0263-proxy-support.md

ADR 263: Self-Hosted Runner Proxies

Date: 2019-11-13

Status: Accepted

Context

• Proxy support is required for some enterprises and organizations to start using their own self-hosted runners
• While there is not a standard convention, many applications support setting proxies via the environment variables http_proxy, https_proxy, no_proxy, such as curl, wget, perl, python, docker, git, and R
  • Some of these applications use HTTPS_PROXY versus https_proxy, but most understand or primarily support the lowercase variant

Decision

We will update the Runner to use the conventional environment variables for proxies: http_proxy, https_proxy, and no_proxy if they are set. These are described in detail below:

• https_proxy a proxy URL for all https traffic. It may contain basic authentication credentials. For example:
  • http://proxy.com
  • http://127.0.0.1:8080
  • http://user:password@proxy.com
• http_proxy a proxy URL for all http traffic. It may contain basic authentication credentials. For example:
  • http://proxy.com
  • http://127.0.0.1:8080
  • http://user:password@proxy.com
• no_proxy a comma-separated list of hosts that should not use the proxy. An optional port may be specified. For example:
  • google.com
  • yahoo.com:443
  • google.com,bing.com

We won't use http_proxy for https traffic when https_proxy is not set, this behavior lines up with any libcurl based tools (curl, git) and wget. Otherwise, action authors and workflow users need to adjust to differences between the runner proxy convention, and tools used by their actions and scripts.

Example:
Customer sets http_proxy=http://127.0.0.1:8888 and configures the runner against https://github.com/owner/repo, with the https_proxy -> http_proxy fallback, the runner will connect to the server without any problem. However, if a user runs git push to https://github.com/owner/repo, git won't use the proxy since it requires https_proxy to be set for any https traffic.

golang, node.js, and other dev tools from the Linux community use http_proxy for both http and https traffic based on my research.

A majority of our users are using Linux where these variables are commonly required to be set by various programs. By reading these values, we simplify the process for self-hosted runners to set up a proxy and expose it in a way users are already familiar with.

A password provided for a proxy will be masked in the logs.

We will support the lowercase and uppercase variants, with lowercase taking priority if both are set.

No Proxy Format

While exact implementations are different per application on handling no_proxy env, most applications accept a comma-separated list of hosts. Some accept wildcard characters (*). We are going to do exact case-insensitive matches, and not support wildcards at this time. For example:

• example.com will match example.com, foo.example.com, and foo.bar.example.com
• foo.example.com will match bar.foo.example.com and foo.example.com

We will not support IP addresses for no_proxy, only hostnames.

Consequences

1. Enterprises and organizations needing proxy support will be able to embrace self-hosted runners
2. Users will need to set these environment variables before configuring the runner in order to use a proxy when configuring
3. The runner will read from the environment variables during config and runtime and use the provided proxy if it exists
4. Users may need to pass these environment variables into other applications if they do not natively take these variables
5. Action authors may need to update their workflows to react to these environment variables
6. We will document the way of setting environment variables for runners using the environment variables and how the runner uses them
7. Like all other secrets, users will be able to relatively easily figure out the proxy password if they can modify a workflow file running on a self-hosted machine