info	(23853) Attempt 1x - Successfully set Hue play Rechts.
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:15.024	debug	(23853) Successfully set /lights/24/state/xy on Hue play Rechts (to 0.1444,0.0327).
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:15.022	debug	(23853) Successfully set /lights/24/state/sat on Hue play Rechts (to 196).
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:14.952	info	(23853) Attempt 1x - Successfully set Hue play Links.
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:14.951	debug	(23853) Successfully set /lights/25/state/xy on Hue play Links (to 0.1444,0.0327).
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:14.884	debug	(23853) Attempt 1x - Send commands to Balkon (lights/23/state): {"sat":209,"xy":[0.7126,0.2874]}.
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:14.881	debug	(23853) State of hue-extended.0.lights.023-balkon.action._commands has changed {"val":"{"hue":271,"sat":209,"bri":254,"on":true}","ack":false,"ts":1572607994796,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.ja
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:14.876	debug	(23853) Attempt 1x - Send commands to Hue play Rechts (lights/24/state): {"sat":196,"xy":[0.1444,0.0327]}.
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:14.873	debug	(23853) State of hue-extended.0.lights.024-hue_play_rechts.action._commands has changed {"val":"{"hue":223,"sat":196,"bri":254,"on":true}","ack":false,"ts":1572607994796,"q":0,"from":"system.a
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:14.842	debug	(23853) Attempt 1x - Send commands to Hue play Links (lights/25/state): {"xy":[0.1444,0.0327]}.
hue-extended.0	2019-11-01 12:33:14.815	debug	(23853) State of hue-extended.0.lights.025-hue_play_links.action._commands has changed {"val":"{"hue":223,"sat":196,"bri":254,"on":true}","ack":false,"ts":1572607994795,"q":0,"from":"system.ad

dercaptainbc · 2019-11-03T09:19:48Z

In the Meantime I've checked the behavior when I use the long version hue values (from hue api)

Quelle	Zeit	debug	Meldung
hue-extended.0	2019-11-03 10:13:46.087	info	(7060) Attempt 1x - Successfully set Badezimmer.
hue-extended.0	2019-11-03 10:13:46.086	debug	(7060) Successfully set /groups/2/action/xy on Badezimmer (to 0.7126,0.2874).
hue-extended.0	2019-11-03 10:13:46.085	debug	(7060) Successfully set /groups/2/action/sat on Badezimmer (to 209).
hue-extended.0	2019-11-03 10:13:46.023	debug	(7060) Attempt 1x - Send commands to Badezimmer (groups/2/action): {"sat":209,"xy":[0.7126,0.2874]}.
hue-extended.0	2019-11-03 10:13:46.021	debug	(7060) State of hue-extended.0.groups.002-badezimmer.action._commands has changed {"val":"{"hue":49333,"sat":209,"bri":254,"on":true}","ack":false,"ts":1572772426016,"q":0,"from":"system.adapt

When I send {"on": true,"bri": 254,"hue": 49333,"sat": 209} directly to the bridge via POST and check XY Values with GET I can see the following values :

{
		"on": true,
		"bri": 254,
		"hue": 49333,
		"sat": 209,
		"effect": "none",
		"xy": [
			0.247,
			0.1318
		],

because of that I think the conversion from hue to xy is not correct at the moment.

Zefau · 2019-11-03T10:43:09Z

This is actually challenging, because the available algorithms to convert to xy are apparently pretty bad.
I don't find anything online converting {"hue": 49333, "sat": 209, "bri": 254} correctly to

"xy": [
	0.247,
	0.1318
]

Zefau · 2019-11-07T15:43:42Z

Could you try again with v1.1.6 (from Github) and check the results? It won't match exactly what you expect I guess but it will most likely be the closest to get.

Zefau · 2019-11-07T16:04:01Z

Is there actually any other state we could convert to alternatively?

Zefau · 2019-11-12T18:41:41Z

@dercaptainbc Any idea on how to proceed with this?

dercaptainbc · 2019-11-14T08:25:12Z

Hi @Zefau sorry for my delay. Its much better now. I can live with it for now. From my point of view we can close it.

Zefau added the bug Something isn't working label Oct 31, 2019

Zefau added the verify-fix Verify if the implemented fix has solved the issue label Oct 31, 2019

dercaptainbc closed this as completed Nov 14, 2019

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

set xy instead of hue for not Philips Hue Bulbs is not working #11

set xy instead of hue for not Philips Hue Bulbs is not working #11

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019

Zefau commented Oct 31, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019 •

edited

Loading

Zefau commented Oct 31, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019

Zefau commented Oct 31, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019 •

edited

Loading

Zefau commented Oct 31, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019

Zefau commented Oct 31, 2019 •

edited

Loading

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019

Zefau commented Oct 31, 2019

Zefau commented Oct 31, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019 •

edited

Loading

Zefau commented Oct 31, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019

Zefau commented Oct 31, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Nov 1, 2019

Zefau commented Nov 1, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Nov 1, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Nov 3, 2019

Zefau commented Nov 3, 2019

Zefau commented Nov 7, 2019 •

edited

Loading

Zefau commented Nov 7, 2019

Zefau commented Nov 12, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Nov 14, 2019

set xy instead of hue for not Philips Hue Bulbs is not working #11

set xy instead of hue for not Philips Hue Bulbs is not working #11

Comments

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019

Zefau commented Oct 31, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019 • edited Loading

Zefau commented Oct 31, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019

Zefau commented Oct 31, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019 • edited Loading

Zefau commented Oct 31, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019

Zefau commented Oct 31, 2019 • edited Loading

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019

Zefau commented Oct 31, 2019

Zefau commented Oct 31, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019 • edited Loading

Zefau commented Oct 31, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019

Zefau commented Oct 31, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Nov 1, 2019

Zefau commented Nov 1, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Nov 1, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Nov 3, 2019

Zefau commented Nov 3, 2019

Zefau commented Nov 7, 2019 • edited Loading

Zefau commented Nov 7, 2019

Zefau commented Nov 12, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Nov 14, 2019

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019 •

edited

Loading

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019 •

edited

Loading

Zefau commented Oct 31, 2019 •

edited

Loading

dercaptainbc commented Oct 31, 2019 •

edited

Loading

Zefau commented Nov 7, 2019 •

edited

Loading