You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
ObjectID= 197
TitleID= 6,716 (someone printed the ID with a decimal separator, silly)
Title= From "Album Unique" formerly in the collection of the Duke of Portland
TitleTypeID= 4
TitleType= Group Title
DisplayOrder= 2
DataDate= 12/23/2015
cbm:object/197 crm:P102_has_title cbm:object/197/group_title,
cbm:object/197/primary_title, cbm:object/197/unknown_title_type.
cbm:object/197/group_title a crm:E35_Title;
crm:P1_is_identified_by cbm:object/197/group_title/id;
crm:P2_has_type cbm:object/197/title_type,
aat:300404670; # preferred name
rdf:value 'From "Album Unique" formerly in the collection of the Duke of Portland'.
cbm:object/197/title_type a crm:E55_Type;
skos:prefLabel "Group Title", "Primary Title".
cbm:object/197/group_title/id a crm:E42_Identifier
crm:P2_has_type aat:300404012; # unique identifier
rdf:value "6,716".
This mapping is badly botched. It has the following problems:
It uses TitleType in the title URL. But one object may have several titles of the same type, eg
The title type uses per-object URL cbm:object/197/title_type. This has 2 undesired consequences:
All titles of an object get all title types. Eg All titles are mapped as "primary" #50 complains that all titles become Primary Title (because all objects have such), and above you see both "Group Title" and "Primary Title"
The title types across objects use different nodes, so the fact that eg "Group Title" means the same across objects is not captured.
So instead, you should use a per-museum (not per-object) URL and use TitleType, eg:
cbm:title/group_title a crm:E55_Type;
skos:prefLabel "Group Title"
There is no need to tag cbm:object/197/group_title/id with aat:300404012 # unique identifier because see next.
Use crm:P48_has_preferred_identifier instead of crm:P1_is_identified_by.
aat:300404670 "preferred name" doesn't reflect the nature of the title (how is a Group Title a Preferred Name???), so remove it
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
LOD CBMAA Titles.csv
includes eg this record:It's converted to this (see http://data.americanartcollaborative.org/page/cbm/object/197/)
This mapping is badly botched. It has the following problems:
Object 45 has 3 Alternate Titles, so the result is this mixup you see at http://data.americanartcollaborative.org/page/cbm/object/45/alternate_title (1 title with 3 values).
Instead of TitleType, you should use TitleID in the URL
So instead, you should use a per-museum (not per-object) URL and use TitleType, eg:
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: